5. Mark Ruffalo in Spotlight - Ruffalo sticks out like a sore thumb with his excessively mannered turn that seems so false within a film going for a strict realism.
4. Christian Bale in The Big Short - Bale is able to make his character's various mannerisms seem natural the problem is the film never allows him to take it anywhere past that set up.
Best Scene: His introduction.
3. Mark Rylance in Bridge of Spies - Rylance gives a moving, inspiring, amusing and technically even devious yet unassuming performance as he artfully makes his Soviet spy everything the film needs Rudolf Abel to be.
Best Scene: "Standing Man"
2. Sylvester Stallone in Creed - Stallone manages to not only find new ground for his seventh depiction of Rocky Balboa but also is able to pay homage to his previous iterations in his return to the character.
Best Scene: "If I could take everything that's good out there and put it into a bowl"
1. Tom Hardy in The Revenant - Good predictions Michael McCarthy, RatedRStar, Jackiboyz, and GM It needs to be said I hate to have to rank these top three. All three do fantastic work and if any of the three were to win the Oscar I'll be more than happy with it. My personal favorite of three, and I love all three of their work, is Tom Hardy's brilliant turn as John Fitzgerald. Hardy makes for an effective and surprisingly even entertaining villain, while still managing to find depth within the motivations of his character.
Best Scene: "God is a Squirrel"
Showing posts with label 2015 Best Supporting Actor. Show all posts
Showing posts with label 2015 Best Supporting Actor. Show all posts
Wednesday, 20 January 2016
Tuesday, 19 January 2016
Best Supporting Actor 2015: Tom Hardy in The Revenant
Tom Hardy received his first Oscar nomination for portraying John Fitzgerald in The Revenant.
My fellow writer on ....uh... films and performances, Calvin Law, aptly compared Tom Hardy's cinematic style to that of a combination of Gary Oldman and Toshiro Mifune. Like Oldman Hardy always seeks to disappear in his roles, rarely ever keeping the same voice or mannerisms from part to part, but somehow, like Mifune, he carries a physical presence that is most definitely all his own. In the role of Fitzgerald, Hardy once again changes his accent this time to a thick Texan drawl which effectively suggests his background in addition to making him seem right in place given the film's time period. Hardy in addition past this carries himself in a particular way that emphasizes the survivalist that Fitzgerald is. There's a constant aggression in terms of his physical demeanor as he's always eager to occupy someone else's space, and never allows another person to stand on higher ground than him. Hardy presents Fitzgerald as a man whose not only ready to attack, but he's also always very watchful of an attack. There is a sense of paranoia that Hardy conveys in Fitzgerald that rarely leaves him that again suggests so well Fitzgerald's troubled history that most certainly started long before he ever started upon the troubled hunting and trapping expedition lead by Captain Henry (Domhnall Gleeson) or came in contact with Hugh Glass (Leonardo DiCaprio).
Now as threatening as Hardy makes the man in simply his nature, Hardy adds to all of this through his domineering screen presence. Hardy can hold a scene all in his own way, even in some his earliest work like Black Hawk Down and Layer Cake he stood out making his characters seem far more important than they were, and in 2015 he made a scene of just mutely indicating how he wanted guns passed to him completely captivating. On a quick side note I can't help but feel that his performance in Mad Max is becoming criminally underrated as though his performance was just a given. Hardy has more lines to deal with in this case but once again commands his place in the film in that fashion so unique to Hardy himself. Hardy adds to the threat and menace of Fitzgerald as a character through this. Hardy's great because he never allows Fitzgerald to seem second to anyone, as he even when he's taking orders from Captain Henry, he always seems to exude a control of his own domain. Hardy gives Fitzgerald the needed impact to be a great villain, and probably even without saying anything Hardy could have been able to make Fitzgerald a worthy adversary for his rival survivalist of sorts Hugh Glass.
Hardy with the setup of the character, just in his physical manner, and that dominance he exudes so well makes Fitzgerald a palatable threat throughout the film. What I love perhaps the most though is that Hardy in his depiction of Fitzgerald's most active scenes does not portray him as this evil mastermind, but instead plays him...as well to quote Marty McFly in Back to the Future 3 "he's an asshole". In the early scenes, even before anything goes wrong, Hardy is terrific in playing up just how consistently miserable Fitzgerald makes everyone else with his focus on just his own personal pelts. Now what's so great about what Hardy does with this is actually how unrelenting he is in making Fitzgerald such a pain in everyone's backside. Hardy doesn't mind showing exactly what Fitzgerald is with most his behavior, which is that of a single minded jerk. This could have seemed too much, but I have to give Hardy the most credit as in his depiction of behavior he's only ever reminded me of people I've known with a similair self absorption. Hardy's loud and that's the only way to be with a man like Fitzgerald who really wants everyone to know quite clearly he only cares about himself. One of my favorite moments in Hardy's performance is his reaction to seeing Glass's mauled, it isn't concern, its just that of lout who's annoyed that this will probably inconvenience him in some way. This might not have worked but Hardy makes it so brutally honest that it absolutely does.
Hardy takes this feature in Fitzgerald and makes it almost too genuine. Hardy's so good because he shows it to be such casual behavior, though actually ties into the mindset of a survivalist, as he can't even wrap his head around the idea that he should ever put someone else first. Hardy makes it so perfectly plain that the first concern for Fitzgerald is always Fitzgerald. Another one of my favorite moments in this performance, I have lots of them I must confess, is when they are struggling to keep moving Glass and it is decided that three men must stay with him. The first two being volunteers, who even will put up their own pay for the sake of Glass, but the third does not come forward. No one will take it until the Captain, and the two men basically offer a great sum of cash to the third man. Hardy's reaction again is flawless as he shows Fitzgerald's face light up. Again Hardy does not keep it as a master plan, he does not suggest that Fitzgerald already has plans for Glass, rather he really makes even worse by so blatantly putting it that Fitzgerald just doing the whole thing for money. When he does end up trying to get Glass to agree to death, Hardy's once again marvelous by finding such a callous indifference to life, this time not even due to malice rather due to impatience, though once again from being concerned only with his own life.
