Showing posts with label Jack Hawkins. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Jack Hawkins. Show all posts

Wednesday, 27 May 2026

Alternate Best Actor 1953: Results

5. Kazou Hasegawa in Gate of Hell - Hasegawa is able to hit the extreme notes called upon him as a character with limited substance but is very much overshadowed by his co-stars who express a bit more nuance in their roles. 
 
Best Scene:  Ending
 
4. Jack Hawkins in The Cruel Sea - Hawkins gives a reliably good performance however his fully lead performance here suggests the possible limitations of his ability as a leading man as a opposed to a character actor. 
 
Best Scene: After the choosing to ignore the men in the sea. 
3. Charles Boyer in The Earrings of Madame de…. - Boyer gives an effective performance in very much playing into his imperious presence in an effective way as essentially presenting his character as above typical human interaction.
 
Best Scene: Requesting the duel. 
2. James Stewart in The Naked Spur - Stewart gives an effectively raw portrayal of a damaged man and successfully downplays his typical charm and heroic presence. 
 
Best Scene: Making the final choice. 
1. Chishū Ryū in Tokyo Story - Good prediction Calvin. Ryū gives a low key but powerful portrayal of the different quiet shades of a father and finding the joy but also painful truths of this man. 
 
Best Scene: Tragedy strikes 
 
Next: 1953 Supporting Reviews (Not a lineup) 

Wednesday, 29 April 2026

Alternate Best Actor 1953: Jack Hawkins in The Cruel Sea

Jack Hawkins did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite receiving a BAFTA nomination, for portraying LT. Commander George Ericson in The Cruel Sea. 

The Cruel Sea takes a realistic approach of a single crew going through World War II. 

If that role sounds primed for Jack Hawkins, the man required to be in every epic during a certain period, you would be correct. This very much is mostly in his more expected wheelhouse just in the lead role, although just barely as the film very much focuses on several members of the crew to get a wider scope of how this life impacts the men. Hawkins provides his presence to the role of a British officer with the innate strength you’d want, and fitting to the most seasoned man called to deck. Hawkins often must fulfill those needs with delivery of his orders with that regal voice of his and with a quiet confidence about a man who knows what he’s doing. That is the set-up however that isn’t all there is to the film or his portrayal of Ericson, though Hawkins certainly does well in filling that Naval uniform so to speak. The film though is trying to be realistic so this isn’t at all about the glory of the navy, and I would say Hawkins is good because even when he’s in his most official capacity he’s not emphasizing any “rah rah” quality, just a man being professional. 

The film gets much darker when the men come across British men in the water but also know there is a German U-boat below the surface. Hawkins is good in this scene where his eyes do capture essentially the cruel but needed calculation of the man as he understands the gravity of his choice yet then proceeds to calmly order that the boat proceed to attack. When he’s called a murderer, even though Ericson had no choice lest their ship also be destroyed, Hawkins’s reaction takes that as truth even as he continues but still maintaining a veneer of indifference to maintain himself as the proper commander. We have a followup scene where Ericson confides his first officer his true heartbeat over the scene, and I’d say Hawkins is good in the scene, but I can’t help but admit I think he’s better in a short, yet very similar scene, in the end of The Bridge on the River Kwai where he also must justify his sacrificial action. There I truly felt the emotion, here I think Hawkins presents it well, certainly delivers on the needs of the moment, but his performance didn’t impact me to the degree of his later work. 

We follow the ship as it has its own destruction where Hawkins again has a good scene where he is recovered with the few remaining crew delivering genuine fear in his expression and conveying the severity of the situation. We follow that even with a personal note of the unfaithfulness of his wife where Hawkins delivers an effective bit of quiet exasperation, where he does care but has been through too much to care all that deeply. Hawkins shows instead the focus of the man now on his job where we have his pivotal scene of becoming obsessed that there is a German U-Boat even though all signs suggest otherwise. Hawkins is good in this scene in managing to portray this dancing on the line in his intensity between determination and paranoia. Hawkins plays around on the note effectively in the build up before he is proven to be right and once again saves the day in less than typically heroic circumstances. Hawkins gives a good performance here, but I will say, along with some of his other leading turns I’ve seen. There is something missing. Don’t get me wrong, he’s good in those other turns, he’s good here, but the weird thing is he weirdly feels like he has a greater presence…when in supporting roles. And it might just be that strange intangible of what makes a star a star, as Hawkins is good, has a strong presence, yet as a leading man, he’s just not quite as gripping as when he comes in and out of a film. 

Saturday, 25 April 2026

Alternate Best Actor 1953

And the Nominees Were Not:

Chishū Ryū in Tokyo Story

Charles Boyer in The Earrings of Madame de...

