Showing posts with label Oliver Reed. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Oliver Reed. Show all posts

Tuesday, 9 August 2022

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1979: Results


5. David Warner in Time After Time - Warner as expected gives a properly calm and menacing portrayal of Jack the Ripper. 

Best Scene: Hotel room.
4. Frederic Forrest - Forrest gives yet another striking portrayal within his film, giving such a potent portrayal of a man struggling to maintain his sanity in an insane world. 

Best Scene: Civilian boat.
3. Art Carney in Going in Style - Carney gives a funny but also moving portrayal of a man attempting to live out a fantasy of sorts. 

Best Scene: Listening to Willie's story. 
2. Oliver Reed in The Brood - Reed gives a striking portrayal of a strange form of therapy while also so carefully walking a rope of ambiguity within his character. 

Best Scene: Opening. 
1. Yaphet Kotto in Alien - Kotto gives a great performance, often between the lines, in just creating such an endearing energy that shifts naturally to a fierce intensity as the situation becomes dire. 

Best Scene: Destroying Ash. 

Next: 1981 Lead

Friday, 5 August 2022

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1979: Oliver Reed in The Brood

Oliver Reed did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Dr. Hal Raglan in The Brood.

The Brood marks a step in Cronenberg's career, where he doesn't quite achieve a wholly successful horror film, though gets a bit closer than Shivers about a man investigating his wife's strange psychiatrist while brutal murders begin to occur. Where the film suffers is in its bland lead Frank (though I think more so the writing here overall), and the makeup effects not *quite* being there, it's definitely a problem when I started laughing at what is supposed to be a disturbing murder scene. 

Anyway, one advancement offered to Cronenberg was a greater budget and seems like with that Cronenberg used it to bring along two more notable actors in Samantha Eggar as our hero's strange wife Nola going through isolated therapy, and Oliver Reed as her strange doctor. Reed opens the film as we see the doctor's methods firsthand as he "treats" a patient. Dressed in a guru's robe, seated and staring right at the man Reed makes a fascinating first impression. Reed's performance in a way illustrates his unique talent a presence because he is such a ferocious physical presence, yet has such an elegant voice. Here we get this in such a brilliant performance as he "treats" his patient by attacking the man on his said to be feminine qualities. Reed's eyes stare right into the man's soul, honestly similar to the first processing scene later seen in The Master, as Reed has that enigmatic power as the man seems to cut right into the man's mind. Reed's performance is amazing because he manages to be incredibly violent in his deliveries of the insults (seemingly evoking the man's abusive father), but Reed's dulcet voice seems to redirect the energy slightly as though he is performing some kind of therapy still. There is a strange comfort even in the violence and he illustrates this as in the end, he seems to indeed have a breakthrough with the man even after all that had been said. It is a bizarre scene that works because of Reed's performance that does naturally realize Hal's strange methods in tangible ways. What Reed also does with this play with the audience's expectation of his performance as he doesn't allow you to pinpoint what exactly the doctor is, whether is he an evil man or is there some method to this madness. Reed plays with ambiguity so effortlessly as we see him outside of the sphere of performing his therapy as Frank confronts him about his daughter having been hurt after visiting his wife. Reed is quite fascinating in his performance in that every delivery of his is a kind deflection though also calming in his responses. Reed doesn't specify but he alludes to something. Reed's eyes suggest a man knowing far more than he is saying, but doesn't simplify what exactly that is. 

He creates a marvelous idea of perhaps an egomaniac doctor refusing to have his methods questioned or someone dealing with something he isn't quite sure of himself. We occasionally see him in his scenes with Eggar (who is wonderfully bonkers in the role), where Reed shows the doctor playing his role. Reed asking her about her daughter's injuries, though not directly, and is fascinating in that he plays her parent at the moment while also seemingly trying to derive something more from her. Again I think even a lot of the dialogue here works because Reed is so convincing in his portrayal of it, and makes the techniques tangible as odd as they are. Reed is captivating in every one of his scenes whether he is playing directly the form of therapy of the doctor, or the therapist who seems to be hiding much from those questioning him. Reed creates this force to be reckoned with and also an element of this film that consistently works, both being actively compelling in giving these strange ideas some truth in performance, but also by letting you ponder whether he is the true villain of the piece or not. Spoilers he's technically not exactly either hero or villain, but his therapy led to the creation of small sinister creatures that kill Nola's "tormentors". Reed though is great in his final scene where he finally reveals the truth to Frank. Reed shows at this moment the man isn't trying to hide or try anything. His eyes at the moment totally earnest as he looks at Frank in the moment. He speaks now just trying to say everything as an honest statement of the man attempting to make some kind of amends with a regretful tone he brings to the whole moment. Reed is terrific in the film, a film that really with a lesser actor in this role would've been fully goofy I think. Reed though never treats the material as monster shlock, as it could've been treated, offering only a real depth and gravity in realizing both his character and the film's odd scenario. 

