Tuesday 2 May 2023

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1961: Nakamura Ganjirō II in The End of Summer

Nakamura Ganjirō II did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Kohayagawa Manbei in The End of Summer.

The End of Summer depicts the relationships of a family underneath an unusual patriarch. 

The End of Summer offers a very different father figure than many films featured in Ozu's films which tend to be a bit self-sacrificing or a bit more reserved. Nakamura Ganjirō II offers a completely new type of father for Ozu's family this time around, and really a different type of presence from so many of his films. Ganjirō's performance offers a very different approach as he presents a man who isn't at all reserved as this business owner, who in many ways isn't at all concerned with the typical expectations of Japanese society, this rather is a man with different concerns. That main concern is the love of life. Ganjirō's performance exudes every pour of his performance as his bright smile is that of a man who just loves the experience of living and wishes to not hesitate in a moment in it. Ganjirō brings so much energy just innately within the character that is particularly dynamic, especially against the more reserved characters around him. He doesn't quite fit in and that is in just the right way in Ganjirō's performance as a man who may be the father of this family, however, he doesn't at all subscribe to the expectations of Japanese society. 

Where Ganjirō's performance is probably most essential is realizing Manbei's character as it relates to really his whole life, which involved being unfaithful to his wife, who is now deceased, and carrying on with his mistress. The mistress who is still living, and whom Ganjirō wants to continue to go see as much as possible it would seem. And it is here where it would be very easy to almost instantly lose any concern for the character, but what is impressive is that not only does he not make you dislike Manbei, he somehow makes him rather endearing. Perhaps if we saw him in his younger days going about this, that would be less sympathetic, but here as the older man Ganjirō brings so much life to his character as he goes about trying to sneak off whenever he can to go see his mistress again. Ganjirō's manner is filled with such a pleasant if not optimistic disposition about the whole thing though with this mischievous glint in his eyes. Ganjirō makes him scheming in a way, but scheming in a way with this kind of silliness about it that it is hard to take it fully seriously. In turn because of that Ganjirō makes it hard not to feel some affection for the old man going about this, even as what he is doing is technically an artifact of behavior that would've caused much grief for the family at one time. 

And what helps is when we see Ganjirō with his mistress, and her son, and he brings such a lively energy to it all. He's overflowing with warmth and affection, and it obviously isn't some simple carnal urge that Manbei finds in this relationship, it is genuine love that he portrays. What's great is how casual Ganjirō is in every moment of it, how natural it is, and just how earnest every moment of these interactions is. One can easily sense the rich history between them in these moments, which isn't at all built on expectation, but rather this very natural manner of just people who love the company of one another. Of course, those who feel a bit less positive about these interactions are the rest of his family, particularly his oldest daughter Fumiko (Michiyo Aratama). And their two interactions on this topic though aren't played as serious drama, but really rather hilarious comedy, as her incisive stares and cutting remarks, against his "aw shucks" reactions are quietly comic gold. As is Ganjirō's portrayal of every moment of Manbei sneaking away, where he truly shows him to be a child sneaking out to basically play with his friends, in his silly manner, which just is hard not to find a bit endearing coming from this older man. And while the concerns about Manbei's health end up bringing more dramatic elements of the film to the forefront, Ganjirō's performance never is weighed down by them, instead showing always, no matter his health, that Manbei's simply a man who is going to enjoy life his way, as long as he can. Nakamura Ganjirō II delivers just a splendid performance here, Ozu's oeuvre presents such a dynamic and unique father figure that contrasts so wonderfully with the typical patriarchs of his films. 

40 comments:

8000S said...

Louis: Your thoughts on Asakazu Nakai's work in this.

Bryan L. said...

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Bates
4. McKern
5. Ganjirō II

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

1. Stephens
2. Melvin
3. Bates
4. Ganjirō II
5. McKern

GM said...

1. Stephens
2. Bates
3. Melvin
4. Ganjirō II
5. McKern

Anonymous said...

Louis I forgot to mention this if you didn't already know but on Cittis review you didn't write that he was was nominated for the Bafta but are you somewhat surprised that he was?

Michael Patison said...

1. Martin Stephens
2. Murray Melvin
3. Alan Bates
4. Nakamura Ganjiro II
5. Leo McKern

Matt Mustin said...

