Sunday 25 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Results

10. Mads Mikkelsen in The Promised Land - Mikkelsen is ideal for the "western" lead here, playing stoic strength with ease, but then making such an impact as he reveals the hidden depths of the character. 

Best Scene: Reunion with Anmai. 
9. Michael Fassbender in The Killer - Fassbender covertly gives a hilarious portrayal of a man who believes himself to be the perfect assassin but is far from that. 

Best Scene: Poor estimate. 
8. Sōya Kurokawa in Monster - Kurokawa gives a dynamic portrait of the sides of the young boy we can't understand and slowly granting us that understanding with a real potent empathy. 

Best Scene: Playing it away. 
7. Charles Melton in May December - Melton seemingly is giving one performance as a man "content" in his existence and brings such a power to the crumbling away of that facade. 

Best Scene: Roof. 
6. Teo Yoo in Past Lives - Yoo gives a powerful though very subtle portrayal of the deep connections and romantic notions of a man who is separated by his love in more than one way. 

Best Scene: Bar.
5. Glenn Howerton in Blackberry - Howerton gives one of the most entertaining performances of the year by going all in portraying a business shark without a hint of shame. 

Best Scene: Doing it all in one day. 
4. Zac Efron in The Iron Claw - Efron gives a powerful portrayal of relatively simple man bottling up his emotions until they finally pour out. 

Best Scene: "I used to be a brother"
3. Andrew Scott in All of Us Strangers - Scott gives a heartbreaking portrayal of a man re-experiencing his grief and the complicated relationship with his parents in a most unusual way. 

Best Scene: Talk with dad.
2. Dominic Sessa in The Holdovers - Sessa gives an all time great debut, that avoids all the pitfalls of his role, while thriving in the risks he takes to give an entertaining and very moving performance. 

Best Scene: "I was going to say the same thing"
1. Kōji Yakusho in Perfect Days - Yakusho gives a perfect, often silent, performance that just embodies so much of the human experience, despite being also so very specific. 

Best Scene: Playing with shadows. 
Overall:
  1. Cillian Murphy in Oppenheimer
  2. Kōji Yakusho in Perfect Days
  3. Dominic Sessa in The Holdovers
  4. Andrew Scott in All of Us Strangers
  5. Paul Giamatti in The Holdovers
  6. Zac Efron in The Iron Claw
  7. Glenn Howerton in Blackberry
  8. Teo Yoo in Past Lives
  9. Charles Melton in May December
  10. Sōya Kurokawa in Monster - 5
  11. Michael Fassbender in The Killer
  12. Mads Mikkelsen in The Promised Land
  13. Benoît Magimel in The Taste of Things
  14. Manolo Solo in Close Your Eyes
  15. Eita Nagayama in Monster
  16. Jeffrey Wright in American Fiction
  17. Jason Clarke in The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial
  18. Nicolas Cage in Dream Scenario
  19. Joaquin Phoenix in Beau is Afraid
  20. Peter Sarsgaard in Memory
  21. Byung-hun Lee in Concrete Utopia
  22. Christopher Abbott in Sanctuary
  23. Song Kang-ho in Cobweb
  24. Jussi Vatanen in Fallen Leaves
  25. Joel Edgerton in Master Gardner
  26. Tom Blyth in The Hunger Games: The Ballad of Songbirds & Snakes
  27. Michael B. Jordan in Creed III - 4.5
  28. Enzo Vogrincic in Society of The Snow 
  29. Gael Garcia Bernal in Cassandro
  30. Alberto Ammann in Upon Entry
  31. Anthony Hopkins in One Life
  32. Chris Pine in Dungeons & Dragons: Honor Among Thieves
  33. Franz Rogowski in Passages
  34. Harris Dickinson in Scrapper
  35. Barry Keoghan in Saltburn
  36. Christian Friedel in The Zone of Interest
  37. Michael Caine in The Great Escaper
  38. Dave Bautista in Knock At the Cabin
  39. Seydou Sarr in Io Capitano
  40. Riz Ahmed in Fingernails
  41. Alexander Skarsgård in Infinity Pool
  42. Soma Santoki in The Boy and the Heron
  43. Jay Baruchel in Blackberry
  44. Deniz Celiloğlu in About Dry Grasses
  45. Colman Domingo in Rustin 
  46. Thomas Schubert in Afire
  47. David Jonsson in Rye Lane
  48. Chris Pratt in Guardians of the Galaxy Vol. 3 
  49. Saleh Bakri in The Blue Caftan
  50. Shameik Moore in Spider-man: Across The Spider-Verse
  51. Tobias Menzies in You Hurt My Feelings
  52. Kelvin Harrison Jr. in Chevalier 
  53. Benedict Cumberbatch in The Wonderful World of Henry Sugar
  54. Paul Dano in Dumb Money
  55. Tom Cruise in Mission Impossible: Dead Reckoning - 4
  56. Taron Egerton in Tetris  
  57. Jake Lacy in The Caine Mutiny Court-Martial
  58. Johnny Flynn in One Life
  59. Keanu Reeves in John Wick Chapter 4 
  60. Nicolas Cantu in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem
  61. Brady Noon in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem
  62. Shamon Brown Jr. in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem
  63. Micah Abbey in Teenage Mutant Ninja Turtles: Mutant Mayhem
  64. Mamoudou Athie in Elemental
  65. Matt Damon in Air 
  66. Michael Fassbender in Next Goal Wins
  67. Kenneth Branagh in A Haunting in Venice
  68. Corey Hawkins in The Last Voyage of the Demeter
  69. Jorma Tommila in Sisu
  70. Park Seo-joon in Concrete Utopia
  71. Ralph Fiennes in Ratcatcher
  72. Timothee Chalamet in Wonka
  73. Jaime Vadell in El Conde
  74. John Boyega in They Cloned Tyrone 
  75. Adam Driver in Ferrari - 3.5
  76. Ryunosuke Kamiki in Godzilla Minus One
  77. Ethan Hwang in Riceboy Sleeps
  78. Dohyun Noel Hwang in Riceboy Sleeps
  79. Zachary Levi in Chicken Run: Rise of the Nuggets
  80. Denzel Washington in The Equalizer 3
  81. Joel Edgerton in The Boys in the Boat
  82. Paul Rudd in Ant-Man & The Wasp: Quantumania 
  83. Ezra Miller in The Flash - 3
  84. Jason Schwartzman in Asteroid City
  85. Harrison Ford in Indiana Jones and the Dial of Destiny
  86. Vin Diesel in Fast X 
  87. Rupert Friend in The Swan - 2.5
  88. Leonardo DiCaprio in Killers of the Flower Moon
  89. Ben Aldridge in Knock At the Cabin
  90. Michael A. Goorjian in Amerikatsi
  91. Callum Turner in The Boys in the Boat
  92. John David Washington in The Creator - 2
  93. Bradley Cooper in Maestro - 1.5
  94. Charlie Day in Fool's Paradise 
  95. Ken Jeong in Fool's Paradise - 1
Next: 1945 lead, though will be on break until the Oscars. 

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Teo Yoo in Past Lives

Teo Yoo did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite being nominated for a BAFTA, for portraying Hae Sung in Past Lives. 

Past Lives tells the three phases of the relationship between Nora (Greta Lee), a Korean woman who moves to America with her parents and her old childhood crush from Korea. 

Teo Yoo plays first the college age Hae Sung, and it has to be said that both he and Lee are great in playing this age, technically with slight changes in appearance but more important is the vibe of their performance. There's a lack of maturity just innately in their manner in general, as they have the mix between the adult and still sort of breezy kind of childlike approach as we see the two in this phase in their lives. Their interaction here though is mainly through literally skype, and in their performances, what they give very much are performances befitting the skype call as compared to how we see them briefly in their personal lives, which again has that specific kind of untamed energy. Anyway the two link up, after their childhood pseudo romance, to talk again over the internet, where the performances beyond the age setting, which isn't something you even think about when watching the film, very much contain that specific approach in these conversations. As both performers are unnatural, in their naturalism, and by that what they do is that sort of awkwardness initially of the skype call, where there are the breaks in conversation from it, sometimes just due to lag, but more than anything this kind of way of monologuing a little bit of their lives due to the nature of it. We see that as each speaks with sincere enthusiasm towards their interests, hers art, his engineering, where both performers show the respectable give and take between their performances. They are interested in their way, but there is a certain presentation of this as well, as showing enthusiasm, not fakely, just in the skype way of making sure your emotions are seen. 