Monday, 25 July 2022

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1979

 And the Nominees Were Not:

Art Carney in Going in Style

Oliver Reed in The Brood

David Warner in Time After Time

Yaphet Kotto in Alien

Frederic Forrest in Apocalypse Now

Monday, 2 May 2016

Alternate Best Actor 1971: Results

5. Jon Finch in Macbeth - The film purposefully restricts his ability to explore the character, but Finch still manages to give an effective portrayal of the transformation of Macbeth particularly in the way he suggests his misdeeds age him.

Best Scene: Learning about the Lady
4. Al Pacino in The Panic in Needle Park - Pacino, unlike the film itself, creates an understanding in his character's disjointed nature effectively showing the different sides of such a man whether he's revealing an abundance of charm, or simply wasting away.

Best Scene: Bobby asks Helen to score for him.
3. Max von Sydow in The Emigrants -I apologize as I did not mean to shortchange this great actor, but I chose not to review the performance only because I felt I could not add anything to what I wrote about his work in the sequel where I felt he had a more dynamic character arc to realize since everything that's great in this performance can be seen there as well he only gets to explore the character further. This is also a very strong performance though that once again works through the sheer simple honesty he brings to the role, along with his marvelous chemistry with Liv Ullmann(who once again is perfection by the way) that works so in tandem with the wonderful vision realized by the film.

Best Scene: Watching over his sick wife.
2. Oliver Reed in The Devils - Reed gives a great performance as he stands as a needed straight man for the film, but also creates an affecting portrait of a priest devoted to his specific ideals.

Best Scene: Defending himself in court.
1. Paul Scofield in King Lear - Good Predictions RatedRStar, Michael Patison and Luke. Scofield more than proves his ability with the words of the bard, through his daring and truly powerful portrayal of the tragic king.

Best Scene: The storm.
Updated Overall (with a few extras):

Next Year: 1971 Supporting

Friday, 8 April 2016

Alternate Best Actor 1971: Oliver Reed in The Devils

Oliver Reed did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Father Urbain Grandier in The Devils.

The Devils is at the very least an interesting film about an anti-establishment priest being accused of witchcraft by a deranged nun.

Oliver Reed begins the film serving a very specific purpose, utilizing his apparent status as a heartthrob as he is ogled by the women in the convent due to his physical appearance. Although this will play an important part in terms of the development of the story, that thankfully is not Reed's only purpose within the film. The last two times I covered Oliver Reed it was in supporting roles as characters both shaped by violence. His leading turn here is in contrast to that as a most unusual priest. Now when we first see him he is just going about his duties as you'd expect any decent priest would, that being Reed brings the right solemn qualities as Grandier simply leads his flock so to speak. That is in a moment where he directly attached to being a servant of God though, and we quickly find Grandier is rather extraordinary priest to say this least. This comes to be seen the moment he mounts a different pulpit that being a political one to speak against the injustices attempted by the power hungry Cardinal Richelieu who wishes to persecute the protestants of France. Reed is outstanding in bringing the needed grand passion in Grandier's words as he denounces the Cardinal, and Reed realizes the righteous force which lies within him. Of course his less than ordinary ways as priest continue past the public sphere.

That refers to Grandier having various sexual liaisons with women which are not very well hidden, but again he does not try to either. Now this is an important aspect to the character which Reed develops very well. It is initially shown with Grandier certainly enjoying himself, which Reed does not shy away from suggesting a certain indulgence on the side of Grandier given an obvious lack of respect for one of the women he chooses to break his vows with. However Reed is quite good by providing the right honesty to Grandier's words as he states his lack of belief in the celibacy requirement. Now Reed does say this well, but it could still be seen earlier on as Grandier covering for himself. It goes beyond that when Grandier receives a confession from another woman Madeleine (Gemma Jones) who admits having sexual thoughts, and accidentally admits that they are about Grandier himself. Reed is excellent in this scene though as he calms her concerns by revealing Grandier's own approval of a lack of sexual repression. What's so wonderful about this is the way Reed brings such a tenderness in his words that never seem that of a lusty priest, but rather a benevolent man who believes this to be the intention of God.