Now with that comes Fitzgerald's most heinous act, which is brilliantly performed by Hardy. This is again because of something atypical Hardy does, that once alludes to the nature of his character. In the moment there is a viciousness but only as though its his instinctual reaction to being attacked, especially by a native. Hardy only emphasizes this all the more as a second or too later basically acknowledes that he went overboard, not through genuine empathy but rather through an especially cruel shrug. That instinctual reaction though is given sense by Hardy when Fitzgerald recounts to the other man who stays to watch Glass, Bridger (Will Poulter), when he was scalped. It's a beautifully played moment by Hardy as he once again keeps Fitzgerald's tone of voice as a bit indifferent and a bit hateful, but in his eyes, that are away from Bridger, you can see that he's about to cry, and is actively trying to keep his composure. Hardy reveals the pain in Fitzgerald from his past, and is even moving in the moment as Fitzgerald only reveals to himself the sensitive man traumatized by his mistreatment. From this though Hardy creates the sense of much of the man's motivation which above all else is his survival. This is reflected all the more in perhaps Hardy's best scene as he recounts to Bridger a story about Fitzgerald's own father finding God in a squirrel. It's an outstanding scene for Hardy as he recounts the story with an underlying warmth, and manages to be genuinely inspiring as he speaks the words. What's so fantastic about it is that Hardy does not compromise the character. It's still all about himself though as he presents the words in a way that it is Fitzgerald in fact comforting himself with the story. Hardy is so good because he does not hold back in terms of the villainy of the character yet still gives him depth. His final scene is a grand example of that as he's so downright pitiless as he even takes away anything Glass could have gotten from his revenge, by bluntly stating the futility of it, yet Hardy still brings a very real fear in face all the same. Hardy balances it all so well, and its astonishing that he even can bring a bit of levity to the proceedings while still maintaining the character without question. This is outstanding work from Hardy, and I loved every second of this performance.
My fellow writer on ....uh... films and performances, Calvin Law, aptly compared Tom Hardy's cinematic style to that of a combination of Gary Oldman and Toshiro Mifune. Like Oldman Hardy always seeks to disappear in his roles, rarely ever keeping the same voice or mannerisms from part to part, but somehow, like Mifune, he carries a physical presence that is most definitely all his own. In the role of Fitzgerald, Hardy once again changes his accent this time to a thick Texan drawl which effectively suggests his background in addition to making him seem right in place given the film's time period. Hardy in addition past this carries himself in a particular way that emphasizes the survivalist that Fitzgerald is. There's a constant aggression in terms of his physical demeanor as he's always eager to occupy someone else's space, and never allows another person to stand on higher ground than him. Hardy presents Fitzgerald as a man whose not only ready to attack, but he's also always very watchful of an attack. There is a sense of paranoia that Hardy conveys in Fitzgerald that rarely leaves him that again suggests so well Fitzgerald's troubled history that most certainly started long before he ever started upon the troubled hunting and trapping expedition lead by Captain Henry (Domhnall Gleeson) or came in contact with Hugh Glass (Leonardo DiCaprio).
Now as threatening as Hardy makes the man in simply his nature, Hardy adds to all of this through his domineering screen presence. Hardy can hold a scene all in his own way, even in some his earliest work like Black Hawk Down and Layer Cake he stood out making his characters seem far more important than they were, and in 2015 he made a scene of just mutely indicating how he wanted guns passed to him completely captivating. On a quick side note I can't help but feel that his performance in Mad Max is becoming criminally underrated as though his performance was just a given. Hardy has more lines to deal with in this case but once again commands his place in the film in that fashion so unique to Hardy himself. Hardy adds to the threat and menace of Fitzgerald as a character through this. Hardy's great because he never allows Fitzgerald to seem second to anyone, as he even when he's taking orders from Captain Henry, he always seems to exude a control of his own domain. Hardy gives Fitzgerald the needed impact to be a great villain, and probably even without saying anything Hardy could have been able to make Fitzgerald a worthy adversary for his rival survivalist of sorts Hugh Glass.
Hardy with the setup of the character, just in his physical manner, and that dominance he exudes so well makes Fitzgerald a palatable threat throughout the film. What I love perhaps the most though is that Hardy in his depiction of Fitzgerald's most active scenes does not portray him as this evil mastermind, but instead plays him...as well to quote Marty McFly in Back to the Future 3 "he's an asshole". In the early scenes, even before anything goes wrong, Hardy is terrific in playing up just how consistently miserable Fitzgerald makes everyone else with his focus on just his own personal pelts. Now what's so great about what Hardy does with this is actually how unrelenting he is in making Fitzgerald such a pain in everyone's backside. Hardy doesn't mind showing exactly what Fitzgerald is with most his behavior, which is that of a single minded jerk. This could have seemed too much, but I have to give Hardy the most credit as in his depiction of behavior he's only ever reminded me of people I've known with a similair self absorption. Hardy's loud and that's the only way to be with a man like Fitzgerald who really wants everyone to know quite clearly he only cares about himself. One of my favorite moments in Hardy's performance is his reaction to seeing Glass's mauled, it isn't concern, its just that of lout who's annoyed that this will probably inconvenience him in some way. This might not have worked but Hardy makes it so brutally honest that it absolutely does.
Hardy takes this feature in Fitzgerald and makes it almost too genuine. Hardy's so good because he shows it to be such casual behavior, though actually ties into the mindset of a survivalist, as he can't even wrap his head around the idea that he should ever put someone else first. Hardy makes it so perfectly plain that the first concern for Fitzgerald is always Fitzgerald. Another one of my favorite moments in this performance, I have lots of them I must confess, is when they are struggling to keep moving Glass and it is decided that three men must stay with him. The first two being volunteers, who even will put up their own pay for the sake of Glass, but the third does not come forward. No one will take it until the Captain, and the two men basically offer a great sum of cash to the third man. Hardy's reaction again is flawless as he shows Fitzgerald's face light up. Again Hardy does not keep it as a master plan, he does not suggest that Fitzgerald already has plans for Glass, rather he really makes even worse by so blatantly putting it that Fitzgerald just doing the whole thing for money. When he does end up trying to get Glass to agree to death, Hardy's once again marvelous by finding such a callous indifference to life, this time not even due to malice rather due to impatience, though once again from being concerned only with his own life.
Now with that comes Fitzgerald's most heinous act, which is brilliantly performed by Hardy. This is again because of something atypical Hardy does, that once alludes to the nature of his character. In the moment there is a viciousness but only as though its his instinctual reaction to being attacked, especially by a native. Hardy only emphasizes this all the more as a second or too later basically acknowledes that he went overboard, not through genuine empathy but rather through an especially cruel shrug. That instinctual reaction though is given sense by Hardy when Fitzgerald recounts to the other man who stays to watch Glass, Bridger (Will Poulter), when he was scalped. It's a beautifully played moment by Hardy as he once again keeps Fitzgerald's tone of voice as a bit indifferent and a bit hateful, but in his eyes, that are away from Bridger, you can see that he's about to cry, and is actively trying to keep his composure. Hardy reveals the pain in Fitzgerald from his past, and is even moving in the moment as Fitzgerald only reveals to himself the sensitive man traumatized by his mistreatment. From this though Hardy creates the sense of much of the man's motivation which above all else is his survival. This is reflected all the more in perhaps Hardy's best scene as he recounts to Bridger a story about Fitzgerald's own father finding God in a squirrel. It's an outstanding scene for Hardy as he recounts the story with an underlying warmth, and manages to be genuinely inspiring as he speaks the words. What's so fantastic about it is that Hardy does not compromise the character. It's still all about himself though as he presents the words in a way that it is Fitzgerald in fact comforting himself with the story. Hardy is so good because he does not hold back in terms of the villainy of the character yet still gives him depth. His final scene is a grand example of that as he's so downright pitiless as he even takes away anything Glass could have gotten from his revenge, by bluntly stating the futility of it, yet Hardy still brings a very real fear in face all the same. Hardy balances it all so well, and its astonishing that he even can bring a bit of levity to the proceedings while still maintaining the character without question. This is outstanding work from Hardy, and I loved every second of this performance.