The skype call begins very gently as both performers speak with at first certain hesitations then more of a natural cadence slowly builds in their performances, as they each become more comfortable in sharing themselves as they go along. The key moments in this, is each speaks with interest in their lives and a calmness about them even. When each suggests a change in that, which would be one visiting the other, every time they ask "Why would I visit said country/city". Both performers again play this absolutely beautifully because they both say it as a question to be answered but also the answer. In that the delivery articulates this kind of sense of the lack of interest in separating themselves from their current existences though leaving something open in the pause. Something that we do in the suggestion when either suggests the invite with a similarly calm way that is trying to persuade them to come though again the delivery is revealing what they're saying while also hiding what they're saying. Neither is completely open in their performances, they're close to it, but they're just not quite there. The connection is there, but so is the disconnect in every one of these interactions, even as the skype awkwardness diminishes after a while, they still aren't quite directly as one. What we see is the possibility, but that possibility but also not quite being enough. And so far, I'm referring to the performances together, because they are so together in representing this state as one, even if separated in their place, and the two are as one in their moments of nostalgia, enjoying each other's company in conversation, and learning about one another, but also as one in keeping that certain barrier up. 

Their conversations end as neither takes the next step in terms of overtly saying they'd give up their current life for the other, and we leap 12 more years, and that is where the performances branch off fully between Lee and Yoo. Yoo we come back into, and again it is impressive is how much he is the "man" now compared to the younger man coming into his own previously. Again it is just a little less in terms of his physical manner that he creates just the sense of maturity in his movements and manner. It isn't anything showy, it is just something convincing that Yoo brings, and worth noting so does Lee, that we completely sense the change in time because we so clearly see the change in them. There is more though however to Yoo as we see him as the older man, successful enough, though living with his parents, which isn't out of the ordinary for Korea, however we do see a man very much more isolated. We see kind of a manner as he seems closed off a bit, even with his friends here, or with his parents, or even the brief glimpse we get of the man in any attempted romance. Yoo shows definitely more than a shield as we see an innate shyness in the man as part of who he is, and very much this quiet sense of isolation in Korea. Yoo doesn't present this as seething sorrow, but it is definitely something very direct and real as part of his existence. It is something he wears as he walks around and he shows absolutely a lonely man in Hae Sung. Although I wouldn't describe Yoo's performance as sad, it is hard not to feel a bit of sadness in seeing him go along as he did, as this solo man, clearly without a fundamental connection in his life. 

The true heart of the piece therefore comes in as he visits America to see Nora, who has now married the American Arthur (John Magaro) and seems happy enough in her success and her life as an American and New Yorker. Nonetheless she agrees to meet Hae Sung despite the two having ended on a note of that disconnection. And now the performances are great in the difference between them, despite the chemistry of their work. The chemistry which is palatable, we see particularly a fundamental shift that Yoo brings in showing that Hae Sung now doesn't have that air of loneliness anymore when he is with Nora. He's much more open and frankly there's just an innate cheer in his face as we see a man truly just unabashedly enjoying his time with her. I think what Yoo does so well is create the specific confines of this relationship and what it means for Hae Sung. As Yoo strikes probably the most ideal balance in creating the sense of love without suggesting anyone with truly any devious notions. Rather what Yoo does that is particularly fascinating is this kind of innocence in his performance that is rather beautifully performed because it really has two separate but pivotal impacts. The first being this innocence immediately disarms you from ever thinking that Hae Sung has any true ill-designs within this relationship, but also in a way shows more of the appeal for Nora to him as in a way, that never feel petulant or arrested development, is kind of the boy she once had a crush on in this way. Yoo finds this specific quality in his face that brings this special kind of manner that never feels unrealistic, but rather just naturally to the sense of the man who is this hopeless romantic, which in a way even accepts Nora's marriage as part of that. 

Yoo approaches each scene between them with this seeming sense of the romantic who is true to his heart, and in a way both completely open in his love for her, while also being respectful entirely with her love for her husband. A balance that perhaps shouldn't work, or at least should perhaps seem illogical, yet the way Yoo plays every moment of this, it just seems to make all the sense in the world. When for example he asks about Nora and Arthur sometimes fighting, Yoo's delivery is key because it could seem some kind of snipping at the relationship but how Yoo speaks the line is that of genuine curiosity. Curiosity that is part of the overall sense of discovery in his performance as he goes along exploring New York and America with her where Yoo brings always that quiet sense of appreciation for the time and the company as it is. We have the moments of him just appreciating the sights with her in this way and creating always this innate fascination with everything that Nora is. Yoo never overdoing this to being creepy though rather the right sense of earnestness to each interaction that creates a particularly moving portrayal of a man appreciating the woman without seeming aggressive in this way. Perhaps part of that is that obviously Nora is always speaking her mind, including noting his romantic sensibilities are what might keep him from being married, something where Yoo has this quiet sort of resignation about it, just as he also speaks about himself in not completely degrading way, but in a way of assuming himself to be just a bit less than he is. Again it's all in the exact delivery, because this could be miserable pathos tweaked one way or another, but Yoo finds just the right tone to make a natural expression of the man understanding his position in life, while accepting the challenge of it, maybe not loving that, but not hating it either. 

As beautifully done as the scenes of Nora and Hae Sung's "dates" are, which are as much made up in just the moments of glances and silences, which are pitch perfect in the sense of the history between the two and the sense of the "almost" within that. Neither is projecting lust, or some sense that either is going to suddenly run away with the other, but what you can't help but sense is the poignancy of the completely uncomplicated affection that does exist between them even as they must exist on their chosen path rather than the path together they very easily might've had. There is most certainly something there as they look at each other silently, but part of what is there is the knowledge that what is there cannot ever be more than that. I think the most dynamic scenes are the ending of the film where Hae Sung, Nora and Arthur go out together. It is a fascinating relationship that we see between the three of them in this situation that is something particularly special. Yoo in his delivery with Lee changes it a touch, as he speaks almost in this secret language to her, secret because Arthur really doesn't know it, and there is a kind of playfulness that Yoo brings at times as almost the old friend messing while hanging out with the new friend. It again is so deftly handled by Yoo he never seems weird in this approach but rather grants you a sense of their specific history as he does ask her why she hasn't gone to the Statue of Liberty with her husband. Yoo is so great though because even in these playful moments the sincerity of his performance is what shines through in granting a sense of needed honesty to this kind of ribbing while also reaffirming the connection he does share with Nora despite the distance of their relationship. And it is important to note the moments between Hae Sung and Arthur, albeit brief they are important. As both do have a certain awkwardness in their interactions with Yoo bringing the humbleness in his initial introduction, and then in their moment together, after a long night with Nora, Yoo and Magaro have a certain shakiness in their interactions, however still there is a special kind of sincerity as the two wish each other well regardless. They still always evoke that they are working in this strange space as they are, but as both actors present the men as trying to make the situation as ideal as possible even if definitely out of the ordinary. I particularly love the moment where Hae Sung says even they share connection, which Yoo again doesn't make it some over the top sell or even obfuscation of his intention rather genuine direct care towards the other man. The final moment between Hae Sung and Nora is almost just a silent goodbye, which is again tender, yet also complicated in the two clearly sharing much albeit in this very specific way. With their final words being acceptance of their choices and Yoo's delivery of it containing that complicated feeling of the could've been, but with this poignant contentment of someone who has also accepted things as they are. This is a truly great performance by Teo Yoo, that exists in such a subdued yet always resonate space, that crafts the journey not out of the big moments, but rather the gentle silences that denote such profound and fundamental connections. 

Friday 23 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Kōji Yakusho in Perfect Days

Kōji Yakusho did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite winning CANNES, for portraying Hirayama in Perfect Days.
 
Perfect Days follows a sanitation attendant through a week in his life. 

The last time I watched a film with Kōji Yakusho in it, it was the horrifying film Cure, so quite a shift in tones as I come into his work here as the attendant of the many public bathrooms of Tokyo. A performance that seems like all performance, while also being no performance, seemingly no great importance in what it is exploring, but also massive importance. And what I mean by all this, is the majority of this performance is just seeing a man going about his day of doing a job faithfully and consistently, listening to oldies (only when driving not while working), having lunch, taking the occasional picture of light coming through trees, visiting restaurants and occasionally some plant rescue. All of this is pretty just things that people do, given intimate detail by director Wim Wenders, with a focus being the whole notion of appreciating the day of this man. Yakusho's performance is just going through this action as Hirayama, who for much of the early scenes barely says a word, and we just see him living his life in the simplest sense of that idea. So what is the performance then? Well, it is kind of everything even the whole notion of it is also being absolutely nothing in terms of noticeable performance, just being as his, and as a performance. No more, no less. 