Grandier soon take the woman Madeleine to be his wife by marrying her to himself. Reed in the ceremony scene again brings a powerful conviction to the words as Grandier fulfills his duty as a priest and as a husband at the same time. Reed in the moment reveals such a palatable devotion and belief in the ceremony. Reed is excellent in the scene as he seems to eliminate even the very idea that Grandier may at all be a hypocrite in the moment. Instead of seeming a man of going against what he believes, Reed is able to find the genuine fervor in Grandier's words, showing him to be a man of true faith whose actions are always directly connected with this faith. Reed's work is striking as he finds the perfect balance between a man of the world, and a religious priest. Reed is able to show it as one and the same, and in turn is able to develop Grandier as a rather special sort. It is not just a strong willed firebrand for justice, though he is indeed that, but also a true reformer. Reed's work is marvelous as he does not hide the elements of the man that one might normally consider saintly, yet allows you to understand everything that Grandier does that makes him seem to earn a certain degree of sainthood.

Now Oliver Reed essentially plays the one sane man in a mad country it seems, and in turn the one sane actor in a mad film. Now based on the evidence of this film and his later science fiction film Altered States it is obvious that director Ken Russell likely wholly encouraged an actor to go to for the extremes to match his equally flamboyant directorial style. Here the performances range from slightly off to full blown schizophrenia, but I don't mean that necessarily in a bad way. In this instance it works given the material which involves mass hysteria, but I would also say in part due to Oliver Reed. Reed is not in a different film, but he is importantly on a very different wavelength in terms of his approach for Grandier. Reed, much like Grandier himself, avoids the insanity imagined by Russell, just as Grandier avoids the insanity imagined by the nuns. Reed makes his performance very much stand out, in a very good way, by keeping Grandier very much a different person than the world around, by being so different from the film, as he goes about giving a realistic portrayal of this man. Reed acts as a necessary balancing factor in the film as he is steadfast in keeping Grandier as well as his performance wholly detached from the madness around them. 

Of course despite Grandier himself not being part of the mass hysteria, he unfortunately becomes the target of it due to the obsession of one nun in particular as well as because the power that be want him out of the way anyways. Grandier ends up being put in front of kangaroo court where he is accused of his crimes of witchcraft. Reed is excellent again playing so close to the chest which acts in such notable contrast to everyone else who is decidedly not doing so. Reed is very careful in this regard because it is never as though Grandier a meek man to begin, he does not mind speaking his mind, particularly not in the face of such madness. Once again Reed brings such conviction in the words as he tears into those persecuting him, while still connecting such affecting manner by always keeping close the humanity behind Grandier's passion. There is one particularly moving moment in his outrage, as Reed reveals such honest concern in Grandier when he learns that they are trying to use his wife against him as well. Now even Grandier's passion cannot change their minds, and the trial goes as one would expected with Grandier being tortured and sentenced to hang. Reed is devastating to watch in these scenes as he keeps the horror, which could seem absurd, so brutally grounded by making Grandier's physical degradation so painfully straight forward. Reed is most heartbreaking in his portrayal of Grandier losing his resolve to the point that Reed plays his final moments in a resigned disbelief that he has come to such an end. This is a great performance by Oliver Reed by not only anchoring a film, which could have completely fallen of the rails without him, but also by creating an understanding of this man through his effective depiction of this complex man.

Monday, 28 March 2016

Alternate Best Actor 1971

And the Nominees Were Not:

Oliver Reed in The Devils

Jon Finch in Macbeth

Paul Scofield in King Lear

Al Pacino in The Panic in Needle Park

Max von Sydow in The Emigrants

Friday, 15 November 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000: Results

5. Billy Crudup in Almost Famous- Crudup gives a good performance by showing both the good and the bad qualities which make a rock star.

Best Scene: Russell takes William to a party.
4. Joe Pantoliano in Memento- Pantoliano unfortunately overacts a bit, but he makes up for much of it by giving a complex portrayal of a man who knows much more than what he says he knows.

Best Scene: Teddy tells Leonard the truth.
3. Oliver Reed in Gladiator- Reed gives a compelling performance as a former gladiator champion although his performance is weakened by the fact that it remains an unfinished work.

