Alternate Best Actor 2014: Results

10. Ethan Hawke in Predestination - Although Hawke ends up being crushed by the machine of his film, he still gives a largely compelling portrayal of grounding mind bending time travel.

Best Scene: Outlining the truth. 

9. Jesse Eisenberg in The Double - Eisenberg is less effective as the "confident man", though not bad, but is engaging in presenting his nebbish protagonist dealing with particularly odd circumstances.

Best Scene: Cyrano date

8. Shahid Kapoor in Haider - Although almost static, though sensibly so, in the first half of his performance, Kapoor in the second half unleashes a brilliant atypical take on Hamlet. 

Best Scene: Song number

7. Dan Stevens in The Guest - Although his film is lesser than, Stevens is a delight and absolutely captivating as a killer who seems strangely invested in a family.

Best Scene: Bully takedown. 

6. Jeremy Renner in Kill the Messenger - Renner gives a powerful portrayal of a man whose convictions slowly destroy him.

Best Scene: Final speech. 

5. Tom Cruise in Edge of Tomorrow - Cruise plays with his star persona by brilliantly subverting it in a multitude of ways, but also by living up to it as a natural progression of his character.

Best Scene: You don't make it any further

4. Oscar Isaac in A Most Violent Year - Isaac gives a brilliant portrayal of an atypical character in presenting a man quietly attempting to maintain his morality while also attempting to maintain power as a boss in a cutthroat business.

Best Scene: Confronting the thief. 

3. Channing Tatum in Foxcatcher - Tatum shatters any expectations on him through his powerful and intense portrayal of a man who has great potential but only can follow.

Best Scene: Breakdown.

2. Tom Hardy in The Drop - Tom Hardy gives one of his best performances in a brilliant high wire act that pays off as you're watching, but even more so with the revelation that gives you a greater sense for the overall accomplishment of his performance.

Best Scene: "You embarrass me"

1. David Gulpilil in Charlie's Country - Good predictions Luke, RatedRStar, Michael McCarthy, Anonymous, Aidan Pittman, Omar, and Mitchell. Gulpilil gives a portrait of just sheer honesty that reflects such a purely genuine person yet endearing in the unique qualities and life within this naturalism.

Best Scene: Seeing his dead friend.

Updated Overall

Next: 2014 Supporting

Alternate Best Actor 2014: Shahid Kapoor in Haider

Shahid Kapoor did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying the titular character in Haider.

Haider is a largely effective re-telling of Hamlet, in some ways closer to The Bad Sleep Well in its first half, in it is loosely adapted, taking elements of the text to craft a more unique narrative, though the second half hews closer to the original text.

This "version" of Hamlet takes place instead in India in a time of political strife. This version does not begin with the death of Haider's, this version's Hamlet, father, rather we see his political imprisonment. His father not being a king though rather a doctor, though we still see the immediacy in which Haider's mother (Tabu) is finding comfort with her husband's brother Khurram Meer (Kay Kay Menon). Although the first half of the film is technically about Haider his role is somewhat limited as it is more focused in setting the political and personal tensions around him. Kapoor's performance is limited as a young man coming back from college to find his father. His performance evoking, effectively, a more generalized smolder through an intense glare fitting a man with only one thing on his mind. Kapoor shows a man who only cares about what happened to his father and nothing else. He creates that sense of the singular mindset and is effective in this even if the note is purposefully limited here. This only changes when a mysterious stranger comes into town Roohdaar (Irrfan Khan). The man being "the ghost" in this version, though alive as a haunted political prisoner who by chance survived when he and Haider's father were taken out for execution. The man giving Haider the knowledge he needs to break his sort of state of inaction. This reflected well within Kapoor's portrayal that senses the immediate grief in his expression but also the anger within it as he learns that his uncle was involved with his father's fate.

Kapoor makes an extreme, fitting, shift as we now enter into really the game of Hamlet, in this version with the interpretation that he is purposefully acting insane. We get this with the shaven head of Kapoor immediately after the revelation in a mad rant. Although less the traditional form and done here more as a performance art piece. I have no hesitation though to say that is brilliantly performed by Kapoor though as he throws himself into this curious rant. A rant that is so artfully done again as his whole manner is that of a slight dance, and is just so effectively done as both this act of seeming madness while also being so incisively potent as an attack on the situation he is living in. This scene only best within Kapoor's work as instead of the traditional "play within a play" we instead get a song and dance number pointed towards his uncle's guilt. Although I often hold reservations towards the Bollywood musical numbers which often lead films to a standstill, here it not only is intertwined within the story it creates a natural progression within it by it being within story. Kapoor is amazing in this sequence as he delivers on the song as he should in terms of just being captivating within the performance however he goes so much further than that. This as the intensity of the notion and the projection of the anger of the scene is portrayed so effectively by Kapoor. This as he wholly embodies within the performance the striking emotion with Haider as he doesn't just sing the song but rather makes it this full accusation towards his uncle within the song.

This is a case of the act of insanity though as we do otherwise then have scenes between Haider and the Ophelia equivalent Arshia (Shraddha Kapoor). These are very much traditionally romantic moments where the Kapoor's, neither related or married, do have a strong chemistry with one another. These moments are brief however Kapoor uses them well to suggest the young man we saw at the beginning of the film, and the chance for normalcy if he chose it. Of course knowing the play things don't turn out that way, though here with less cloak and dagger, and more machine guns/explosions. This leading to the climax to be a bit more abrupt and direct to say the least. For example instead of Rosencrantz and Guildenstern trying to have him covertly executed, they instead killed with rocks instead by Haider. I'll say though Kapoor is terrific though in becoming really the spirit of vengeance in these later moments. Finding really a balance between the false insanity we saw earlier and the single focused man who arrived home. Kapoor finding this sort of vicious determination as he goes about killing or trying to kill the traitors within his midst. Kapoor bringing sort of the right undercurrent of emotional desperation within the task, particularly in the moments of accusing his mother. Kapoor exuding in it the pain of the act flawlessly while also conveying the sort of thrill of being able to release his pent up anger. The climax actually doesn't leave too much time for reflection however I'll grant that Kapoor uses the time he does have effectively. This particularly in his final moment, which goes a bit differently, Kapoor silently expresses the conflict of the moment between revenge and clemency. Although the focus of this Hamlet is rather different, Kapoor delivers on giving a captivating, off-beat and powerful version of the oft played character.

Alternate Best Actor 2014

And the Nominees Were Not:

Channing Tatum in Foxcatcher

Tom Hardy in The Drop

Shahid Kapoor in Haider

Ethan Hawke in Predestination

Dan Stevens in The Guest

Predict Those Five, These five or both:

Jesse Eisenberg in The Double

Jeremy Renner in Kill the Messenger

Tom Cruise in Edge of Tomorrow

David Gulpilil in Charlie's Country

Oscar Isaac in A Most Violent Year