A person just existing may seem like an easy task to one who has never seen deadly dull performances of the ilk, so one must credit the specificity of the action, the editing and Yakusho's performance that the most mundane of moments are absolutely captivating here. Yakusho as the man about his job has a monk-like dedication as we see him go about every little segment of each bathroom with clear attention to detail and this focus. The man is here to do his job, and to do it right. There's ease in his action, even when dealing with less than ideal situations, like a man kicking over his caution sign without picking it up, Yakusho's performance shows Hirayama makes no particular note of it, he just keeps working. Even the nonsensical behavior of his far less focused co-worker, Yakusho shows a man not phased much by his less than stellar performance, rather just the conviction within his own work where everything is an exact task he will go about as a true professional. There's a minor slight disbelieving glance when his coworker is on his phone when doing the job, but even so he stays true and direct. Yakusho makes something wonderful about just a man doing his job, and in this case cleaning filth, that is wonderfully admirable as showing a man who is able to do it with a considerable ease in spirit. 

And perhaps we see the nature of the man most in the moments where he is not working, which big and small speak so loudly through honest poignancy realized in Yakusho's performance. Which is never cloying or forced in the idea of calm, it is just calm in a way that is mesmerizing in its way by how generous and pure it all seems. Take the first time someone ends the bathroom while he's working, which he quickly steps out for the minutes he needs to before proceeding again. Yakusho's performance as the man waiting isn't that of a man being impatient or annoyed by the moment; rather, you see him instead look up and take a moment in. And Yakusho's entirely wonderful in the way he makes this so genuine in the way Hirayama enjoys the little moments in life even as a quick respite between working, he still finds something worthwhile by just taking in the life around him. When we see him in lunch break, again we see the man just enjoying what he can, breathing in nature, taking in the sights he can see, and just finding the beauty of living in a way that feels so naturally earned through the delicate ease of Yakusho's performance. Although much of his reactions are specific, never do they feel as such as we just see him being him in a way that is entirely true to just being. 

When not working we see the man go about his day in a similar way that is built on routines, though this isn't about doldrums, rather it is about appreciation of these moments in fact. Take particularly when we see his hobby of saving interesting plants by picking them up and then planting them in his home garden. Yakusho makes the big statements so often not by saying anything at all, but also by his expression being equally quiet. He's not making big mime gestures, rather he's granting insight in such an easy way of a man who is very calm even in his expressiveness. But in this making the expressions he does have such a power to them, such as the generous pride we see in the slight smile as he goes about tending his garden clearly with a sense of love for this hobby. And there is the almost indescribable brilliance at times, of just little things he does, moving his fan from him to another, glancing at a rainstorm, enjoying his bath, getting a quick bit of excitement from a reaction to a baseball game all shouldn't exactly be captivating but they are. And again it isn't by Yakusho forcing us to enjoy his company, it just seems impossible to not enjoy it. What his performance is generous in spirit, in the way of inviting us in, though inviting us in the kind of purest empathy of showing a human trying just to be human. But always key to this, is basically showing that this is something worthwhile even in its seeming simplicity. 

After the first day what we examine between the routine mostly are what are the changes that he undergoes. Some changes are pretty minor, like a sincere bit of fun with playing a quick game of ongoing tic tac toe with an unknown user of the bathroom, but some are more substantial like when Hirayama ends up getting pulled into his coworkers fairly weak attempt to try woo a woman. And we get some great comedy as Hirayama's routine is disrupted by this and he's literally stuffed into the back of his own car as the younger pair pilot his car and his radio. As much as it is a sillier setup Yakusho's marvelous in the same way, but a new way. Same way in that this just the character so naturally, so remarkably, but what's new is what we see more of the man as he engages within the situation. He's funny as he makes sure they don't break his tapes as they use them, as well as just his general expression of quietly observing the situation, being awkward in a certain sense, while trying to be as natural as he can. Yakusho just being a joy to watch explore the scene, because we too are exploring with him in this interaction, and he's completely lovely in also bringing this ease of warmth when he admires the young woman's appreciation for his taste in music or even more so his extremely endearing head-shaking in just reflecting on this interaction. 

The button on that scene is the young woman bringing back one of the tapes she borrowed to hear it one more time, and Yakusho articulating the right sort of sense of connection and disconnection at the same time. Awkward but with understanding and like most scenes just watch what Yakusho is doing and there's so much life in there. Yakusho suggests life experience even when not saying it as the young woman ponders her own experiences and anguish it seems, with Yakusho being calm in his care and understanding. With the unexpected kiss on the cheek though being a tremendous scene by the perfectly acted moment by Yakusho of the genuine surprise of the older man who can take it as anything but something to be appreciated and a bit taken aback by. But tis the philosophy of this man it would seem who just is taking all as it is, and as much as he's a hard working man it seems life, even frequently alone, is east through the sense of appreciation for it that fills the scenes. Yakusho's performance is one of amplification in silence so often, that it is about as remarkable as it comes in the way he articulates the way of the man. Whether it be reading a book with interest, or just taking a moment to appreciate a live performance of a bar owner, with the deepest care that has such a tremendous power in his reaction because it speaks so strongly to the philosophy of the man. 

Of course who this man was before this point in his life, well we finally figured some of that out when his niece unexpectedly turns up on his doorstep after running away from home. Yakusho is outstanding in seeing here because he again couldn't be more genuine in granting an immediate sense of history as he looks in confusion at first but then slowly this loving realization of his family along with the years that have gone by in his delivery of her name. We now see the break in the routine and Yakusho is fantastic in being different, though still so natural, in showing the man with a bit more required self-awareness as he now knows he's being watched by his niece. Yakusho now does things with a bit more of a rush at times, a bit more of a show as he attempts to in a way now do his routine while presenting his routine to his niece. It isn't this painstaking difference, but subtle in Yakusho's performance that shows a break in his equilibrium. Not an unpleasant break mind you, but a break from it. Even though he has a moment where he's a bit more self-aware in the way he goes about his apartment now, we also see the poignant warmth as he goes about sharing his experience with his niece. Bringing the sense of an innate love even when needing to fumble about a bit such as ask what shop "spotify" is, bringing the natural humor of the man of his generation with an elegant purity to  Hirayama absolutely just being who he is as he is. 

We have such moments of tender beauty, such as when Hirayama shows off his old camera with that certain easy pride of a man who just loves to do things his way, while also being taken aback as she shows off a gift he once gave her to which he has no memory but attempts to put on the grace of an uncle about it. With their being the most pleasant of suggestions of this relationship as you see the connection of long ago, even as again she kind of questions his state, such as his tree picture taking and there is again something so special in the sincerity of Yakusho's smile at the very idea of the question. Yakusho's performance expresses itself in new ways even as consistent in his ways, as we see the man with specific familial connection, and it is fascinating. As despite the man always being alone, you never sense him being truly lonely, but what Yakusho presents in these scenes is that while the man isn't desperate for the connection the appreciation for such a connection isn't something he'd ever hide. With Yakusho so honestly creating the years of separation in the emphasis on the certain discovery, but so much the real love in the brightness of his smile every time she indicates she always wanted to see him again, even if he might not be able to fully decipher the reason immediately. 
 
We have probably one of the longest talking scenes up till this point in the film as Hirayama briefly comments on the relationship between himself and his sister. Yakusho is truly amazing in this scene as we get Hirayama's simple yet profound statements in the nature of there being different worlds for different people to explore, and he and his sister are in two different worlds in that respect. It isn't with heartache Yakusho speaks the words, nor pompous disregard, rather a concise understanding of where this man finds his happiness in his life. The next moment is even more tremendous of a moment, as modest as Yakusho's delivery is, as the niece asks about the next time they'll meet and Hirayama simply says "next time is next time" "today is today". Yakusho speaks with the utmost conviction albeit also so gently in his way, and really with such a sense of jubilation that it is hard not to be inspired to take his the idea he's projecting to heart. As you see in his voice, in his eyes, and his whole demeanor that this is fundamental to the man, and his belief in life, which we have seen throughout the film up until this point, we just didn't realize it. His scene with his sister perhaps speaks even more to the man, as she comes to pick up her daughter from him. It's an extraordinary scene because both actors immediately, you know these two are siblings, not the closest, but you do sense the ease of siblings, even as they exist in "different worlds" as he describes it. And you do see the different worlds, just as you see the history, as he smiles with such a brotherly smile as she brings him his favorite chocolate as a thank you, but you do see the separate world as she asks if he's really cleaning toilets with a bit of judgment, to where we see in Yakusho a man without a shame a man who is who he is and will be that. But in their final embrace, no more words, but the connection is fundamental, is truly deeply felt, and you do see understanding even if still separation. With one of the most emotional moments from Yakusho words, which speaks volumes from his reserve, as we do see a bit of sorrow as he breaks down briefly, where even in acceptance in his relationship Yakusho naturally reveals, acceptance doesn't mean sadness can't exist within that.