1. Stephens
2. Melvin
3. Bates
4. Ganjiro
5. McKern

Calvin Law said...

Yeah just watched this and thought he was absolutely delightful, as was everyone else. And having watched them all now I'll do my predictions:

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

Tim said...

1) Melvin
2) Stephens
3) Bates
4) Ganjiro
5) McKern

Anonymous said...

Thoughts on the song "Boom Clap" from The Fault in Our Stars

Perfectionist said...

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

Luke Higham said...

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

BRAZINTERMA said...

5º Leo McKern
4º Alan Bates
3º Nakamura Ganjirō II
2º Murray Melvin
1º Martin Stephens

Calvin Law said...

Saw Guardians 3, which I really liked despite some expected issues (clunky pacing, Gunn can go too far with a joke that isn't clicking), what Gunn's good at is all there, pretty much everyone gets their time to shine, and the Rocket backstory stuff is particularly great.

Pratt - 4
Saldana - 3.5
Bautista - 4
Gillan - 4
Klementieff - 4
Cooper - 4
Gunn - 3
Poulter - 3.5
Iwuji - 3.5
Debicki - 3
Cardellini - 3.5

8000S said...

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

Luke Higham said...

Louis: Thoughts on the Dune Part II trailer.

Ytrewq Wertyq said...

It's kinda funny how in this picture Manbei looks as if he's playing videogames.

Tony Kim said...

Louis: What would be your past roles for Bill Hader, Jonathan Banks, and Rhea Seehorn?

Omar Franini said...

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

RatedRStar said...

I also saw Guardians 3, which does tug a little too hard on the heart strings if I am honest, especially since i recently saw MIGHTY MORPHIN POWER RANGERS: ONCE & ALWAYS, but it is still solid overall.

Louis Morgan said...

8000's:

Quietly vibrant work, that I will say one probably has to attribute the composition and framing to Ozu, as that is consistent across his films regardless of the cinematographer but here you do perhaps get just a touch more dynamic lighting than the color work of Late Autumn (though now dismissal there that is also a beautiful looking film), and Nakai does seem to make the most of the exterior shots granted to him, such as the ending precession and Manbai wandering through the town.

Anonymous:

No, because they did have some rather unique nominations via the "foreign actor" category, like Laydu, Shimura, and Mifune.

Luke:

I mean looks great as to be expected visually, so more than eager to see if Villeneuve can make the story land fully.

Tony:

Hader:

Eagon Spangler
Harry Roat
Johnny Smith

Banks:

Freddie Sykes
Lt. William F. Kinderman
Ira Wells

Seehorn:

Jane Craig
Marge Gunderson
Cecilia (The Purple Rose of Cairo)

RatedRStar said...

Louis: Did you ever watch the Might Morphin Power Rangers series? since I noticed you saw the motion picture, I just wondered if you liked the series in general since I would recommend the MIGHTY MORPHIN POWER RANGERS: ONCE & ALWAYS film/episode if you were a fan (it is surprisingly decent and nostalgic)

Matt Mustin said...

Louis: Thoughts on this? https://youtu.be/Xeqo93tC6Xk

8000S said...

Louis: What are your thoughts on Masayuki Mori as an actor? I feel like he's easily one of the most underrated actors of all time. There's such a chameleon-like quality to his performance.

Oh, and you can find this film where he's paired with Takamine from 1961 here (directed by Naruse of course)

https://ok.ru/video/2473025866350

8000S said...

*performances

Shaggy Rogers said...

I finished watching them all and I'm going to change the rank:

1. Melvin
2. Stephens
3. Ganjiro II
4. Bates
5. McKern

Robert MacFarlane said...

I saw Are You There God? It's Me, Margaret.

I'm going to be very, VERY annoying for the rest of the year trying to get Rachel McAdams an Oscar for this.

Michael McCarthy said...

1. Martin Stephens
2. Murray Melvin
3. Leo McKern
4. Nakamura Ganjiro II
5. Alan Bates

Anonymous said...

Louis: Your thoughts on this scene from The Thick of It?

https://youtu.be/K_FrQnQv0Vw

Tony Kim said...

Louis: What's the best performance you were introduced to through a request? Also, is there a single performance you've found the most difficult to write about?

Mitchell Murray said...

