Sunday 28 January 2024

Best Supporting Actor 2023: Results

 5. Sterling K. Brown in American Fiction - Brown gives an entirely good traditional supporting turn, where he provides the right dramatic and comedic chemistry with his onscreen brother. 

Best Scene: Talking to Monk at the reception.
4. Ryan Gosling in Barbie - Gosling gives one of the funniest performances of the year in throwing himself headfirst into Ken's journey in a mix between silliness and a strange kind of earnestness. 

Best Scene: "I'm Just Ken" 
3. Robert Downey Jr. in Oppenheimer - Downey gives an exceptional portrayal of the facade of professionalism slowly giving way to a personal vindictiveness. 

Best Scene: Outburst. 
2. Robert De Niro in Killers of the Flower Moon - De Niro gives a surprising and disarming portrayal of evil, where there's an ease and lack of hate, creating a particularly chilling portrait of a man who kills purely for profit. 

Best Scene: Final scene in jail. 
1. Mark Ruffalo in Poor Things - Good predictions Oliver, Luke & Perfectionist. Ruffalo tops this impressive lineup for me which included another very funny performance, but this one just took the laugh rate to the extreme as where Gosling was one of the funniest performances, Ruffalo is THE funniest. Ruffalo gives a convincing portrayal of a smug cad turning into a mad fool, but what's more important is every moment he's onscreen he finds a way to be hilarious in a way that only amplifies that journey. 

Best Scene: Duncan makes one more appearance. 

18 comments:

Lucas Saavedra said...

How do you think Oscar Isaac and Colin Farrell would have done as Duncan Wedderburn?

Luke Higham said...

My request is Anthony Quinn in Requiem For A Heavyweight.

Luke Higham said...

Louis: Whenever you will update the winning requests page, Caine in Little Voice needs to be changed to John Hurt in Love And Death On Long Island (David Jones made the change a couple of months ago).

Anonymous said...

Louis, if Downey indeed wins, where would you rank him among this decade’s Supporting Actor winners?

Luke Higham said...

Anonymous: He'd be 2nd.

Anonymous said...

Louis, your updated top ten De Niro, Downey, Gosling, and Ruffalo performances?

Also, your ranking of the members of KOTFM's cast that were nominated for the SAG Ensemble? (So that's Tantoo Cardinal, Robert De Niro, Leonardo DiCaprio, Brendan Fraser, Lily Gladstone, John Lithgow, and Jesse Plemons)

Psifonian said...

For Best Actor:

1. Giamatti
2. Murphy
3. Wright
4. Domingo
5. Cooper

Perfectionist said...

Louis: My request is Alan Cumming in Josie and the Pussycats(2001). A friend really loves this performance so I thought this would be interesting.

Ytrewq Wertyq said...

Perfectionist: I wholeheartedly support this choice.

Luke Higham said...

Perfectionist: I'm very happy with that one. We're finally getting that review in December.

Tony Kim said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Tony Kim said...

Louis: Your thoughts on Siskel & Ebert's reviews of Bogus and Outbreak?

Oliver Menard said...

I'll save my request for a short while.

J96 said...

Psifonian, when are you coming back and making new videos?

Jonathan Williams said...

Louis: What's your rating and thoughts on Lukas Haas in Witness. Can't find them anywhere.

J96 said...

1. Murphy
2. Giamatti
3. Wright
4. Domingo
5. Cooper

Perfectionist said...

Luke: Love to see people elated.

Louis Morgan said...

Again any requests based on non-2023 thoughts please save till past my typical busy period.

Lucas:

Isaac could've gone either way particularly based on some of his recent efforts, Farrell sounds like a strong fit, though would've been a little different.

Anonymous:

He would indeed be 2nd behind Quan.

Anonymous:

Tantoo Cardinal, Robert De Niro, Leonardo DiCaprio, Brendan Fraser, Lily Gladstone, John Lithgow, and Jesse Plemons

1. Lily Gladstone
2. Robert De Niro
3. Jesse Plemons
4. Tantoo Cardinal
5. John Lithgow
6. Leonardo DiCaprio
7. Brendan Fraser