Monday, 18 January 2016
Best Supporting Actor 2015: Christian Bale in The Big Short
Christian Bale received his third Oscar nomination for portraying Michael Burry in The Big Short.
The Big Short is a mess of a film which tells three separate stories of Wall Street investors who all decide to bet against, "short", the housing market.
A common problem when a broad comedy director, like Adam McKay, tries to make a more serious minded film is that it can result in an odd tone as they can't seem to let go of their urge whenever there is potential for a cheap gag now and again. The problematic tone is found in The Big Short and crosses over to the performances where every one is not exactly on the same wavelength. Ryan Gosling plays his role as though he wandered off the set of a not as good version of The Wolf of Wall Street, Brad Pitt plays his role dead seriously, John Magaro and Finn Wittrock play their roles like they're the hapless heroes in a broad comedy, and Steve Carell's voice and walk seem like a comedic creation yet his intentions for the role never seem to be a such. Then there's Christian Bale whose story seems to be in even more of his own bubble than the other two as most of his scenes never leave Michael Burry's office, or are just him having some sort of reflective narration about himself. In turn Bale's performance actually is in a bit of a bubble all its own, though to be fair in this case the film's portrayal of Michael Burry is that he's suppose to be a guy in a bubble all his own.
Bale gives his performance very much a take it or leave it quality, though this is technically very much required for the part of Burry whose suppose to be detached from most everything and probably has Asperger syndrome. The film puts an emphasis on this all the more in the way his scenes are edited as the narration will be over his normal interactions as though to make it so we also are disjointed from him all the more. The film does this as an attempt to show that this disjointed quality in Burry is actually what enables him to see the flaws in the Mortgage market which propels him to start shorting it. Bale in turn gives a portrayal of Burry that from our position seems quite random, and actually to Bale's credit he perhaps gives the performance that might have been what the tone of the film should be. Bale in no way gives a comedic performance, but rather presents Burry exactly as he is. He's never playing for laughs but the potential for that is there. I will say this approach might have worked quite well if the film had been more intelligently directed and edited. Not that this causes Bale's performance to wholly fail though, but the film's tone is too random to make proper use of what he's doing.
Now what Bale is doing just in terms of an abstract view is some random behavior....a great deal of random behavior. Burry has a lot of personal tics as Bale has him speak in kind of an internalized way even when he's directly speaking to someone, and never quite feels like he'll talk right at you. It does not stop there as he just does what he does in terms of behavior whether it is brushing his teeth, or drumming to music in as though he's oblivious to others. Bale keeps his body language withdrawn that always makes him seem a difficult man to approach. Bale will even have Burry sometimes suddenly laugh or smile in a somewhat awkward fashion. Now what Bale does well is he makes this randomness feel natural enough to make it all seem like something normal to Burry, and in fact should be a bit off putting for someone else watching him. It's random to us but it's not random to Burry. Bale pulls this off, and I did not feel like I was just watching Bale act, I felt like he made all of it feel as something a guy with Asperger syndrome would do. Now having said all that, this performance really did very little for me. Again because the film does not make use of what Bale is doing in an effective fashion.
The only interactions are from either those who are playing it dead seriously too which means again Bale is still stuck in his bubble with only the occasional brief minor character having some over the top reaction to him. None of it becomes very amusing, but it did not necessarily have to be that way. It should be engaging at least but the way the scenes are handled there's Bale there doing his thing, and that's it. There's no where to take the behavior past...... well the behavior, especially since Burry basically just gets his short set up then just ignores everyone. This leaves Bale only with the behavior, which in itself becomes a bit repetitive and not too compelling. The film is basically done with him before it even reaches the half way point but it still occasionally cuts to him as he is doing something on a computer, writing down a few numbers, or doing some more drumming. Again only behavior, as the film never bothers to come up with something for Burry to do that's dynamic, which might be true to life but who cares it's a movie. I frankly felt the film halted whenever it came back to Burry, at no fault of Bale's either. All you're left with is a guy acting like he has Asperger Syndrome. To Bale's credit, once again, he pulls it off, but film does not let him take Michael Burry anywhere past the set up.
The Big Short is a mess of a film which tells three separate stories of Wall Street investors who all decide to bet against, "short", the housing market.
A common problem when a broad comedy director, like Adam McKay, tries to make a more serious minded film is that it can result in an odd tone as they can't seem to let go of their urge whenever there is potential for a cheap gag now and again. The problematic tone is found in The Big Short and crosses over to the performances where every one is not exactly on the same wavelength. Ryan Gosling plays his role as though he wandered off the set of a not as good version of The Wolf of Wall Street, Brad Pitt plays his role dead seriously, John Magaro and Finn Wittrock play their roles like they're the hapless heroes in a broad comedy, and Steve Carell's voice and walk seem like a comedic creation yet his intentions for the role never seem to be a such. Then there's Christian Bale whose story seems to be in even more of his own bubble than the other two as most of his scenes never leave Michael Burry's office, or are just him having some sort of reflective narration about himself. In turn Bale's performance actually is in a bit of a bubble all its own, though to be fair in this case the film's portrayal of Michael Burry is that he's suppose to be a guy in a bubble all his own.
Bale gives his performance very much a take it or leave it quality, though this is technically very much required for the part of Burry whose suppose to be detached from most everything and probably has Asperger syndrome. The film puts an emphasis on this all the more in the way his scenes are edited as the narration will be over his normal interactions as though to make it so we also are disjointed from him all the more. The film does this as an attempt to show that this disjointed quality in Burry is actually what enables him to see the flaws in the Mortgage market which propels him to start shorting it. Bale in turn gives a portrayal of Burry that from our position seems quite random, and actually to Bale's credit he perhaps gives the performance that might have been what the tone of the film should be. Bale in no way gives a comedic performance, but rather presents Burry exactly as he is. He's never playing for laughs but the potential for that is there. I will say this approach might have worked quite well if the film had been more intelligently directed and edited. Not that this causes Bale's performance to wholly fail though, but the film's tone is too random to make proper use of what he's doing.
Now what Bale is doing just in terms of an abstract view is some random behavior....a great deal of random behavior. Burry has a lot of personal tics as Bale has him speak in kind of an internalized way even when he's directly speaking to someone, and never quite feels like he'll talk right at you. It does not stop there as he just does what he does in terms of behavior whether it is brushing his teeth, or drumming to music in as though he's oblivious to others. Bale keeps his body language withdrawn that always makes him seem a difficult man to approach. Bale will even have Burry sometimes suddenly laugh or smile in a somewhat awkward fashion. Now what Bale does well is he makes this randomness feel natural enough to make it all seem like something normal to Burry, and in fact should be a bit off putting for someone else watching him. It's random to us but it's not random to Burry. Bale pulls this off, and I did not feel like I was just watching Bale act, I felt like he made all of it feel as something a guy with Asperger syndrome would do. Now having said all that, this performance really did very little for me. Again because the film does not make use of what Bale is doing in an effective fashion.