We continue another the break in the routine, in what perhaps speaks most strongly about the idea of appreciating the little things, can sometimes not even be enough, when you are overworked to the bone and not allowed to appreciate them. As Yakusho's co-worker quits with little notice leaving the man to do the most evil of punishments...the regrettable double shift. And within this sequence we see that his equilibrium being broken, by being asked to do more than he should in all rights have to do, shows the man still working diligently, but now instead of a profession he's truly just doing his job as an overworked job. He's moving around just to do things, just going from place to place, there's no calm, there's no focus in the job, but most of all we see that he can't take those seconds to appreciate life because he only has more and more work to do. Yakusho shows perhaps so simply this pain in this by showing us the natural joy the man finds in life being lost, and replaced with annoyed frustration at this state. Leaving his exasperated delivery of needing his bosses to find someone, as the man truly having enough when far too much is being asked of him. 

True to form, when he gets a new coworker the next day, peace can be found, and honestly it's hard not to feel the same immense relief that Hirayama feels. We have the final break that occurs by accident, as he stumbles into a bar at the wrong time, to find the owner and a man embracing, causing Hirayama to run off. Great acting by Yakusho in just completely embodying many of what many have also had, which is the "ooh didn't mean to step into a personal moment, I will try to erase myself from existence as quickly as possible". That's not the break actually, rather the break is when the man (Tomokazu Miura), misinterpreting Hirayama's quick exit, tracks down Hirayama to try to explain the situation, as the man thought Hirayama might've had some closer relationship with the bar owner, which he did not. What follows is just an extraordinary scene, and one of the very best of 2023. Yakusho begins in just being taken aback a little confused by the sudden appearance but welcoming enough as he can be, as the man asks for cigarette off of him, before inquiring more, where Yakusho grants Hirayama just the perfect look of a man who just is trying not to focus too much on his accidental embarrassment. The man reveals himself to be her ex-husband, which you see the tension of trying to be a distant stay in Yakusho, until the man reveals that he is dying of cancer. Yakusho gives one of the most beautiful portrayals of human empathy as his face falls in hearing this news, losing the awkwardness and switching to trying to now immediately find some kind of connection as he offers the man a beer and a bit of friendship. Yakusho being so wonderful in the way he just listens to the man, even if he has to gently explain he's not in any relationship with his ex wife, and exudes just the utmost generous warmth in his endearing smile towards the man. 
 
A smile that comes as the man ponders if shadows get darker when on top of each other, to which Yakusho invites the man over to check, and well Yakusho portrays it as though Hirayama has become a boy who found a friend to play with on a playground. Bringing this perfect combination of the weight of what he just heard but this energy of a man trying to bring a bit of happiness to another in such a desperate time. When both men start trying to jump on each other's shadows, the chemistry and the connection couldn't feel more honest or natural, and couldn't be more heartwarming. As both actors are just kids again in the moment, and in that you see the men be able to share in a simple joy of life, if for a minute, but what an essential minute that is. Yakusho's performance here is masterful in a way that you don't often see, but when you do it is a treasure to behold. As it is completely effortless, never do you feel performance or look at performance. It isn't a performance about accents or the most extreme moments of human condition. It is a performance about the human condition, capturing in a way few performances do, by making every little gesture, every reaction and every interaction something special and a pleasure to behold in itself. And this review simply wouldn't be complete if I didn't mention his final scene, of Hirayama starting his week again by driving to his job early in the morning while listening to his music and seemingly taking a moment for reflection on what it means to be human. Yakusho's expression of Hirayama in this moment in a way seems to express it all, as there is the bitter with the sweet, joy with the sorrow, intense happiness, with tragedy as Yakusho seems to go through almost every emotion between that gap of sadness and jubilation. With such a fundamental ease in his performance that it is just particularly stunning bit of acting, particularly at the very end where he in the same expression you see tremendous joy with tremendous sadness, which doesn't feel contrived, doesn't feel forced, rather it feels just like the truth of what any one of us can experience, expressed with the utmost perfection from a performer. Perfection because never does it feel like acting, it just is, is in a way that is this whole performance, that can bring every one of us into a singular life of an elderly Japanese man cleaning toilets and not make it remotely foreign but rather profoundly universal.

Tuesday 20 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Glenn Howerton in Blackberry

Glenn Howerton did not receive an Oscar nomination because the Academy is IDIOT SAVAGES, despite being nominated for an Independent Spirit Award and a few critic's awards, for portraying Jim Balsillie in Blackberry.
 
Blackberry depicts the rise and fall of the company that invented the first smartphone.
 
It is with much pleasure that I can finally review Glenn Howerton for a performance, as I have always been a champion of his all time great comedic work on It's Always Sunny in Philadelphia, so to see him find a decent role, and then excel at it feels like vindication. And excel he does as the CEO of the company invited on hesitantly by the more tech minded Mike Lazaridis (Jay Baruchel) to run the company on the business side of things. Howerton of course has a powerful golden god-esque presence to begin with but importantly what he is doing here is crafting a particular character here that is making use of his talents we know him for but directed in the right way to become this guy. This guy that Howerton sets up as specifically a shark in the business world whose methods are that of basically personal force more than anything and his ability to try to guess the worst intentions of others, since he himself often would pick those intentions. Howerton in the early scenes portraying Balsillie as the man with the aggressively specific intention and his eyes are that of a predator looking for some sort of opportunity for gain, watching for it, in order for him to be able to strike. His performance works particularly effectively as contrast to the meek Baruchel and Mike's goofy second Doug (Matt Johnson), where Howerton presents everything as man whose mind is for success without caring who he has to figuratively murder for them to advance. A man who unlike them isn't lost in anything other than making sure he can make it unquestionably to the top.
 
I think something important that Howerton does is that he basically utilizes what he is known for to enliven the work but doesn't allow it to pigeonhole the performance into the wrong kind of genre of performance. Howerton as a comedic performer often is the one making things funny merely by the nature of his performance and his very specific line delivery and intensity of his performance. That is here, and this is a very entertaining performance as he is the colossal ball buster and vicious businessman who seems like a tornado through the sloppy world of Mike's nerd infested company. Howerton's a hoot every second he comes in and so directly cuts through every scene with the man demanding action from them without hesitation or reservation in regards to how they might feel about it. He's fun to watch, but he also does two important things to really keep it from just becoming a one note caricature rather than an extreme character. One is that Howerton's intensity is with specific intention towards showing the way the man's intensity is always attached to making things happen and for success. He's a  man who is pretty heightened all the time, but he's not always at 11. Howerton goes to 11 at the right moments where you see it basically as the man's arsenal to launch his attacks in order to either get his company to actual work for him, or to try to come basically to present arms with like minded business centric men who he knows how to battle and in what ways.
 
The other is that Howerton is not always that specific intensity that is outward, though he presents Balsillie as always a pretty intense guy, he balances it with moments that does give the right hints to the character as a man even if it isn't something he wants to show frequently. When for example early on he goes to the bank to find his investment was immediately used for debt, Howerton shows a disbelief as the man can be lost. Or later when he admits to having lost his job before joining their company and having mortgaged his house to support this endeavor. Howerton brings just a hint of vulnerability fitting a man who has no desire to show it whatsoever, but it is there as cut-throat as he can be. Howerton makes the most though in balancing it to grant nuance to his performance. Which also is in even the business side of the character where Howerton is great in showing the different methods of the man which are not singular to his more aggressive style which we specifically see when either motivating or in direct conflict with someone. As we see when he first pitches the phone, Howerton brings a more persuasive force where he accentuates all the positives and presents a more open quality as the man trying to sway the people to his sale. Or when we see him play against a more powerful shark in the CEO of Palmpilot, Howerton brings it in to play the seeming submissive as eloquently as the shark, in bringing the sense of subterfuge as just a natural part of his arsenal.
 
Howerton very much carries the film as we follow the Blackberry in its success streak, though seemingly battling one crisis after another, including an attempted hostile takeover, where Balsillie will build up no matter what even when the tech may not be able to handle it. Howerton brings an appropriate for a Safdie film type of locked-in conviction of his performance to go from one problem to another to keep selling everything. Where Howerton is the pressure cooker performance and is captivating every second of it. Part of this is including his anger, which let's be honest here Howerton plays anger perhaps better than almost anyone if he is able to do it in a way that is hilarious while also being completely convincing in its viciousness. Which is entirely ideal here as he brings such a perfect kind of shamelessness consistently as Balsillie does whatever he can to try to keep Blackberry on top. Which we naturally get great moments of him going about his negotiations where Howerton's expression is always just focused on the goal not on anything else, as he speaks to offering millions of dollars to get the right engineers, he speaks just whatever it takes, including illegal stock offers, which Howerton presents as just another weapon for him to use no more than no less. Meanwhile bringing only the most direct wraith on his own staff when anything goes wrong, and Howerton is hilarious yet also convincing in just presenting it as the innate nature of the man whenever anything is less than perfect. Although I love just the bits of balance, such as when the engineers do present him with a great idea, the jubilation in his voice is just as sincere, if entirely related to clearly the money he is about to make. 