Robert: Initial thoughts on McAdams' performance, and where it stands amongst her career thus far?

This is coming from someone whose generally liked her better work, and on a personal connection, actually went to the same high school.

RatedRStar said...

Actually I might change my view on Guardians 3 from Solid to OK/Decent, everything I liked and disliked are unfortunately spoiler stuff.

Ytrewq Wertyq said...

Louis: Your past roles for Aaron Eckhart, Jackie Earle Haley and Jeffrey Dean Morgan?

Louis Morgan said...

Though Guardians 3 definitely could've been edited down a bit, or condensed a bit at the screenplay phase, the tonal shifts don't always feel completely natural and Gunn can occasionally overdo a joke (though thankfully never to the extent like Guardians 2 and thankfully the characters don't laugh at their own jokes this time around). Having said that, the film consistently engaged me, made me laugh and I did find the character material, particularly everything with Rocket, very moving. Even if a tighter work could've been produced, this one most certainly worked for me, and probably the most I've liked a Marvel movie in some time.

Basically concur with all of Calvin's ratings.

Louis Morgan said...

RatedRStar:

I did see some episodes of the oldest Power Rangers, but I can't say it was ever exactly "my bag" so to speak.

Matt:

I'll admit the Martin roasts always waver between a bit forced and genuinely funny. There's a little bit of the former there, but overall do enjoy Carney playing literally Norton for his bit, particularly including the two going right back into it for a second with the "get on with it".

8000's:

I believe I have given my thoughts on Norton previously.

Tony:

The former is a little hard just because I don't remember every performance that was a request. But *I think* Michael Redgrave in The Browning Version was, so maybe him.

As I've noted before *just fine* performances of actors I've covered before are usually the hardest to write about, and something I've tried to avoid after when I did a full lineup for the second 37 round because I just didn't have much to say about Fonda/Robinson or Donat there (and should've just reviewed Gabin and Colman), and I'll admit all three of those reviews were very hard to write about just because while good performances, there just wasn't much to be said about those performances from those performers.

Otherwise Adam Driver in Paterson, which I found easy once I chose the atypical review style, but that choice was necessary because I was struggling with how to come at describing the appeal of that performance in a straightforward way.

Ytrewq:

Eckhart:

Blake (Glengarry Glen Ross)
Arthur Reikle

Haley:

Hazel Motes
Burke (Blow Out)

Morgan:

Rumsfield (The 'burbs)
Butler (McCabe & Mrs. Miller)

8000S said...

Louis: You mean Mori.

Oh, aside from As a Wife, As a Woman, here's another Takamine movie to watch from 1961.

https://ok.ru/video/1611946003054

Make sure you watch both.

Tony Kim said...

Louis: Regarding your Freddie Sykes suggestion for Banks, did you mean Sykes from Twin Peaks? That's the only character that popped up when I Googled the name.

Also, have you thought of any jokes you found funny in comedies you otherwise didn't enjoy?

Ytrewq Wertyq said...

Tony: He meant Edmond O'Brien's character in The Wild Bunch.

Louis: Thoughts on this 2000s cast for Broadcast News and your choice for a director?

Aaron Eckhart as Tom Grunick
Matthew Perry as Aaron Altman
Rhea Seehorn as Jane Craig (breakout role)

Shaggy Rogers said...

Louis: Say which are the best performances and films that were directed by Ida Lupino?

Louis Morgan said...

Tony:

All of Sellers's bits - The Pink Panther (which dull outside of him)
Howard Cosell covering an assassination - Bananas
"I was trying to be funny" - Stardust Memories
Merv Griffin! - The Man With Two Brains
John Candy's bits - Splash
"In Banks" - Ritchie Rich
Blood Splatter - Dracula Dead and Loving It
Crane Fight - Life Stinks!
Nightmare - The Cable Guy
Train Peeking around the corner, John Walsh - Wrongfully Accused
"Maybe not that bad but still pretty bad" - Little Nicky
Jon Lovitz as Hitler - Rat Race
Hot Coffee - Death to Smoochy
Hoffman's Bits - Along Came Polly

Ytrewq:

Not entirely sure about Perry but certainly can see the other two with ease. Richard Linklater perhaps.

Shaggy:

I've seen two of her directed films so a bit of a shallow pool.