The only interactions are from either those who are playing it dead seriously too which means again Bale is still stuck in his bubble with only the occasional brief minor character having some over the top reaction to him. None of it becomes very amusing, but it did not necessarily have to be that way. It should be engaging at least but the way the scenes are handled there's Bale there doing his thing, and that's it. There's no where to take the behavior past...... well the behavior, especially since Burry basically just gets his short set up then just ignores everyone. This leaves Bale only with the behavior, which in itself becomes a bit repetitive and not too compelling. The film is basically done with him before it even reaches the half way point but it still occasionally cuts to him as he is doing something on a computer, writing down a few numbers, or doing some more drumming. Again only behavior, as the film never bothers to come up with something for Burry to do that's dynamic, which might be true to life but who cares it's a movie. I frankly felt the film halted whenever it came back to Burry, at no fault of Bale's either. All you're left with is a guy acting like he has Asperger Syndrome. To Bale's credit, once again, he pulls it off, but film does not let him take Michael Burry anywhere past the set up.
Sunday, 17 January 2016
Best Supporting Actor 2015: Mark Rylance in Bridge of Spies
Mark Rylance won his Oscar from his first Oscar nomination for portraying Rudolf Abel in Bridge of Spies.
Bridge of Spies hits the old fashioned Hollywood sweet spot in its depiction of the story of James B. Donovan (Tom Hanks) an American Lawyer who tries to defend an accused Soviet spy.
The soviet spy is played by Mark Rylance who has been an extremely well respected stage actor though only recently expanded into film and television in terms of major projects, though he has been in both in the past. Rylance in 2015 received his most prominent roles in these mediums to date. The first being his television lead role as Cromwell in Wolf Hall, a performance that I would not be giving justice to by describing it in just a few sentences, and his role as Rudolf Abel in this film. Though Rylance is best known from the stage there's nothing at all theatrical about his work. The earliest scenes of the film we follow Abel as he is almost silent as he goes about his day as a spy. Now perhaps what one might be able to take as an indication of Rylance's background as a thespian though is how well he captures one's attention. Abel really is not doing anything of note in these scenes, other than finding a strange nickel with secret information, yet Rylance makes something inherently magnetic about him. Rylance then again is always doing much, though you'd never notice if you've never seen Rylance in anything other than this film, as he so naturally physically transforms himself in the role.
Rylance very quietly ages himself as he actually has a very distinct facial set he keeps that accentuates his aged features. In addition to that he projects a certain body language that carries that of an elderly man, but also a certain timid quality that seems an essential part of him, suggesting his years of being a spy who would have been careful in his interactions with almost anyone. There is something else that Rylance cleverly drives at with his performance, that is never really spoken in the open, is that Rudolf technically is always far more deceitful than he appears, after all Rudolf Abel is not even his real name. Rylance is terrific in the way that he sets up a man who would be unnoticed by most, and written off by many just because of how unassuming he always is. A great moment reflecting this trick, that Rylance is even pulling on the audience itself a bit, is as he's originally captured and Abel goes about destroying an important piece of evidence with CIA agents present. Rylance is unquestionably convincing in his portrayal of this as Rylance is so good in actually realizing Abel as the operator in this moment, as he so calmly takes care of his job that it's hard to notice that he even did it.
Of course Abel's time as a spy is short lived in the film as he is captured, and with no one willing to defend him the case goes to an insurance lawyer, Donovan, who also is quite hesitant to take on the case as well. Rylance's set up for Abel gives sense to his behavior as he refuses to divulge any information or even admit to being a spy. Rylance continues to be brilliantly enigmatic in the role as he makes Abel a very difficult man to comprehend fully, yet Rylance's portrayal never feels vague in the slightest. Rylance treads a fine line as his manner could just be assumed as a shy older man, or a cunning spy who is in fact deciphering everything going on through those tired eyes of his. Rylance even leaves his accent as an interesting curiosity as he delivers a slight Scottish touch to his accent that could be either the truth or just a certain layer of his cover. Now none of this is focused upon in terms of the main narrative by the film yet the detail Rylance brings to the role is remarkable, and adds a great deal to of substance the character of Abel. Rylance never leaves his Abel as a mere plot device, which he very, very easily could have been given how he specifically is used for the rest of the film. Rylance brings a so much more nuance to his depiction that he manages to Abel much more than that, and a captivating figure past the somewhat narrow focus we are given of him here.
Now that's a whole lot on just the earliest scenes of his performance but it is an essential part to the strength of his work as he makes Abel so much more, even before he set into the position in terms of how the story uses him. How the story uses him is technically in a more limited fashion, and in that was this is really a very old fashioned supporting performance in terms of both screen time and purpose. Once Donovan takes up the case the film keeps the focus most closely on him, and we see Abel through his perspective, where Abel is still quite the mystery. Rylance continues to be fantastic though in the role, and one moment I love early on is when Abel warns Donovan on what he might be getting himself into. Rylance brings a most incisive quality to his words that alludes to Rudolf's knowledge of the tensions involved in the Cold war. Donovan though has no desire to know the truth about Abel, after Abel denies taking a deal from the C.I.A. though and the view of him constricts a certain way, though this in no way makes Rylance's performance any less effective. Rylance deftly adjusts his performance to Abel in a way, doing what he believes is his sworn duty, in which is to remain as calm as possible while facing treason charges that very well might lead to his death through execution.
In this way Rylance again succeeds in somehow managing to make Abel an extremely endearing character of sorts despite what the charges are, or how bleak things look he will maintain his composure no matter what. Rylance is able to bridge this to being quite the capable comedic performance as well as he so wonderfully realizes Abel's dead pan demeanor through some impeccable timing particularly in his always amusing delivery of Abel's motto of "Would it Help" whenever Donovan questions this demeanor. At the same time though Rylance also manages to create a convincing friendship of sorts between Abel and Donovan. Rylance very smartly though eases into this idea, never giving Abel fully away, and actually only revealing his great capability of warmth after it becomes quite clear that Donovan only wants to give Abel a fair deal. Now if that's noy enough Rylance is also needed to add an extra bit of gravitas by verbalizing Donovan's personal struggle to defend Abel because of what is right, despite everyone is telling him he's wrong. This leads to Abel to tell Donovan a story from his childhood, about "a standing man" that he believes Donovan is similair to. The specific purpose of this scene very well could have fallen flat, if it were not for Rylance's absolutely flawless delivery of the monologue. Rylance brings the emotional power to the story with such ease to the moment as he vividly creates Abel's own memory through only his words, and absolutely brings the needed dramatic weight behind the moment for the film. Rylance has several challenges from the role, and he is required to fulfill them all despite him screen time begin somewhat limited, he is not present for a large chunk of the film. Technically there are several juicy scenes so to speak, but they could have come across as the most obvious of Oscar baiting given the shifts involved in terms of Abel's character. Rylance never allows this as he is able to be the elusive spy, the funny eccentric, the heartfelt friend, what ever is required of Abel. There is not a wasted moment as Rylance matches whatever a given scene requires him. I mean he even is heartbreaking as he somberly indicates to Donovan a possible terrible fate for himself, even though the film's own final text reveals that was never the case for him. Rylance makes every situation so honest, that it never seems odd that Abel is so many things. He flawlessly coheres all these various ideas for Abel into a single fascinating portrait of a man.