Jack Hawkins in The Cruel Sea

James Stewart in The Naked Spur

Kazuo Hasegawa in Gate of Hell

Wednesday, 2 March 2016

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1962: Results

5. Robert Duvall in To Kill a Mockingbird - Duvall gives a flawless performance that fully realizes his his pivotal character in a matter of 3 minutes.

Best Scene: His only scene. 
4. Lee Marvin in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance - Marvin gives a memorable villainous turn by being the absolute lout bully that Liberty Valance should be.

Best Scene: The duel. 
3. Tatsuya Nakadai in Sanjuro - Nakadai once again offers a worthy adversary for Toshiro Mifune's nameless samurai, but this time surprisingly strikes up a certain underlying connection between the foes.

Best Scene: The duel. 
2. Robert Ryan in Billy Budd - Ryan gives one of his best performances, giving a chilling portrayal of a sadist, but also manages to find the depth within what compels the man.

Best Scene: Billy tries to comfort Claggart. 
1. Peter Sellers in Lolita - Sellers gives an amazing performance as he's absolutely hilarious, but also manages to be surprisingly unnerving in the role at the same time.

Best Scene: Just a normal guy with a normal face.
7. Arthur Kennedy - Kennedy offers the needed two sides to his character the slightly shallow broadcaster, but as well the sardonic man who is well aware of what he is doing.

Best Scene: "I'll take your bloody picture"
6. Anthony Quayle - Quayle brings surprising depth to his role as he quietly portrays the affecting arc of his character, which is to fully understand who Lawrence really was.

Best Scene: The funeral. 
5. Anthony Quinn - Quinn gives an appropriately larger than life performance capturing the grandeur needed for the role, but importantly finds the right nuance when it is needed.

Best Scene: Tayi and Brighton.
4. Jack Hawkins - Hawkins naturally fulfills the role of the proper British General but goes further in his exploration of his character's relationship with Lawrence.

Best Scene: Allenby convinces Lawrence to take up the fight again.
3. Alec Guinness - As per usual Guinness gives strong work successfully disappearing into his role as well as giving a rather captivating portrait of a quiet yet powerful leader.

Best Scene: Faisal is interviewed.
2. Jose Ferrer - A brilliant one scene wonder as he completely realizes his character's disposition and finds the needed subtext of his scene through his performance.

Best Scene: His scene.
1. Claude Rains - Good predictions mcofra7, and Jackiboyz. Rains gives such an excellent performance as he does not waste a second in creating a fascinating depiction of a smooth political operator.

Best Scene: The ending.
Overall Rank:
  1. Peter Sellers in Lolita
  2. Robert Ryan in Billy Budd
  3. Omar Sharif in Lawrence of Arabia
  4. Claude Rains in Lawrence of Arabia
  5. Tatsuya Nakadai in Sanjuro 
  6. Lee Marvin in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  7. Jose Ferrer in Lawrence of Arabia
  8. Brock Peters in To Kill a Mockingbird
  9. Alec Guinness in Lawrence of Arabia
  10. Robert Duvall in To Kill a Mockingbird
  11. Jack Hawkins in Lawrence of Arabia
  12. Charles Bickford in Days of Wine and Roses 
  13. Burgess Meredith in Advise & Consent
  14. Ed Begley in Sweet Bird of Youth 
  15. James Gregory in The Manchurian Candidate
  16. Anthony Quinn in Lawrence of Arabia
  17. Melvyn Douglas in Billy Budd
  18. Anthony Quayle in Lawrence of Arabia 
  19. Charles Laughton in Advise & Consent
  20. Karl Malden in Birdman of Alcatraz
  21. Lee Montague in Billy Budd
  22. Arthur Kennedy in Lawrence of Arabia
  23. Lew Ayres in Advise & Consent
  24. Frank Overton in To Kill a Mockingbird
  25. Joseph Wiseman in Dr. No 
  26. David McCallum in Freud
  27. Richard Harris in Mutiny on the Bounty  
  28. Woody Strode in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance 
  29. Richard Attenborough in All Night Long 
  30. Henry Fonda in Advise & Consent
  31. John McGiver in The Manchurian Candidate
  32. Jack Klugman in Days of Wine and Roses
  33. Rentaro Mikuni in Harakiri
  34. David McCallum in Billy Budd
  35. Edmond O'Brien in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  36. Michael Redgrave in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner
  37. Khigh Dheigh in The Manchurian Candidate
  38. Paul Rogers in Billy Budd
  39. Victor Buono in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? 
  40. Akira Ishihama in Harakiri
  41. Walter Pidgeon in Advise & Consent
  42. Robert Brown in Billy Budd
  43. Gary Cockrell in Lolita
  44. John Carradine in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  45. Yuzo Kayama in Sanjuro
  46. John Neville in Billy Budd
  47. Jack Kruschen in Cape Fear
  48. John Megna in To Kill a Mockingbird 
  49. Buddy Hackett in The Music Man 
  50. Telly Savalas in Cape Fear
  51. Andy Devine in The Man Who Liberty Valance 
  52. Martin Balsam in Cape Fear
  53. Rip Torn in Sweet Bird of Youth 
  54. Takashi Shimura in Sanjuro
  55. Hugh Griffith in Mutiny on the Bounty
  56. James Anderson in To Kill a Mockingbird
  57. Andrew Prine in The Miracle Worker
  58. Paul Fix in To Kill a Mockingbird
  59. Larry Parks in Freud
  60. Wesley Addy in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? 
  61. Telly Savalas in Birdman of Alcatraz
  62. Don Murray in Advise & Consent
  63. Edmond O'Brien in Birdman of Alcatraz 
  64. Henry Silva in The Manchurian Candidate
  65. Victor Jory in The Miracle Worker
  66. Jack Lord in Dr. No
  67. Ron Howard in The Music Man
  68. Keith Mitchell in All Night Long
Next Year: 1939 Lead