Best Scene: Proximo tells Maximus how he achieved his freedom.
2. Takeshi Kitano in Battle Royale- Takeshi Kitano gives an effective turn by being the evil teacher he should be, but as well by showing why this man has come to be this way.

Best Scene: Kitano reveals his dream.
1. Jason Isaacs in The Patriot- This part asks one thing of Isaacs which is to be evil, and boy is he. Isaacs gives a striking performance by being unrelenting in his portrayal of the sadism of his character, while never once using the nature of his character as an excuse to overact.

Best Scene: Gabriel's attack on the dragoons.
Overall Rank:
  1. Malcolm McDowell in Gangster No. 1
  2. Paddy Considine in A Room For Romeo Brass
  3. Emilio Echevarria in Amores Perros
  4. Joaquin Phoenix in The Yards 
  5. Song Kang-ho in Joint Security Area
  6. Kyle MacLachlan in Hamlet
  7. Jason Isaacs in The Patriot
  8. Takeshi Kitano in Battle Royale
  9. Oliver Reed in Gladiator
  10. Sean Connery in Finding Forrester
  11. Stephen Tobolowsky in Memento  
  12. Benicio Del Toro in Traffic
  13. Tim Blake Nelson in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  14. Patrick Warburton in The Emperor's New Groove 
  15. Sam Shepard in Hamlet
  16. James Woods in The Virgin Suicides
  17. Philip Seymour Hoffman in Almost Famous 
  18. Lucas Black in All the Pretty Horses
  19. Michael Douglas in Traffic 
  20. Joe Pantoliano in Memento
  21. Liev Schreiber in Hamlet
  22. Billy Crudup in Almost Famous
  23. Taro Yamamoto in Battle Royale 
  24. Issey Ogata in Yi Yi
  25. Tom Wilkinson in The Patriot 
  26. Don Cheadle in Traffic 
  27. James Caan in The Yards 
  28. We Nien-jen in Yi Yi
  29. David Thewlis in Gangster No. 1  
  30. Mads Mikkelsen in Flickering Lights
  31. Alvaro Guerrero in Amores Perros
  32. Sousuke Takaoka in Battle Royale 
  33. Larry Holden in Memento
  34. John Turturro in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  35. Jeffrey Wright in Shaft 
  36. Peter Stormare in Dancer in the Dark
  37. Heath Ledger in The Patriot 
  38. Brad Pitt in Snatch
  39. Kim Tae-woo in Joint Security Area
  40. F. Murray Abraham in Finding Forrester 
  41. John C. Reilly in The Perfect Storm
  42. Gary Oldman in The Contender  
  43. Tony Haygarth in Chicken Run
  44. John Goodman in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  45. Alex Cox in Herod's Law
  46. David Morse in Dancer in the Dark
  47. Vin Diesel in Boiler Room
  48. Paul Schnedier in George Washington
  49. Donald Sutherland in Panic 
  50. John Hawkes in The Perfect Storm
  51. Shin Ha-kyun in Joint Security Area
  52. Morgan Freeman in Nurse Betty
  53. Jack Black in High Fidelity
  54. Chris Cooper in The Patriot
  55. Gael Garcia Bernal in Amores Perros 
  56. Bill Murray in Hamlet
  57. Marlon Wayans in Requiem for a Dream
  58. Timothy Spall in Chicken Run
  59. Takashi Tsukamoto in Battle Royale
  60. Richard Harris in Gladiator
  61. Michael Badalucco in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  62. Greg Kinnear in Nurse Betty
  63. Christian Bale in Shaft 
  64. John Ritter in Panic
  65. Benjamin Whitrow in Chicken Run
  66. Charles Durning in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  67. Eddie Marsan in Gangster No. 1
  68. Michael Caine in Quills 
  69. Robert Downey Jr. in Wonder Boys
  70. Steven Culp in Thirteen Days 
  71. Daniel Van Bargen in O Brother Where Art Thou?
  72. Masnobu Ando in Battle Royale 
  73. Gary Lewis in Billy Elliot 
  74. Lennie James in Snatch
  75. Eric Stoltz in The House of Mirth 
  76. Alan Ford in Snatch
  77. Clifton Collins Jr. in Tigerland 
  78. Dennis Farina in Snatch
  79. Kevin Conway in Thirteen Days
  80. Miguel Ferrer in Traffic
  81. Frank Wood in Thirteen Days