Bridge of Spies hits the old fashioned Hollywood sweet spot in its depiction of the story of James B. Donovan (Tom Hanks) an American Lawyer who tries to defend an accused Soviet spy.
The soviet spy is played by Mark Rylance who has been an extremely well respected stage actor though only recently expanded into film and television in terms of major projects, though he has been in both in the past. Rylance in 2015 received his most prominent roles in these mediums to date. The first being his television lead role as Cromwell in Wolf Hall, a performance that I would not be giving justice to by describing it in just a few sentences, and his role as Rudolf Abel in this film. Though Rylance is best known from the stage there's nothing at all theatrical about his work. The earliest scenes of the film we follow Abel as he is almost silent as he goes about his day as a spy. Now perhaps what one might be able to take as an indication of Rylance's background as a thespian though is how well he captures one's attention. Abel really is not doing anything of note in these scenes, other than finding a strange nickel with secret information, yet Rylance makes something inherently magnetic about him. Rylance then again is always doing much, though you'd never notice if you've never seen Rylance in anything other than this film, as he so naturally physically transforms himself in the role.
Rylance very quietly ages himself as he actually has a very distinct facial set he keeps that accentuates his aged features. In addition to that he projects a certain body language that carries that of an elderly man, but also a certain timid quality that seems an essential part of him, suggesting his years of being a spy who would have been careful in his interactions with almost anyone. There is something else that Rylance cleverly drives at with his performance, that is never really spoken in the open, is that Rudolf technically is always far more deceitful than he appears, after all Rudolf Abel is not even his real name. Rylance is terrific in the way that he sets up a man who would be unnoticed by most, and written off by many just because of how unassuming he always is. A great moment reflecting this trick, that Rylance is even pulling on the audience itself a bit, is as he's originally captured and Abel goes about destroying an important piece of evidence with CIA agents present. Rylance is unquestionably convincing in his portrayal of this as Rylance is so good in actually realizing Abel as the operator in this moment, as he so calmly takes care of his job that it's hard to notice that he even did it.
Of course Abel's time as a spy is short lived in the film as he is captured, and with no one willing to defend him the case goes to an insurance lawyer, Donovan, who also is quite hesitant to take on the case as well. Rylance's set up for Abel gives sense to his behavior as he refuses to divulge any information or even admit to being a spy. Rylance continues to be brilliantly enigmatic in the role as he makes Abel a very difficult man to comprehend fully, yet Rylance's portrayal never feels vague in the slightest. Rylance treads a fine line as his manner could just be assumed as a shy older man, or a cunning spy who is in fact deciphering everything going on through those tired eyes of his. Rylance even leaves his accent as an interesting curiosity as he delivers a slight Scottish touch to his accent that could be either the truth or just a certain layer of his cover. Now none of this is focused upon in terms of the main narrative by the film yet the detail Rylance brings to the role is remarkable, and adds a great deal to of substance the character of Abel. Rylance never leaves his Abel as a mere plot device, which he very, very easily could have been given how he specifically is used for the rest of the film. Rylance brings a so much more nuance to his depiction that he manages to Abel much more than that, and a captivating figure past the somewhat narrow focus we are given of him here.
Now that's a whole lot on just the earliest scenes of his performance but it is an essential part to the strength of his work as he makes Abel so much more, even before he set into the position in terms of how the story uses him. How the story uses him is technically in a more limited fashion, and in that was this is really a very old fashioned supporting performance in terms of both screen time and purpose. Once Donovan takes up the case the film keeps the focus most closely on him, and we see Abel through his perspective, where Abel is still quite the mystery. Rylance continues to be fantastic though in the role, and one moment I love early on is when Abel warns Donovan on what he might be getting himself into. Rylance brings a most incisive quality to his words that alludes to Rudolf's knowledge of the tensions involved in the Cold war. Donovan though has no desire to know the truth about Abel, after Abel denies taking a deal from the C.I.A. though and the view of him constricts a certain way, though this in no way makes Rylance's performance any less effective. Rylance deftly adjusts his performance to Abel in a way, doing what he believes is his sworn duty, in which is to remain as calm as possible while facing treason charges that very well might lead to his death through execution.
In this way Rylance again succeeds in somehow managing to make Abel an extremely endearing character of sorts despite what the charges are, or how bleak things look he will maintain his composure no matter what. Rylance is able to bridge this to being quite the capable comedic performance as well as he so wonderfully realizes Abel's dead pan demeanor through some impeccable timing particularly in his always amusing delivery of Abel's motto of "Would it Help" whenever Donovan questions this demeanor. At the same time though Rylance also manages to create a convincing friendship of sorts between Abel and Donovan. Rylance very smartly though eases into this idea, never giving Abel fully away, and actually only revealing his great capability of warmth after it becomes quite clear that Donovan only wants to give Abel a fair deal. Now if that's noy enough Rylance is also needed to add an extra bit of gravitas by verbalizing Donovan's personal struggle to defend Abel because of what is right, despite everyone is telling him he's wrong. This leads to Abel to tell Donovan a story from his childhood, about "a standing man" that he believes Donovan is similair to. The specific purpose of this scene very well could have fallen flat, if it were not for Rylance's absolutely flawless delivery of the monologue. Rylance brings the emotional power to the story with such ease to the moment as he vividly creates Abel's own memory through only his words, and absolutely brings the needed dramatic weight behind the moment for the film. Rylance has several challenges from the role, and he is required to fulfill them all despite him screen time begin somewhat limited, he is not present for a large chunk of the film. Technically there are several juicy scenes so to speak, but they could have come across as the most obvious of Oscar baiting given the shifts involved in terms of Abel's character. Rylance never allows this as he is able to be the elusive spy, the funny eccentric, the heartfelt friend, what ever is required of Abel. There is not a wasted moment as Rylance matches whatever a given scene requires him. I mean he even is heartbreaking as he somberly indicates to Donovan a possible terrible fate for himself, even though the film's own final text reveals that was never the case for him. Rylance makes every situation so honest, that it never seems odd that Abel is so many things. He flawlessly coheres all these various ideas for Abel into a single fascinating portrait of a man.
Friday, 15 January 2016
Best Supporting Actor 2015: Sylvester Stallone in Creed
Sylvester Stallone received his second acting Oscar nomination for reprising the role of Rocky Balboa in Creed.
Creed is the excellent seventh film in the Rocky series that follows Apollo Creed's son Adonis (Michael B. Jordan) as he tries to make his way as a professional boxer.