The last act, which I would say is the weakest act of the film, where the company is scrambling to deal with the Iphone, and I say that in that I think there just needed to be a little more of just minor respite to indicate their top of the world status, if even just for one complete scene. I just think this would've helped tee up just a little more of them becoming potentially somewhat overly comfortable in their position to get blindsided as they do, as we jump into Balsillie as he seems more concerned with buying, and secretly moving a hockey team rather than dealing with the company. Howerton regardless though is still great in the scenes of him maneuvering this deal as basically just another target with just this nonchalant and shameless brandishing of his power now. Still just a mesmerizing performance in itself, as we see Balsillie's last day presented essentially as he attempts to figure out how the Iphone is going to work with so much data use, while trying to close the deal on his hockey team and avoiding the investigation into his illegal stock sales. Howerton naturally goes one step beyond the 11 to bring all of it into this final sequence of just the man going as far as he can all at once, and again he is simply fun to watch nearly lose it in this section. Primarily when we see the NHL denies his purchase deal for having boasted about his plans to move it, where Howerton naturally brings Balsillie a bit lost for words in seeing his lack of shame coming to bite him before backpedalling towards his usual choice of intense anger. I will say this is the one time where I perhaps saw more Dennis than Balsillie, as he delivers the ridiculous line at the NHL which is that he is "From Waterloo where the Vampires hang out" as some kind of warning but I'll let him have it. As one he has to sell an absurd line, so perhaps going all in in this way into his "training" for selling insane lines is the way to go, and two he manages to make it work just by going for it as he does. What I like though is that after this we finally see the man lose steam which Howerton portrays as the collapse of the man's confidence as he first hears the plan to make the Iphone work as crushing and then finds out that Mike is giving him up to the FTC. Howerton plays it as basically this state of exhaustion with a hint of almost this kind of admiring surprise as he sees Mike finally assuming the role of the shark, that he had always played, and portrays the accepting disbelief of Balsillie in the moment beautifully. Balsillie is finally a man lost for words, and Howerton earns that by creating this final depletion of that fire that energized him, and perhaps he exhausted in his hockey purchase failure. And I won't lie this whole performance I got a kick out of, one it was proof of something I already knew, however proof in the form of a consistently captivating, entertaining and altogether compelling portrait of drive for success regardless of cost, a performance that remembers the essential traits of a great performance:
Demonstrate character in every action.
Elevate the dialogue.
Nuance should be utilized appropriately.
Navigate tone. 
Invigorate the audience.
Service the material.
(For the Five Star Man) 

Monday 19 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Charles Melton in May December

Charles Melton did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite winning several critic's awards, for portraying Joe Yoo in May December.

May December follows an actress Elizabeth (Natalie Portman) as preps for a role by meeting and investigating a woman Gracie (Julianne Moore) who had a sexually inappropriate relationship with an underage child, and later married him.
 
Charles Melton previously is an actor I didn't really notice much in the few things I had seen him in, in fact didn't notice he was in them other than Poker Face, where he played a fine though not standout killer of the week. So hearing about his standout work in this film I was very much interested to see what exactly he had in him, in the role of the now aged former victim of sexual abuse, though married to his predator. And I'll admit watching it the first time I was still wondering in the early scenes of the film, where despite getting a bit more focus camerwise found Melton just kind of there in his early scenes where Elizabeth comes to visit and tries to get to know him and Gracie. Melton's performance frankly seems a bit bland as he goes about this seemingly doting around his wife as we see him. Always there for her to lie on and just laughs off a box of sent over crap, literally, as though it is standard procedure. Melton's performance doesn't seem to have much to it in these early scenes as he presents just a man just kind of doing whatever his wife wants and being the image of a potential "ideal" of someone who is doing whatever he can to support his wife. There is no complication in that rather he seems to be existing in this state of a  kind of created being, with a certain malaise underlying it all. As he speaks just in a subdued if not also unremarkable way, just being kind of well "there". Which might sound like I am currently tearing this performance a new one in my description of it all so far, but trust me I'm not. 

Rather, Melton's performance is creating the image for the outside of the man who seems to be compliant in his own former abuse by the way he just seems to be existing so calmly in this state. Although Melton's performance would seem bland, what it is doing is actually setting up for the shift. As his line deliveries are almost like afterthoughts of the man just barely putting himself into conversations between Gracie and Elizabeth. His manner is always different, he is always just there seeming to wait to be supported, and seemingly just alright with everything that is going on. It might seem boring in fact, but what Melton is doing is setting much up with this performance. By being a man of no importance it would seem, just going about his life as this near drone under the sway of Gracie. Although there are moments where Melton speaks just a little more in his performance, which seems to speak much more. When for example Gracie is less open to some of Elizabeth's questions, Melton's face denotes a quiet anxiety as well. When Elizabeth tries to ask him a few more questions early on, Melton's low key great though by actually playing it so stiff. In that what Melton's doing as he's speaking his lines with this kind of just functioning statements, and when pressed to analyze anything about himself such as the fact that he has college age kids at such a young age, Melton's little break and sudden hesitations gives the hint of that all is far from right with Joe, despite how he may seem much of the time. Perhaps the most staggering scene in this stage of his performance is the one with his father where their interaction couldn't be more distant, however outside of the watchful eye of Gracie, you see Melton's performance just slightly but profoundly to suggest a real sorrow, however a sorrow perhaps Joe doesn't entirely understand. 

Although all this would be maybe looking too much into this if there was a very exact and brilliant gradual change in Melton's performance as Joe the more Elizabeth interacts with him and the more she causes, if only for selfish reasons on her part, to think more about his past. When for example she asks about his habit of saving butterflies, Melton is great in the way we see the malaise partially remove itself from him as he lets out excitement about his quiet passion. Just a little bit and Melton's so good because he almost seems to be struggling against a kind of conditioning in every moment of the conversation. He's kind of showing himself but not fully. And we have more of this when Elizabeth asks him more for his side of the story where Melton is great in his run down of Joe's version of the events, which is an incredible mix in his performance between conditioning and seeming truth which he differentiates in his performance. When telling it as though he is somehow the one who wanted to be preyed on by a much older woman, Melton recites the lines as though very much Joe reciting his lines where each point seems so specifically said with this overdone calm and consideration for selling the perspective that has been brainwashed into him. Again when Joe talks a little more about his own family, having lost his mom and dealt with his distant father and his own problems with girls that were his own age. The emotion as he drifts to these lines suddenly feels real and more importantly suddenly feels very raw and powerful as he speaks these words as filled with so much more anxiety and more importantly truth. We see in the same scene from Melton the man who he truly is in what has happened to him and the man who has been "crafted' by Gracie. 

We see the contrast between Joe and Gracie, when she has a mental breakdown, and Melton portrays this sad sort of reduction of himself to be her "rescuer" every time and is a most frozen in arrested development. This is against when we see him with his adult children, where Melton portrays the "dad" at moments where you again see a break in his behavior. His interactions with them are more natural than with Gracie and you see the moment of seeming attempts at real happiness albeit broken in their way still. Something that comes out more when he talks to his son on the roof of his house and they both get high. Melton is great in the scene because in the moment, he shows the man unencumbered by any of the forced expectations put on him by Gracie. Melton's breakdown reveals more than just a guy not knowing how to deal with the drugs, rather a man seeing his emotions more directly for once. His delivery is so powerful because it is a man so sloppily coming out with any sense of self and trying to explain himself to his son. Melton brings such a seething desperation in the moment of just showing how truly broken the man is in the moment, and struggling to try to fully connect with his son beyond the confines of the mental prison Gracie has put him in. Melton shows the mess within the man's mind when he begins to face it, though what we see as the film progresses is the man coming more and more to terms with his mental anguish. Melton's performance basically shedding off that state we originally saw him in through the first act of the film, and we see the shifting in the man as he seems to be finally doing any reflection whatsoever on what was done to him at a young age. 