  82. Gene Hackman in The Replacements 
  83. Stephen Graham in Snatch
  84. Robert Duvall in The 6th Day
  85. René Auberjonois in The Patriot
  86. Dylan Baker in Thirteen Days 
  87. Don Cheadle in Mission to Mars 
  88. Bruce Davison in X-Men 
  89. Vinnie Jones in Snatch
  90. Willem Dafoe in American Psycho 
  91. Paul Mooney in Bamboozled
  92. David Hemmings in Gladiator 
  93. Rade Serbedzija in Snatch
  94. Ian McKellen in X-Men 
  95. Jason Statham in Snatch
  96. Tchéky Karyo in The Patriot
  97. Ray Park in X-Men 
  98. Dennis Quaid in Traffic 
  99. Udo Kier in Shadow of the Vampire
  100. Patrick Stewart in X-Men
  101. Terence Stamp in Red Planet
  102. Will Patton in Remember the Titans
  103. Keanu Reeves in The Gift
  104. Ron Rifkin in Boiler Room
  105. Jeremy Irons in Dungeons & Dragons
  106. Joaquin Phoenix in Gladiator
  107. Luis Guzman in Traffic 
  108. Albert Finney in Erin Brockovich
  109. Giovanni Ribsi in The Gift
  110. Djimon Honsou in Gladiator 
  111. Leon Rippy in The Patriot
  112. Jeff Bridges in The Contender
  113. Noah Taylor in Almost Famous  
  114. Ruben Blades in All the Pretty Horses
  115. Giovanni Ribsi in Gone in 60 Seconds
  116. Derek Jacobi in Gladiator 
  117. James Brolin in Traffic 
  118. Tommy Davidson in Bamboozled
  119. Jack Lemmon in The Legend of Beggar Vance 
  120. David Paymer in Bait 
  121. Dennis Haysbert in Love and Basketball
  122. Mark Boone Junior in Memento
  123. Paul Giamatti in Big Momma's House 
  124. Peter Woodward in The Patriot
  125. Xander Berkeley in Shanghai Noon
  126. Albert Finney in Traffic
  127. David Morse in Bait 
  128. Owen Wilson in Meet the Parents
  129. Eddie Izzard in Shadow of the Vampire 
  130. Greg Kinnear in The Gift
  131. Donnie Yen in Highlander Endgame 
  132. James Mardsen in X-Men
  133. Sam Elliot in The Contender
  134. Michael Clarke Duncan in The Whole Nine Yards
  135. Roger Yuan in Shanghai Noon
  136. Change Chen in Crouching Tiger, Hidden Dragon
  137. James Rebhorn in Meet the Parents 
  138. Adam Baldwin in The Patriot 
  139. Kevin Pollak in The Whole Nine Yards
  140. Carey Elwes in Shadow of the Vampire
  141. Topher Grace in Traffic
  142. Joey D. Vieira in The Patriot 
  143. Christian Slater in The Contender
  144. Jay Arlen Jones in The Patriot
  145. Tom Sizemore in Red Planet 
  146. Tobey Maguire in Wonder Boys
  147. Johnny Depp in Before Night Falls  
  148. Vincent D'Onofrio in The Cell
  149. Donal Logue in The Patriot 
  150. Johnny Depp in Chocolat
  151. Aaron Eckhart in Erin Brockovich
  152. Jason Lee in Almost Famous 
  153. Thomas Jefferson Byrd in Bamboozled
  154. Doug Hutchison in Bait
  155. Gregory Smith in The Patriot
  156. Orland Jones in Bedazzled 
  157. Mos Def in Bamboozled
  158. Christopher Eccleston in Gone in 60 Seconds
  159. Jerry O'Connell in Mission to Mars
  160. Rainn Wilson in Almost Famous
  161. Toby Huss in Bedazzled
  162. Will Smith in The Legend of Beggar Vance 
  163. Henry Thomas in All the Pretty Horses
  164. Shawn Ashmore in X-Men
  165. The Cast of The Grinch
  166. Larry Miller in The Nutty Professor II
  167. John Ales in The Nutty Professor II 
  168. Savior Glover in Bamboozled
  169. Cast of Little Nicky
  170. Cast of Road Trip
  171. Tyler Mane in X-Men 
  172. Chris Rock in Nurse Betty 
  173. Michael Rappaport in Bamboozled
  174. Forest Whitaker in Battlefield Earth
  175. Bruce Payne in Highlander Endgame
  176. Bruce Payne in Dungeons & Dragons
  177. Marlon Wayans in Dungeons & Dragons
Next Year: 1981 Lead

Thursday, 14 November 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000: Oliver Reed in Gladiator

Oliver Reed did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite being nominated for BAFTA, for portraying Proximo in Gladiator.