Sylvester Stallone once again returns as Rocky, though for the first time Rocky is in the position of the supporting role of the film. Now Rocky has been through a lot as a character, he started out so meekly, became champ through two difficult fights, had to beat Mr. T, bought a robot, fought a giant Russian, climbed a mountain to defeat said Russian, was in a horrible sequel, then was in a much better sequel that seemed made just to erase that terrible film out of memory. Rocky's never gone completely stale as a character, now I'll admit part of that is that he is a bit fluid or he has been over the films in terms of his IQ, as well as his physical conditions. Of course one more time could be one too many, it was for five though six fixed that. How about seventh? Well on the point this is very much the continuation of the down to earth guy found in the original and Rocky Balboa. Stallone is as comfortable as he's ever been in the role as Adonis first comes to see him at his restaurant with Rocky being unaware of who he is. Stallone though does not merely just come in and play Rocky from scratch again. Stallone instead represents a Rocky who's gone through all the films (perhaps a more down to earth rocky IV), and more.
Now what made Rocky one of the one iconic of all movie characters can once again be found in Stallone here. That very certain charm that Rocky has is once again evident. Now I have to be honest I've in the past not really given proper credit to this in some of Stallone's other turns as Rocky. Rocky's charm is not that of Stallone's per se, Rocky is not like any other characters Stallone has played or actually like Stallone himself. There is something that Stallone does so well in portraying Rocky's certain simple sensibilities and the fact that Rocky is not exactly the smartest guy who ever lived. Stallone does something special with this, which is evident in Creed, particularly in one exchange about the location of a "cloud", as it was in the original Rocky, which is he allows you to laugh about these certain shortcomings Rocky has without it seeming as though your laughing at him. A reason for that is Stallone who always plays Rocky as a man who's aware of these shortcomings, and is able to embrace them himself. Stallone makes Rocky a man truly without any pretensions over himself, and honestly is barely able to believe the position he has been able to attain for himself. Stallone is naturally endearing here, and once again makes Rocky just a hero you want to see succeed.
Rocky this time of course has no boxing match to fight himself, and instead it is about Rocky taking Adonis under his wing as a trainer. Rocky technically is now fitting into the role once fulfilled by Mickey (Burgess Meredith) in the original film, but this is in no way Stallone's attempt to copy that type of mentor role. Instead there is something very different in the methods of Rocky as he tries to help Adonis best he can. Rocky is and has always been a fairly easy going guy and Stallone correctly keeps this as the central idea as he earnestly though slowly shows Adonis the ropes on how to prepare for a big fight. What's so special that comes from these scenes is the development of the relationship between Adonis and Rocky. Technically speaking the two of them just being tossed together shouldn't necessarily work, but oh does it thanks to Jordan and Stallone's performances. The two develop fantastic chemistry together and they make it instantly convincing that they two so naturally become friends, when in reality the film makes it really a given. Stallone and Jordan allow it to be this way though as they work so well in tandem with one another, with Stallone's more unassuming approach with Rocky making such a great foil against Jordan's more eager and aggressive approach with Adonis.
Now again coming back to this being a reprise of Rocky, Stallone does not waste the fact that he had six other films with the character. Stallone in Rocky's early conversations with Adonis about the past in regards to Apollo, as well as the scenes where he mentions in passing his wife or his best friend Paulie, is incredibly affecting. Stallone carries this quiet melancholy in Rocky suggesting the memories of his past losses are just a part of him that he has to live with now, but within that unconditional optimism that just seems to be just a part of his soul. Stallone does not depict Rocky as really dwelling upon them as he goes about his day, but rather it as just a part of life now. Eventually yet another tragedy befalls Rocky in the story when he is diagnosed with Non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Stallone makes the moment absolutely heartbreaking through his reaction. What's so devastating about it is Stallone does not portray Rocky as someone breaking down from the news, but instead Stallone plays it as though he knew something like this was coming sooner rather than later, as though it is just the one last thing for him to lose. It is in this scene and the succeeding ones where Stallone depicts Rocky without that glint of hope in his eyes as it finally seems that Rocky would rather just give up on this fight.
Eventually this leads to Adonis confronting Rocky on Rocky just giving up. Stallone is outstanding in the scene as Rocky finally allows the extent of his sadness out, having kept inside for so long. It's such a powerful moment due Stallone's work as Rocky reveals how much he misses the past, not due to his stature as a boxer, but in his inability to ever see his wife again. What's so special is Stallone echos the romance that was so pivotal in the past films, as Rocky speaks, as Stallone realizes those glimmers of joy within this moment of despair. It's such a moving moment as Stallone finds just how much what was left behind meant to Rocky, but actually even how much Rocky means to us. Rocky's turn around though, motivated in large part by Adonis, isn't given a precise moment. Instead again Stallone is amazing in the way he just gradually brings back that spark in Rocky, that has always been a pivotal part of his character, as he guides and encourages Adonis to live his own dream. The warmth in this Stallone finds in a genuinely inspiring fashion, as he finds what helping Adonis really does mean to Rocky by the end. The film ends with what is often one of the most emotional moments in any Rocky film, that being when he runs up the steps of the Philadelphia Art Museum. This time though Rocky does not run but walks, with some help by Adonis, to get to the top at least one last time. Even the physical trouble that Stallone moves as a man of old age, shows all that's Rocky been through, and even though its not a triumphant rush to the top, it still feels like a victory. The contentment in Rocky's eyes is something that Stallone has justified through all of Rocky's terrible hardships. I have heard the blanket statement that reprising a role is easier. Although it's true the actor has been there before, its even harder to bring something new, and this is the seventh time. Stallone's great performance does this as he not only takes Rocky to a new place in his life with his work as Creed, which works all within the context of Creed alone but also acts as a statement on the whole life of Rocky Balboa throughout the entire series.
Sylvester Stallone once again returns as Rocky, though for the first time Rocky is in the position of the supporting role of the film. Now Rocky has been through a lot as a character, he started out so meekly, became champ through two difficult fights, had to beat Mr. T, bought a robot, fought a giant Russian, climbed a mountain to defeat said Russian, was in a horrible sequel, then was in a much better sequel that seemed made just to erase that terrible film out of memory. Rocky's never gone completely stale as a character, now I'll admit part of that is that he is a bit fluid or he has been over the films in terms of his IQ, as well as his physical conditions. Of course one more time could be one too many, it was for five though six fixed that. How about seventh? Well on the point this is very much the continuation of the down to earth guy found in the original and Rocky Balboa. Stallone is as comfortable as he's ever been in the role as Adonis first comes to see him at his restaurant with Rocky being unaware of who he is. Stallone though does not merely just come in and play Rocky from scratch again. Stallone instead represents a Rocky who's gone through all the films (perhaps a more down to earth rocky IV), and more.