Part of this comes in when Elizabeth purposefully seduces him, seemingly just for her own research for her role and little else, where Melton's performance is great in the aftereffect of it because you see his reaction closer to like a teenage boy in the moment. You see suddenly shame reflect on his face and anxiety as you see him thinking about Gracie, though not as sadness but rather as an internalized fear. Melton though articulates so much pent up hesitation and frustration that speaks to a history of repression. When Elizabeth dismisses his whole life as "a story", Melton's performance is very effective in showing just how broken Joe is as he brings such a natural, unnatural quality, and by that we get this sense of adult like betrayal in his anger towards Elizabeth's blitheness, while also showing the sheer mess as he falls into this petulant childlike delivery of any line speaking towards thinking that Elizabeth cared for him. And with this Melton shows the man who doesn't want his emotions played with but also the boy whose whole idea of romance, attraction and sexual behavior is completely broken by what was done to him as a child. He's equally fantastic in the following scene with Gracie, where you see the man no longer in the sunken state but yes in the submissive state as he tries to talk to Gracie. Where he and Moore don't have chemistry of a romantic pair, rather you see consistently this state of manipulation. Starting with this meek way of trying to get beyond her control in her way and genuinely asking if he was too young to make the decisions she claims he made to pursue the relationship. Melton is heartbreaking because you sense the years of anxiety but also mental grooming he is struggling through as he shows deep down it is just a man looking for answers for this life of his, which Gracie treats only as an infraction. Melton is very moving then in his final scenes in the film where we see him with his daughter before graduation and you have the hint of a more complete man in the honest way he presents his love to his daughter. In the moment Melton shows the one part of Joe that isn't controlled or broken in any way and that's the love for his kids. With his final reaction to seeing his kids graduate high school being incredible work that offers an end to his character without words. As you see that love in his eyes, the man is moved as a man should be to see his kid, but this slowly becomes mixed in with all the trauma the man has gone through and is finally truly feeling as he breaks down in the moment so painfully though poignantly as you do see the joy of children with the suffering of his plight. This is great work by Charles Melton because what he does is present you with the surface idea, which he slowly cracks at then reveals the truth in his powerful portrait of man finally realizing his life is a lie.

Sunday 18 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Michael Fassbender in The Killer

Michael Fassbender did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying the titular character of The Killer. 

The Killer follows the exploits of, well the killer, who seeks revenge after retribution for a botched job.

Writing a review for Michael Fassbender as the Killer takes time, persistence and a Netflix subscription...or perhaps a borrowed subscription if one pays it back with an HBO MAX subscription. I have already written the requisite of Fassbender's lack of a nomination and brief synopsis, perhaps should be known already, but one does have to stick to their plan, not improvise, well except the review itself is written as I'm writing but regardless, as I review this, I must remember my review of Bradley Cooper's Oscar nomination this year and remember that empathy is weakness. I need to stick to my plan and write this review, but I keep narrating to myself instead which can really get in your way. I haven't had my required protein for the day, perhaps I should follow the Killer's advice and get a McDonald's breakfast sandwich, however the additional ingredients of dirt from the employees poor hygiene and extra ounces of grease tend to cause a miserable pain to my digestive system. Although perhaps the killer's less than stellar taste in fast food choices speaks to my realization against the common idea that "Films about hitmen are cool" it's not Jean Pierre-Melville but it should be. But it's the language of The Killer though in fact is being subverted by the language of the Killer. As I've noticed some have believed the film engages in the nihilism that Fassbender's killer espouses, so I have to ask "Based on what exactly". It is true as I'm doing now we hear the Killer's thoughts spoken in a calm if not even dulcet tone by Michael Fassbender, who seems like someone who will play the cool killer, who is the expert at all things, but the one thing you need to remember about the Killer is "HE...IS...FULL...OF...SHIT" Shit, gave away the main point of my review too early, best just press on. 

After all I need to remind any reader that the first person the killer quotes is Popeye the sailor man, not known to be the greatest philosophers, personally I prefer Bluto, who has been known to be so mean that he beat himself up, although that was only in the infamous Robert Altman film and may not in fact hold up to scrutiny. Much as the hitman's own philosophizing which includes another quote where Fassbender stares blankly and a "duhhhh" coming out of his mouth wouldn't exactly be out of place on his vacant face as he fails to properly cite his source much like a Wikipedia article written in the early 2000's. And in the man's voice every word is about the meticulousness of his planning, yet he almost immediately gets caught and looks upon Fassbender's face which is of a man who is very much concerned about being found out. He glances looking around his perch from where he is going to kill his proposed target, and what is his performance exactly. Well Fassbender is presenting curiosity not precision, and despite everything being built for the kill in the Killer's calm claims, I must ask again "Based on what exactly?". The Killer's own buildup to his first attempted kill is all of a man gearing up for the kill. Fassbender's expression of a man pumping himself up for it and we have two completely disparate moments in a singular scene around performance. As we first hear that the killer "DON'T...GIVE...A...FUCK" which Fassbender delivers with the utmost confidence and pride, against his "fuck" after immediately missing his kill he prepared so much for, with the face of a man who screwed up royally that gets funnier the more you think about it.

I should take a moment though to immaculately clean my computer before I keep typing, as there can be a minute build up of dust over weeks and months, however one must keep their computer relatively dust free in order to complete a review. A review here I'll freely admit my bias towards captivating silent physical performance, that has much to do with presence, but the presence must be there. Michael Fassbender, despite seemingly indirectly killing ("wocka wocka" - Fozzy Bear) the talent of many formerly talented directors in his last few films, this time David Fincher thankfully was spared and we have an ideal match up with the cold calculation of the director being matched by the cold calculation of a performer. And I will make no bones about it, it is compelling just to watch Fassbender do the rigmarole of his tasks as he goes about his various methods of preparing his kills and body disposals. He shows in his physical work just the precise manner of the man who believes he's "sticking to the plan" again and again. Although that may break my thesis of his incompetence, I never said incompetence, he's just full of it, and isn't *as* good as he thinks but more so isn't as anything as he thinks, to explain, which of course I'm going to explain, this is my review after all, he's also not *as* heartless as he claims he is, though Fassbender plays this on the margins, effectively so. In the opening escape, he is genuinely fearing for his life in Fassbender's furious breathing and concerned eyes, though trying to hold it together. When other hitmen try to attack his girlfriend, Fassbender's performance shows that the Killer does care about her and his whole home away from killing, even if he wants to so desperately suggest otherwise. Everything in Fassbender's performance suggests he does care, he's holding back as much as he can, but the degree of which he's expressing his concern shows this to be a wounding event, and also explaining why he then goes about his revenge tour shortly afterwards. 

Now do I have to note that we see the cold killer, of course, but what we see with Fassbender though very much is the projecting of this trait, almost as someone who saw Le Samourai, and said "that's literally me" without watching the ending of that film...or more likely with the Killer saw the trailer one time and it was directed by a former French resistance fighter...what was his name again? As what Fassbender does on the edge of moments suggests the truth, as when he kills the cabbie who drove the hitmen to his house, there is a brief glimpse of vicious anger before he shoots him even though his head up to that had been the heartless killer. His vocal performance additionally is frequently at odds with what he is doing, as his voice is one of my favorite narrations in recent years because it is so falsely true to what he actually is doing most of the time. As every narration conversation it is with that confidence of the man who has outlined every kill with the precision of the genius, yet probably might need a few letters spotted as well for spelling antidisestablishmentarianism, that's for all you Honeymooners fans out there...is that just me, well you know as the Killer says I DON'T GIVE A , eh forget it. Anyway, frequently you get the punchline from the narration, to the action, to the performance. As take it when he kills his old mentor and job liaison, where he calmly uses a nail gun on him, positions an option for survival then calculates his survival time so specifically in his head, only for the man to immediately choke on his own blood, and Fassbender's befuddled realization of his failure is pure darkly comic gold. 

He says "forgo empathy" but he does stage his mentor's secretary's death as an accident as a way to honor her last wish. He prepares to carefully murder the brute hitman who attacked his girlfriend, by carefully disabling his Pitbull through drugs then maneuvering in the house, only to get his ass kicked, for the lack of a better description, where Fassbender's many "oh shit" reactions subvert the "cool" presence beautifully as does his "ah come on" when finding only a cheese grater in a kitchen draw and frankly Fassbender's face is hilarious. As is the fact that he didn't fully disable the dog, needing to high tail it out of there, and even his narration gets impacted this time, where Fassbender's voice changes briefly from the calm control as though the beating was so bad even that front has to take a breather. His later sleeping on the plane to his next target is of any exhausted man, whose worked too hard the past few days, and there's nothing remotely cool about it. And my review of this performance wouldn't be complete if I didn't mention the quote as he goes about stalking the expert hit person (Tilda Swinton) "It’s common knowledge when a female is found slain, the prime suspect is always the husband or boyfriend. Especially if she hasn’t been sexually assaulted." spoken with a return to the cold calculation and we get one more subversion even in his narration for Fassbender's hilarious line delivery (frankly one of my favorites of 2023) "Well, maybe not common knowledge." which he says a quick correction as though he's just realized how ludicrous his previous statement sounded. The one time we do see the pure Killer routine not shake for a moment is confronting the final target, where his demeanor is purely that of the cold blooded killer...and even this is a subversion because the target (Arliss Howard) happens to be just a bit of idiot who has too much money, and the killer when most able to present himself as he believes him to be...he doesn't kill. Now did I write this review just to do it in part in the style of the Killer's own narration partially, no in fact I didn't come up with that until I started writing the review and just seemed the easiest way into the performance. But one does have to ask the need to feel secure in one's opinion. It's a slippery slope. Opinions are a placebo. The only review path, is the one you just wrote (as long as it ends with clear rating at the end of the review as rating and paragraph counts are everything). If, you can't accept this opinion of loving Fassbender's work as wonderful dark comedy, well maybe you're not one of the few. Maybe you're just like me. One of the many....whatever that's supposed to mean...not sure that part made sense. 