Oliver Reed plays Proximo the man who buys Maximus Decimus (Russell Crowe) after he has had his family murdered by the evil Emperor Commodus (Joaquin Phoenix). Proximo is a gladiator manager and owner, although he is a bit different in that he himself was a former Gladiator. Reed was an excellent choice to play the part having played many tough guy roles throughout his career and here he brings that sort of presence to this role. Although Proximo is aged, and most certainly past his prime, with Reed we can see what made him the great warrior he once was, and possibly how exactly how he once came to be the true champion of the Colosseum.

Reed plays both sides of the role very well. As the outer side, Reed shows Proximo to be a shrewd businessman. Reed brings the right sly attitude with a certain strong force of personality as Proximo showing him to be a man well versed in the nature of his trade. Proximo though does have the deeper connection with Gladiator's then just the money. Reed has one great scene where he tries to inspire his men to victory giving a hint of his own mastery of the arena. Reed is terrific as he thrusts with a knife portraying the powerful technique in Proximo, and suggesting exactly who Proximo once was when he had to save his life by ending another simply for entertainment purposes.

Oliver Reed's best scene though is when he encourages Maximus to be more than a killer, and be a showman who the crowd adores. In the scene Proximo describes when he was made free by the former emperor after becoming the champion of the arena. Reed handles the scene beautifully because it is not like he is just giving a lecture to Maximus. Reed instills the moment with a tremendous nostalgic pride and shows Proximo almost relive the moment as he gives the sense of the joy Proximo held when he finally achieved freedom so many years ago. It is a wonderfully acted scene by Reed, and it also properly alludes to why Proximo would be willing to give up his own livelihood to help Maximus late in the film.

This film was Reed's last one, and unfortunately he actually died during filming. All of Proximo's scenes were not completed and this is noticeable in the film. When everyone is captured in Proximo's compound the Roman guards for whatever reason kill Proximo even though they don't do the same to the slaves even the ones who have fought back. Of course this is a pretty obvious rewrite to compensate for Reed's untimely end. The required changes cuts Proximo short really. If Reed had lived it is pretty easy to see that Proximo probably would have had one more scene that would have given a more fitting end to his character, rather than the very quick exit his character receives in the film.

In my view Oliver Reed once again gives the best performance in a best picture winning film, even though once again his character is far from being even the most important supporting character in the film. Reed even with the fact that he really did not get to portray the actual conclusion of the character before his death makes Proximo a compelling character. I only wish there had been more of Proximo in the film as Reed makes him a fascinating part of the film even though the character could very well have made absolutely no impact on the film whatsoever. Oliver Reed brings out the complexities of the part incredibly well, and creates an interesting portrait of a gladiator after he has put away his sword.

Friday, 8 November 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000

And the Nominees Were Not:

Billy Crudup in Almost Famous

Takeshi Kitano in Battle Royale

Oliver Reed in Gladiator

Jason Isaacs in The Patriot

Joe Pantoliano in Memento

Monday, 25 February 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1968

5. Oliver Reed in Oliver!- Reed despite not singing actually gives the best performance in his film never failing to bring the menace with his performance.

Best Scene: Bill returns to Fagin after the murder. 
4. Michael York in Romeo and Juliet- York plays Tybalt as well as he really could be through his portrayal of the role with his pompous flamboyant delivery, and his success in bringing more weight to the role than one would expect.

Best Scene: Tybalt and Mercutio sword fight. 
3. Timothy Dalton in The Lion in Winter- Dalton despite having possibly the least screen time of the important characters in the film has one of the strongest impacts giving a powerful portrayal of the vengeful French King.

Best Scene: Henry is shown his children's secrets by Philip. 
2. Anthony Hopkins in The Lion in Winter- The hardest part of this ranking was determining between the two Lion in Winter supporting men who should have been nominated over Jack Wild and especially Daniel Massey. Hopkins is terrific in his role as Richard bringing across the power of the King in the man, but also being very powerful in his depiction of his vulnerabilities as well.