Now what made Rocky one of the one iconic of all movie characters can once again be found in Stallone here. That very certain charm that Rocky has is once again evident. Now I have to be honest I've in the past not really given proper credit to this in some of Stallone's other turns as Rocky. Rocky's charm is not that of Stallone's per se, Rocky is not like any other characters Stallone has played or actually like Stallone himself. There is something that Stallone does so well in portraying Rocky's certain simple sensibilities and the fact that Rocky is not exactly the smartest guy who ever lived. Stallone does something special with this, which is evident in Creed, particularly in one exchange about the location of a "cloud", as it was in the original Rocky, which is he allows you to laugh about these certain shortcomings Rocky has without it seeming as though your laughing at him. A reason for that is Stallone who always plays Rocky as a man who's aware of these shortcomings, and is able to embrace them himself. Stallone makes Rocky a man truly without any pretensions over himself, and honestly is barely able to believe the position he has been able to attain for himself. Stallone is naturally endearing here, and once again makes Rocky just a hero you want to see succeed.
Rocky this time of course has no boxing match to fight himself, and instead it is about Rocky taking Adonis under his wing as a trainer. Rocky technically is now fitting into the role once fulfilled by Mickey (Burgess Meredith) in the original film, but this is in no way Stallone's attempt to copy that type of mentor role. Instead there is something very different in the methods of Rocky as he tries to help Adonis best he can. Rocky is and has always been a fairly easy going guy and Stallone correctly keeps this as the central idea as he earnestly though slowly shows Adonis the ropes on how to prepare for a big fight. What's so special that comes from these scenes is the development of the relationship between Adonis and Rocky. Technically speaking the two of them just being tossed together shouldn't necessarily work, but oh does it thanks to Jordan and Stallone's performances. The two develop fantastic chemistry together and they make it instantly convincing that they two so naturally become friends, when in reality the film makes it really a given. Stallone and Jordan allow it to be this way though as they work so well in tandem with one another, with Stallone's more unassuming approach with Rocky making such a great foil against Jordan's more eager and aggressive approach with Adonis.
Now again coming back to this being a reprise of Rocky, Stallone does not waste the fact that he had six other films with the character. Stallone in Rocky's early conversations with Adonis about the past in regards to Apollo, as well as the scenes where he mentions in passing his wife or his best friend Paulie, is incredibly affecting. Stallone carries this quiet melancholy in Rocky suggesting the memories of his past losses are just a part of him that he has to live with now, but within that unconditional optimism that just seems to be just a part of his soul. Stallone does not depict Rocky as really dwelling upon them as he goes about his day, but rather it as just a part of life now. Eventually yet another tragedy befalls Rocky in the story when he is diagnosed with Non-Hodgkin lymphoma. Stallone makes the moment absolutely heartbreaking through his reaction. What's so devastating about it is Stallone does not portray Rocky as someone breaking down from the news, but instead Stallone plays it as though he knew something like this was coming sooner rather than later, as though it is just the one last thing for him to lose. It is in this scene and the succeeding ones where Stallone depicts Rocky without that glint of hope in his eyes as it finally seems that Rocky would rather just give up on this fight.
Eventually this leads to Adonis confronting Rocky on Rocky just giving up. Stallone is outstanding in the scene as Rocky finally allows the extent of his sadness out, having kept inside for so long. It's such a powerful moment due Stallone's work as Rocky reveals how much he misses the past, not due to his stature as a boxer, but in his inability to ever see his wife again. What's so special is Stallone echos the romance that was so pivotal in the past films, as Rocky speaks, as Stallone realizes those glimmers of joy within this moment of despair. It's such a moving moment as Stallone finds just how much what was left behind meant to Rocky, but actually even how much Rocky means to us. Rocky's turn around though, motivated in large part by Adonis, isn't given a precise moment. Instead again Stallone is amazing in the way he just gradually brings back that spark in Rocky, that has always been a pivotal part of his character, as he guides and encourages Adonis to live his own dream. The warmth in this Stallone finds in a genuinely inspiring fashion, as he finds what helping Adonis really does mean to Rocky by the end. The film ends with what is often one of the most emotional moments in any Rocky film, that being when he runs up the steps of the Philadelphia Art Museum. This time though Rocky does not run but walks, with some help by Adonis, to get to the top at least one last time. Even the physical trouble that Stallone moves as a man of old age, shows all that's Rocky been through, and even though its not a triumphant rush to the top, it still feels like a victory. The contentment in Rocky's eyes is something that Stallone has justified through all of Rocky's terrible hardships. I have heard the blanket statement that reprising a role is easier. Although it's true the actor has been there before, its even harder to bring something new, and this is the seventh time. Stallone's great performance does this as he not only takes Rocky to a new place in his life with his work as Creed, which works all within the context of Creed alone but also acts as a statement on the whole life of Rocky Balboa throughout the entire series.
Thursday, 14 January 2016
Best Supporting Actor 2015: Mark Ruffalo in Spotlight
Mark Ruffalo received his third Oscar nomination for portraying Mike Rezendes in Spotlight.
Spotlight is a compelling procedural that depicts the Boston Globe's attempt to discover the sex scandal cover up involving the Catholic Church.
Spotlight as a film takes a specifically rather unassuming approach in potentially very incendiary material, just imagine if say Oliver Stone made the film instead for example. Although there's a definite emotional undercurrent to the story, the film stays focused on the way the reporters found the facts of the matter to build their story, while they often have to internalize what they learn from each new witness. The cast seems to understand that and for the most part they give performances that focus on being realistic above else, well except for the guy I'm reviewing today. The first time we meet Mark Ruffalo's Mike Rezendes is when we follow Michael Keaton's Robby Robinson as he enters the Spotlight room which will be heading the investigation. The other people are doing their jobs and in turn just seem like normal people doing their jobs, then there is Mark Ruffalo. Oh Mike's doing his job too, but there just seems something odd about it as he speaks to his fellow reporters. Everything he says he delivers quickly with a strange monotone way of speaking, and then just the way Ruffalo leans over his desk it as though Mike seems to be preparing for an off Broadway production of The Hunchback of Notre Dame.
Unfortunately this is not one odd scene for Mike, this is Ruffalo's whole performance. No matter what's going on in the scene Ruffalo feels he has to do something a bit atypical. He's always leaning in some odd way, his expressions in the group meeting scenes always have this odd gaze to them, his hands frequently find his pockets as though he's James Dean looking for a nickle. He even gets on some good old gum chewing just for good measure. There's not a scene where Ruffalo heeds to the criminal's warning "act natural". Everything he does is seemingly to get you to say is that oh boy that Mike Rezendes sure is a character. What I'm trying to say is that this is an extremely mannered performance, as about as mannered of a performance can get to be honest. Ruffalo does not seem to be content to do anything just you know, normal, it all has to be something else. Now my two favorite Ruffalo performances are Foxcatcher and Zodiac. Those are technically both mannered themselves. The thing is though those performances you don't notice are mannered until you are getting into a detailed discussion about them. Everything he did in those two performances seemed right for the respective characters, and seemed to fit right in with the rest of the film.