Saturday 17 February 2024

Alternate Best Actor 2023: Dominic Sessa in The Holdovers

Dominic Sessa did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite receiving. a BAFTA nomination, for portraying Angus Tully in The Holdovers.

The role of the young man who is the foil to the older man is a common enough role to exist, and frequently played very poorly.  At least half the time Angus Tully would be a dullard that you wish we'd just get back to his curmudgeon lazy eyed teacher Paul Hunham (Paul Giamatti), some of the time he'd be worse and an actively grating part of the film, and occasionally he'd be decent but definitely unquestionably overshadowed by the older actor that you still do kind of forget about him as an essential part of the film. It isn't that the role itself is bad, in fact it is very well written, rather the nature of the part often seems to lead to uninteresting casting choices of not always the most talented performers, who either still need to come into their own or will never come into their own. You might've guessed I'm prefacing all of this to praise the casting director and probably Alexander Payne for casting Dominic Sessa in this role, who was a student at one of the boarding schools they used for the fictional boarding school of Barton and auditioned for the film. You'd never even guess this backstory necessarily, other than the fact that Sessa doesn't look like your standard Hollywood fresh face, and rather has a natural character of his own. Which is just point one in the points of exceptional elements that exist in this performance. Because in the parts where you often most feel the performance, or at least perhaps the not good enough attempt at one, it is in these roles, and Sessa just is this role from the first scene, which in itself is actually a lot trickier than one might think even for the low key establishing scenes. 

Wrong choice number one would be to appear far too modern for the role of the 70's teenager. Well success number one is that Sessa's presence rather curiously feels like a young actor from the 70's and is entirely convincing as such, that again you don't even consider him for a moment as a modern teenager. There's something particularly interesting about pulling this trick off, because the certain style of performance could be that of that dull 70's actor, but thankfully Sessa is much closer to a Jeff Bridges or Timothy Bottoms, than a Robby Benson or Richard Gere. But he's also not copying in any way, he is entirely his own and that is where success number two comes in right away. Which is avoiding being a big nothing, as to try to be likeable one can easily have no defining features whatsoever, but Sessa very much defines Angus as his own character from his opening scenes, where frankly he is in a less innately likeable space of the teenage boys being teenage boys as they wait to go to on Christmas break. In this scene I think frankly it is some of the most difficult work as you get into his antagonism with a few other classmates particularly the properly named Kountze, as there were two dangers here. One being bland in just portraying the character in being slightly righteous in his attacks leaving no distinction whatsoever, or being aggravating in overplaying the antagonism. Sessa side steps either by indeed being distinct in his callous manner towards the classmates he has less affection for where he doesn't hold back, but doing so with just a natural ease in his delivery that makes the scene feel honest within his performance.
 
Sessa's great in his first interaction with Hunham, that is on a similar brand to his first scene, where he speaks up after most of the class gets failing test grades, though not Angus and Hunham decides to still teach class even though it is the last day of the semester. A low key scene but speaks to the strength of his performance because it would be again easy to fall into the pitfall of being too heroic as the one who speaks up for the class or obnoxious if we see the man seemingly owning his privilege as he states he's more interested in where he's going for his vacation. Sessa again is so good by riding the far more honest middle ground as he does speak with confidence and a bit of genuine befuddlement at Hunham's persistence, but just as that there's glints just before he's speaking and waiting for Hunham's response of some actual fear, showing that Angus is taking a step he's not entirely prepared for even if he is making it. And then earning far more than the undercurrent of anxiety and natural guilt he wears as Hunham allows for them to go enjoy the day, though with homework and no makeup test for a better grade. Sessa doing what is the most important thing, actually being a believable teenager who perhaps has his heart in the right place at times, but doesn't always make the right decisions consistently. 

Unfortunately for Angus his newly re-married mother decides to have a late honeymoon over the break rather than let Angus come home for Christmas leaving him as one of the five Holdovers to be watched over by the still grumpy Hunham even over break. Although a relatively brief portion of the overall film, the sequence of Angus with the Holdovers is great work for Sessa. Sessa in part is just naturally creating the right sense of frustration over having to be stuck for his entire break at Barton that much longer, and creating that annoyance in a believable and in a very easy to sympathize fashion. Sessa's also great in creating the sense of his place in the school, as he's with two other older students and two other younger students. Where Sessa very much shows Angus playing the role within the group of mostly peers when all are together, where we see them together in frustration at the situation, and just being slightly rebellious in their ways. Sessa though makes the most of two separate moments out of really the portrayal of how Angus presents himself to his classmates. First two wonderful moments with the younger students, that Sessa manages to play with such an ease, because he plays warmth, but doesn't overplay it. He doesn't suddenly become this perfect person, but rather suggests just an innate care in his delivery where he brings a specific emphasis on a "we'll get through this" kind of support for the younger boys that creates a very naturalistic though better nature in Angus. That is in stark contrast to when we see him with his nemesis Kountze who has stolen a family photo. Where Sessa is great, in doing something I will get to more of as his performance goes on, but so fantastic in the way of playing the intensity of the conflict, though with the front of just being direct at his enemy, but internalizing the real sense of distress as something he's trying to hide. Although it is most evident that Angus is very much attached to his photo which means much to him, he's trying to keep the feelings in him in front of the other students.

The group gets a break when one of the student's parents lets him come home and in turn all the boys are given the chance to go on vacation with him, except poor Angus because his parents refused to ever come to the phone. Which brings me so much to what makes this such a great performance which is how dynamic Sessa is in playing Angus, particularly in the way he expresses his maturity, and uses that so well to create the sense of who this young man is and what he has been through. As on the surface Sessa plays the teenager who is trying to be tough, somewhat indifferent at times, though not unemotional, but most of all not revealing everything that is going on within him. Something that seems to inform so much of Sessa's work that ends up bringing such nuance to the character. The early scenes of the new situation, where it is just Angus, Hunham and the school cook Mary (Da'Vine Joy Randolph), Hunham is constantly on top of him, though still demanding he follow procedure for the most part. Sessa's great in just his expressions of this slight bit of boredom as he's stuck within the school, and the internalized frustrations as he just has to keep going. An example of Sessa doing so much more than you might expect from a first time film actor is actually in the montage, which isn't always the type of sequence one thinks of for acting, is great work though. As we see Angus swipe the school keys from Hunham and go around the school finding whatever joy he can. Sessa's wonderful in the scene because you see the wavering maturity of the not quite man but definitely not a boy person that is Angus. As you do see the moments where physically he's almost skipping like a child, but others where he's just staring at the empty halls of nothing with the sad contemplation of the mature understanding of being so stuck in this place. 

The moment where there's a bit of a break, both literally and metaphorically in the situation, is where Angus has had enough of Hunham's control and purposefully pesters him by running around the school. A scene which is again speaks to what you would think is a far more seasoned performer, as he brings just the right type of mischievous smile as he goes about it, that I think importantly shows that this isn't just trouble making for the sake of it, he's also is more than getting a little crazed due to the cabin fever, playing the note just so effortlessly, particularly his big smile as he purposefully goes about "crossing the Rubicon" by taking a leap in the unfinished gym, right into dislocating his arm. Leading to another impressive scene for Sessa because he is hilarious, but hilarious in a way that is especially tricky not to be too much or too little, particularly when doing the comedy off a more seasoned performer like Giamatti who obviously has done both comedy and drama with ease over his long career. Sessa though completely sells the moment of the extreme sense of pain as he stares at his arm, just barely holding it together while also bringing this venomous anger towards Hunham's failure to "protect" him after Hunham said he'd "wash his hands of him". A very broad moment that wouldn't work if it wasn't delivered well, which Sessa delivers flawlessly, especially his "Of Course you meant It metaphorically! What were you going to do? actually go and wash your hands?!" that is comic gold. What is amazing is that Sessa is as comfortable in the scene as Giamatti is, and they are both great together. 