Best Scene: Philip manipulates Richard.
1. Jason Robards in Once Upon A Time in The West- Good Prediction Koook160. Robards gives a great performance in his very important supporting role in this film. He manages to be a humorous presence, an imposing one with some mystery, and even a tender one.

Best Scene: Cheyenne talks about his mother. 
Overall Rank:
  1. Jason Robards in Once Upon a Time in The West
  2. Henry Fonda in Once Upon a Time in The West
  3. Tony Curtis in The Boston Strangler
  4. Anthony Hopkins in The Lion in Winter
  5. Timothy Dalton in The Lion in Winter
  6. Tom Courtenay in A Dandy in Aspic
  7. Seymour Cassel in Faces
  8. James Mason in The Sea Gull
  9. Gabriele Ferzetti in Once Upon a Time in The West
  10. David Warner in The Sea Gull
  11. John McEnery in Romeo and Juliet 
  12. Ian Holm in The Bofors Gun
  13. Oliver Reed in Oliver!
  14. Telly Savalas in Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell
  15. Patrick Magee in The Birthday Party
  16. Klaus Kinski in The Great Silence
  17. Michael York in Romeo and Juliet
  18. Dirk Bogarde in The Fixer
  19. Sydney Tafler in The Birthday Party
  20. Oskar Werner in The Shoes of the Fisherman 
  21. Telly Savalas in The Scalphunters
  22. Gunner Bjornstrand in Shame
  23. Harry Andrews in The Sea Gull
  24. Trevor Howard in The Charge of the Light Brigade
  25. Milo O'Shea in Romeo and Juliet
  26. Patrick Wymark in Where Eagles Dare 
  27. John Gielgud in The Charge of the Light Brigade
  28. Percy Rodriguez in The Heart is a Lonely Hunter 
  29. Ian Holm in The Fixer
  30. Douglas Rain in 2001: A Space Odyssey
  31. John Castle in The Lion in Winter 
  32. Derren Nesbitt in Where Eagles Dare 
  33. Phil Silvers Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell
  34. Woody Strode in Once Upon a Time in The West
  35. Maurice Evans in Planet of the Apes 
  36. Jack Elam in Once Upon a Time in The West
  37. Alfred Lynch in The Sea Gull
  38. Robert Vaughn in Bullitt
  39. Stacy Keach in The Heart is a Lonely Hunter 
  40. Denholm Elliott in The Sea Gull
  41. Barry Foster in Twisted Nerve
  42. Pat Hingle in Hang Em High
  43. Michael Dunn in No Way to Treat a Lady
  44. William Hickey in The Boston Strangler 
  45. Massimo Girotti in Teorema
  46. Peter Cook in A Dandy in Aspic
  47. Michael Hordern in Where Eagles Dare 
  48. George Voskovec in The Boston Strangler
  49. John Cassavettes in Rosemary's Baby
  50. Harry Secombe in Oliver! 
  51. Roddy McDowall in Planet of the Apes 
  52. James Olson Rachel, Rachel
  53. Anton Diffring in Where Eagles Dare 
  54. Ralph Bellamy in Rosemary's Baby
  55. William Windom in The Detective 
  56. Charles Denner in The Bride Wore Black
  57. Robert Helpmann in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang 
  58. Michael Lonsdale in Stolen Kisses
  59. Terry Kiser in Rachel, Rachel
  60. Laurence Olivier in The Shoes of the Fisherman
  61. Eg Begley in Hang Em High
  62. Jack Wild in Oliver!
  63. Charles Grodin in Rosemary's Baby
  64. Patrick Wymark in Witchfinder General
  65. Peter Vaughn in The Bofors Gun 
  66. Jack Palance in The Mercenary
  67. Vittorio De Sica in The Shoes of the Fisherman
  68. Gary Lockwood in 2001: A Space Odyssey 
  69. Keenan Wynn in Once Upon a Time in The West 
  70. Herb Edelman in The Odd Couple
  71. Karl Hardman in Night of The Living Dead
  72. Dennis Hopper in Hang Em High
  73. George Kennedy in The Boston Strangler 
  74. Joby Baker in Blackbeard's Ghost
  75. Robert Beatty in Where Eagles Dare 
  76. Ben Johnson in Hang Em High
  77. John Fiedler in The Odd Couple 
  78. Claude Rich in The Bride Wore Black
  79. Robert Duvall in The Detective
  80. Jack Weston in The Thomas Crown Affair
  81. Frank Wolff in The Great Silence 
  82. Donald Houston in Where Eagles Dare 
  83. Hugh Griffith in Oliver! 
  84. Beau Bridges in For Love of Ivy
  85. Dick Van Patten in Charly
  86. Peter Lawford in Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell
  87. Murray Hamilton in The Boston Strangler
  88. Robert Russell in Witchfinder General
  89. Harry Andrews in The Charge of the Light Brigade
  90. Frank Wolff in Once Upon a Time in The West
  91. Sidney Blackmer in Rosemary's Baby
  92. Richard Warwick in If....
  93. Murray Hamilton in No Way To Treat A Lady 
  94. Jason Robards in Isadora 
  95. Benny Hill in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
  96. Arthur Lowe in If....
  97. Don Francks in Finian's Rainbow
  98. Phillippe Leroy in Buona Sera, Mrs. Campbell
  99. Lionel Stander in A Dandy in Aspic 
  100. James Fox in Isadora 
  101. Keenan Wynn in Finian's Rainbow
  102. Walter Pidgeon in Funny Girl
  103. Lionel Jeffries in Chitty Chitty Bang Bang
  104. Paolo Stoppa in Once Upon A Time in The West
  105. Daniel Massey in Star
  106. John Fraser in Isadora
  107. Lionel Stander in Once Upon a Time in The West
  108. Joseph O'Conor in Oliver!
  109. Tommy Steele in Finian's Rainbow
  110. Peter Bogdanovich in Targets
  111. Nigel Terry in The Lion in Winter
Next Year: 1951 Leading