That is not the case in Spotlight. Everyone else gives performances that honestly are very supportive of each other only trying to standout when it is the right time to. Ruffalo always wants to stand out which is ill fitting for the calm way everyone else plays their parts. The funny thing is there is another technically very mannered performance in the film. That being Liev Schreiber's as the new boss of the Globe. What Schreiber does though is unassuming in a way that it just feels natural to his character, in addition to that he never seems to be doing it to directly get attention, that always seems to be the case for Ruffalo. Now Ruffalo does indeed stand out in any scene he is in, but unfortunately that's not a good thing. In the group scenes he's just distracting as the rest of the ensemble is playing it straight, keeping the focus on the story, but Ruffalo is busy doing something weird that surely Mike Rezendes must do. Ruffalo can't seem to help himself and the problem is that it hurts the film. There is one moment where one of the victims is telling his story, a moving scene to be sure, but when the victim reveals his dad committed suicide Ruffalo's odd delivery of "Jesus!" instantly makes the scene lose some its power as it all of the sudden seems to be about Ruffalo's performance rather than the victim's story.
For most of the film Ruffalo just stands as this oddball thing interacting with real people. He's a blemish in any frame because he just can't seem genuine even for a moment, and is particularly off-putting due to the film's very straight forward style. Now though he's the wrong kind of distraction for the most of the film, which is made up to a point by the fine work by the rest of ensemble, another bigger problem comes near the end of the film. The film again plays it low key as most of the actors just internalize either the pain or disgust involved with the molestation as well as the cover up. That is until one of them has a bit of an emotional outburst. It could have been an great moment if the scene belonged to one of the other actors, but instead this is given to old Ruffalo. Ruffalo does not build up to this point because he's too stuck in his weird slants and cockeyed looks to effectively build the outrage brewing in Mike. Ruffalo does not earn it in the least, the passion feels sanctimonious unfortunately, and frankly a bit whiny. When Keaton's Robby asks him in exasperation "You Finished?", that's how I felt as well. The moment should have been cathartic but its not because of Ruffalo. Apparently Ruffalo prepared for the role by asking the real Mike Rezendes to say lines for him. Perhaps Ruffalo has never seen the Jackie Robinson Story, but asking the real guy to play himself isn't always the best idea. This actually makes sense as Ruffalo's performance feels like an imitation of an imitation. It's all surface posturing from Mark Ruffalo as he not only fails to make Mike Rezendes convincing as a character, but he fails the film itself. His presence hurts the film as he becomes something false within a film that is striving for authenticity.
Spotlight is a compelling procedural that depicts the Boston Globe's attempt to discover the sex scandal cover up involving the Catholic Church.
Spotlight as a film takes a specifically rather unassuming approach in potentially very incendiary material, just imagine if say Oliver Stone made the film instead for example. Although there's a definite emotional undercurrent to the story, the film stays focused on the way the reporters found the facts of the matter to build their story, while they often have to internalize what they learn from each new witness. The cast seems to understand that and for the most part they give performances that focus on being realistic above else, well except for the guy I'm reviewing today. The first time we meet Mark Ruffalo's Mike Rezendes is when we follow Michael Keaton's Robby Robinson as he enters the Spotlight room which will be heading the investigation. The other people are doing their jobs and in turn just seem like normal people doing their jobs, then there is Mark Ruffalo. Oh Mike's doing his job too, but there just seems something odd about it as he speaks to his fellow reporters. Everything he says he delivers quickly with a strange monotone way of speaking, and then just the way Ruffalo leans over his desk it as though Mike seems to be preparing for an off Broadway production of The Hunchback of Notre Dame.
Unfortunately this is not one odd scene for Mike, this is Ruffalo's whole performance. No matter what's going on in the scene Ruffalo feels he has to do something a bit atypical. He's always leaning in some odd way, his expressions in the group meeting scenes always have this odd gaze to them, his hands frequently find his pockets as though he's James Dean looking for a nickle. He even gets on some good old gum chewing just for good measure. There's not a scene where Ruffalo heeds to the criminal's warning "act natural". Everything he does is seemingly to get you to say is that oh boy that Mike Rezendes sure is a character. What I'm trying to say is that this is an extremely mannered performance, as about as mannered of a performance can get to be honest. Ruffalo does not seem to be content to do anything just you know, normal, it all has to be something else. Now my two favorite Ruffalo performances are Foxcatcher and Zodiac. Those are technically both mannered themselves. The thing is though those performances you don't notice are mannered until you are getting into a detailed discussion about them. Everything he did in those two performances seemed right for the respective characters, and seemed to fit right in with the rest of the film.
That is not the case in Spotlight. Everyone else gives performances that honestly are very supportive of each other only trying to standout when it is the right time to. Ruffalo always wants to stand out which is ill fitting for the calm way everyone else plays their parts. The funny thing is there is another technically very mannered performance in the film. That being Liev Schreiber's as the new boss of the Globe. What Schreiber does though is unassuming in a way that it just feels natural to his character, in addition to that he never seems to be doing it to directly get attention, that always seems to be the case for Ruffalo. Now Ruffalo does indeed stand out in any scene he is in, but unfortunately that's not a good thing. In the group scenes he's just distracting as the rest of the ensemble is playing it straight, keeping the focus on the story, but Ruffalo is busy doing something weird that surely Mike Rezendes must do. Ruffalo can't seem to help himself and the problem is that it hurts the film. There is one moment where one of the victims is telling his story, a moving scene to be sure, but when the victim reveals his dad committed suicide Ruffalo's odd delivery of "Jesus!" instantly makes the scene lose some its power as it all of the sudden seems to be about Ruffalo's performance rather than the victim's story.
For most of the film Ruffalo just stands as this oddball thing interacting with real people. He's a blemish in any frame because he just can't seem genuine even for a moment, and is particularly off-putting due to the film's very straight forward style. Now though he's the wrong kind of distraction for the most of the film, which is made up to a point by the fine work by the rest of ensemble, another bigger problem comes near the end of the film. The film again plays it low key as most of the actors just internalize either the pain or disgust involved with the molestation as well as the cover up. That is until one of them has a bit of an emotional outburst. It could have been an great moment if the scene belonged to one of the other actors, but instead this is given to old Ruffalo. Ruffalo does not build up to this point because he's too stuck in his weird slants and cockeyed looks to effectively build the outrage brewing in Mike. Ruffalo does not earn it in the least, the passion feels sanctimonious unfortunately, and frankly a bit whiny. When Keaton's Robby asks him in exasperation "You Finished?", that's how I felt as well. The moment should have been cathartic but its not because of Ruffalo. Apparently Ruffalo prepared for the role by asking the real Mike Rezendes to say lines for him. Perhaps Ruffalo has never seen the Jackie Robinson Story, but asking the real guy to play himself isn't always the best idea. This actually makes sense as Ruffalo's performance feels like an imitation of an imitation. It's all surface posturing from Mark Ruffalo as he not only fails to make Mike Rezendes convincing as a character, but he fails the film itself. His presence hurts the film as he becomes something false within a film that is striving for authenticity.
Best Supporting Actor 2015
Mark Ruffalo in Spotlight
Mark Rylance in Bridge of Spies
Sylvester Stallone in Creed
Christian Bale in The Big Short
Tom Hardy in The Revenant
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)