Which then we get the real start of their relationship as more than just the teacher everyone hates, as they go to get Angus's arm treated, to which Angus lies to save Hunham's job by pretending to be his son. Another scene that is incredible again regardless, but particularly when again this is the first film gig, because Sessa on the surface is playing well the act of the concerned kid for his dad to be convincing to the nurse, playing this humbleness as he seems so reasonably intent to be able to see his "dad" again, which is all good, but the little glints of real emotion relating to the idea of seeing his dad pierces through just a bit in the moment as Sessa suggests Angus using real emotion to sell the false scenario. And with this we finally see the beginning of the connections between Angus and Hunham, which is fantastic work from both actors because it isn't easy. As initially their conversation, which is what is the best alcoholic drink, arguing about lying as a Barton man and getting a burger out of him, might seem mostly casual stuff, yet what both actors do is help to establish at least a conversational speech that bridges the two in some way. They are hardly friends, but they are no longer just grumpy teachers and frustrated students. There is at least a little more there, a bit more of any connection if with the right distance still that needs to be worked through.

When the at-home trio are invited to a Christmas eve party by another staff member from the school, Miss Crane (Carrie Preston), Sessa is able to express the range of his work that is most impressive. The first moment actually being a quick one but one of my favorite scenes in the film, where Angus takes a moment to look at a snow globe, and there's this quiet sadness mixed with nostalgia Sessa brings as Angus seemingly is lost in thought for a moment at the ideal Christmas that the globe seems to represent to him. When he goes off with Miss Crane's niece, you have again Sessa being impressive in really scenes that being okay would've been fine. But Sessa's great because he manages to so naturally play the shifting maturity of Angus in such a natural way, and again a way that speaks very honestly to a teenager who wants to be mature but isn't quite there yet. And with the niece Sessa's good in playing the moment of scoffing at kids finger painting, to having an earnest moment of potential romance with the niece, but also being properly awkward as he'd be at first denying trying to look down her shirt to shyly admitting it. It is the way he is able to flow within the character, while always seeming the character that just makes you feel like you're entirely getting to know this young man, while also just being compelling. His other moment is as much the mature man as he gets Hunham to help as the widowed and bereaved parent has a mental breakdown, and Sessa is great in just his work as a scene partner, reactionary, where he quietly conveys his empathy to the moment and genuine concern in the young man even if he doesn't quite have the words himself. When leaving the party you have a quick, but still a great moment where Angus asks to go back to the party after they take Mary back home, however when Hunham dismisses this as well as his want to enjoy his time off in any way, Sessa's expression almost freezing is great acting. What he shows is basically the "tough face" of the teenager who doesn't care about anything, while actually alluding to the teenager who just doesn't want to be needlessly hurt. 

Hunham, thanks to some important words from Mary, decides to try his best to make a decent Christmas for Angus after all, which first includes gifts and a Christmas tree. A scene where Sessa's performance is pitch perfect, though speaks well to the relationship between the two at this point, where you see kind of the sense that the gesture isn't overall amazing in terms of the output but there's a definite sort of begrudging appreciation that the attempt has been made regardless. When asked though if he can have a sort of a gift, Sessa's delivery of "let's go to Boston" is amazing because the excitement again speaks to the real youth of the character even perhaps even more connection to Boston symbolizing more than just possibly a fun trip. We see then the advancement of the relationship between Hunham and Angus as they go on their trip to Boston, where Sessa and Giamatti are great together. They are great because they never go to the completely simple choice, rather there is a connection with a little bit of a back and forth of a pseudo battle as well. As we get moments of Hunham being the teacher to Angus at times, where Angus comes back at the student, and I love the two nearly connecting lines as delivered by Sessa. The first being as he notes Hunham's passion over Ancient history, being genuine seeming in the moment and saying just so directly though encouragingly that he wished he taught like that when was in class. This is followed by him telling Hunham that everyone hates him, which is key delivery that Sessa nails, because it isn't about trying to put Hunham down or even express hate, it rather with this bluntly honest way of trying to get Hunham to see the trench that Hunham has created between himself and others. But between the best and the worst, the two have natural moments of just having fun with one another, occasionally a bit of  cutting though not hateful remarks, but also the moments of understanding as the two begin to respect one another in their way. Every moment feels earned in their performances and never does a moment of openness feel like a jump because Sessa and Giamatti are so genuine together. 

Eventually though Angus tries to slip away from Hunham, which is a brief but terrific scene for both performances because you see them briefly kind of return to their old status though differently. As in Hunham you see genuine betrayal with the frustration with the young man, meanwhile Sessa is so powerful by being so meek in the moment of the man hiding away his emotions, that emotion being connected to his father, who he previously said was dead, and is trying to run away to see. We see the reason for the attempt and the lie as Angus comes to see his father who is in a mental institution due to being a paranoid schizophrenic. Sessa is outstanding in this scene because we see none of the attempts to present himself anything but his way. Sessa most looks like a boy in this scene, from his anxiety in waiting for his son, and then the purity of his smile as he sees his dad. His voice cracking in the emotion pouring in from seeing his dad in this way. His "miss you" has no attempt "cool" to it, just completely wanting to connect with his dad, his excitement in telling him about his grades is really heartbreaking because the way Sessa says every word is this outpouring of just trying to share his life and his potential with his dad he clearly once had such a strong connection to. Sessa is the boy here who just wants to be acknowledged by his dad and is frankly eager to be recognized. As we see as he looks at his dad with hope, as his dad is about to tell him something, which is only paranoid ramblings, and the way Sessa's face falls into realization of just how lost his dad is absolutely devastating. 

The following scene Sessa is amazing because we now see him without any front with Hunham in just recounting his dad's descent into madness. Sessa's so heart wrenching in the scene because you feel every moment of the difficult history as he briefly tries to smile in talking about the good times, then just brings so much vulnerable pain as he discusses his dad's slowly increasing madness. The history here is felt in every word, but that's not even the most impressive moment. The most impressive is when we see that vulnerability pour into his own exile from his family, and the heartbreaking expression of his own concern that he might become like his dad at some point. Sessa is so open in his performance, that we see as the hidden truth of the scared boy beneath it all, that is so beautifully acted and just brings such an earned poignancy into Angus admitting all that he's been going through this whole time. Hunham's words to try to build up Angus then, that comes from his own pains and heartbreak, speak so much loudly due to Sessa's reaction that you see is reserved yet let just a little bit of inspiration and hope pour into his face that is absolutely moving in seeing the real connection between the two. A connection that makes it convincing that Hunham would rather lose his job than throw Angus under the bus for visiting his father, and sacrifices himself for the sake of the young man after the break period is over. A moment followed by Hunham directly sharing his own self by simply telling Angus which of his two eyes is the one to look at, and it is all in both Giamatti's delivery and Sessa's reaction where you see the profound meaning in the two sharing this moment. Which is only a warm-up to their final scene together as Angus goes to see Hunham as he's finally leaving Barton. A scene I saved purposefully for this review because of how great the two are together in realizing this exceptional scene. The way Angus begins by acknowledging what Hunham did for him, to which Hunham brushes off as they both admit to keeping to their Barton men code of silence between them, is so sweet yet earned as the pair create fully too an inside understanding between them in their pitch perfect performances. Seguing so naturally to a brief moment of joking again about their beer ranking and alluding to the good times they did have together, with the warmth between the two just overflowing so naturally and it is hard not to feel the warmth yourself, as Angus suggests the two go off to get lunch one more time. Hunham softly turning him down as this having to be a goodbye, Giamatti brings fully the maturity of the teacher being completely the teacher he's always should've been against Sessa, wearing so powerfully the emotion of how much it has meant that an adult has genuinely cared about him. Creating the sense of the meaning this relationship has meant to both the old and the young man. And Giamatti's way of showing Hunham final near complete emotional break just below the surface as he says "you can do this" to Angus, as Angus says "I was going to tell you the same thing" matching the same emotional undercurrent, before each finding their strength in the other in the handshake, is absolute perfection from both actors, and just such a strikingly beautiful scene made so by two tremendous performances. Two tremendous performances, because Sessa gives one of the all time great feature film debuts here. It's already a part with so many potential pitfalls, which Sessa misses every one to give an effortless performance which I absolutely adore every moment of. And what is more impressive is how risky the performance is, he goes for the big emotions, he goes for the big comedic moments, but he knows to do that with subtlety, nuance, and always an understanding for who his character is, what are his truths, and what everything means within his arc.