Friday, 22 February 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1968: Oliver Reed in Oliver!

Oliver Reed did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Bill Sikes in Oliver!.

Oliver Reed plays Bill Sikes in this musical version of Oliver Twist, and although the film won best picture he was never going to be nominated as he plays what might be the least favorite type of Oscar character. Bill Sikes is just a despicable character, but without any "redeeming" style in the way he goes about being despicable. Although this is a musical adaptation and many of the characters are fairly lightened up through this adaption particularly Fagin and Artful Dodger, Oliver Reed's portrayal of Sikes makes no concessions for the fact that there is all sorts of singing and dancing around him.

Sikes actually had a song in the original musical, but it was removed from the film. This might have been done because Reed could not sing, but it was probably a good idea to remove Sikes singing making him stand out as a character who does not have a song in his heart. Reed plays Sikes insanely straight, and his portrayal of Sikes would have worked in a down and dirty adaptation of Oliver Twist. He goes for playing the character as Charles Dickens envisioned him. Reed portrayal of him does not ever try to avoid creating the extreme brutality that lies right within the character.

Oliver Reed is quite effective in his performance as Sikes as he brings a quite menace to the part that works for two reasons. One is that he shows the great possibility of violence that Sikes is capable of, and does indeed act upon later in the film. The silence also works because although the menace is there Reed manages to make it believable that the good hearted Nancy (Shani Wallis) would stay with him at all. The reason is in his silence it seems that very well she could easily accept him, and even believes that she loves him as the vicious criminal is not always rapidly apparent.

Reed though carries his menace well into when he talks as well and we see the full extent of the killer inside. He is particularly chilling in the scene where he threatens Fagin by telling what chickens do when their necks are rung off. Reed delivery of this scene is incredibly good, and shows exactly what there is to Sikes. Reed is good in the role because how base evil he is as Sikes who is just a criminal thug, not a mastermind, but capable of horrible deeds anyway. Reed is great as Sikes in the quiet scenes, but he also succeeds at the end of the film when Sikes is a man on the run after having murdered someone.

Reed succeeds well in his last scenes showing Sikes lose his more restrained demeanor at the end, as he becomes almost like an animal in corner as he is chased. Reed is quite good in this scene because after he does the murder it would have been easy enough to show Sikes just keep his demeanor from before. Reed does much more by showing that Sikes definitely knows what he has done.  He might not show remorse exactly for his action he expresses that Sikes understands there is no turning back from what he is done. Reed gives this moment a lot more weight by doing this, and does far more here than was honestly required of Sikes as character. It is a good performance, and despite being the one character who does not sing in this musical he honestly gives the best performance in the film.

Wednesday, 20 February 2013

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1968

And the Nominees Were Not:

Anthony Hopkins in The Lion in Winter

Timothy Dalton in The Lion in Winter

Jason Robards in Once Upon a Time in The West

Oliver Reed in Oliver!

Michael York in Romeo and Juliet