Tuesday, 1 March 2016

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1962: Alec Guinness, Anthony Quayle, Anthony Quinn, Arthur Kennedy, Claude Rains, Jack Hawkins, and Jose Ferrer in Lawrence of Arabia

Lawrence of Arabia is often touted as one of the greatest films of all time, and deservedly so. However it's one of those films were some elements are often overlooked in its praise. Of course the masterful vision of David Lean's direction, the sheer scope, and Peter O'Toole performance as Lawrence are praised, again deservedly so. What seems more often a little overlooked is how well developed the cast of characters are along with Lawrence, it is not a one character piece. These smaller, yet not underdeveloped roles, are help realized by the film's brilliant screenplay and of course its large ensemble.

Alec Guinness did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Prince Faisal in Lawrence of Arabia.

Naturally David Lean's frequent collaborator is in the mix here as the Arab Prince who is most active in his rebellion against the Turkish Empire. Alec Guinness disappears into the role of Faisal, which could be surprising if this were not Alec Guinness. Guinness somehow wears the makeup particularly well, and his adjustment to his accent is especially effective in realizing Faisal's character. Guinness carries himself with the needed quiet dignity of a man who does not use many words, but only seems to make use of important words. Guinness is rather captivating in the way exudes the authority of Faisal with such an ease. He has the grace of a truly great leader. The intelligence of the man just seems a given by Guinness's performance as he very plays Faisal as a leader who is constantly listening to those around him. There's something so special about Guinness's use of his eyes here as they are piercing yet comforting at the same time realizing Faisal as both a man that does not enforce himself upon you, however you cannot ignore his presence.

This is something very interesting about the way Guinness manages to conduct himself as Faisal in that he makes him seem as though he's somewhat aloof, though paints this as merely a facade in order disarm those around him. Guinness presents Faisal as an educated man, but one who purposefully does not try to remove himself from the simple view that a foreigner may take from him. Guinness's approach here is very effective as he shows the way that Faisal does this in order for his more important remarks to be all the more incisive. Guinness utilizes the set up so well as he has this the overriding feature of Faisal yet still suggests so much more about him. There's a great scene for Guinness when the Prince is interviewed about his campaign. Guinness is so good as he keeps Faisal the proper Prince on the surface, however underneath it Guinness finds a striking cutting edge to the man when he states that for him mercy is only good manners. The same holds true in the scenes where he directly interacts with the British high command. There is a definite determination, a far more fervent desire, that Guinness brings within this as Faisal questions the British intentions, and later when he goes into direct negotiations with them. Speaking of the British High Command.

Jack Hawkins did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying General Allenby in Lawrence of Arabia.

Hawkins, having already collaborated with Lean on The Bridge on the River Kwai, once again returns as a British Officer this one of a somewhat different sort. Hawkins's carries himself as one would expect from a proper British General, that being an assured yet respectful command. Now this is the sort of role that very well could have been just the standard authority figure there to occasionally move along Lawrence's story. That's never the case as Hawkins's performance brings much more nuance to the role than one might even expect. Already important whenever Allenby speaks of military matters Hawkins portrays that proper assurance and passion for his duties. Whenever a political working comes up Hawkins infuses the right sort of exasperation delivering well Allenby's frequent aside of "I'm not a politician, thank God!", though this in itself is not simplified by Hawkins as indifference. Hawkins instead presents an underlying understanding in Allenby that he definitely knows the political issues, but uses this exasperation as basically a defense to make it so he barely has to speak of it.

Hawkins is especially strong in his scenes where he converses with Lawrence directly. Hawkins does well to show the different wavelengths that Allenby is playing at. He keeps the stature of the General correctly when trying support Lawrence's ideas, or attempt to explain away that the English may intend to take Arabia for themselves. Hawkins does not leave it at that though revealing a bit of introspection in Allenby as he puts forth some casual jealousy in the man when he ponders about his own stature when compared to Lawrence's. My favorite moments of Hawkins's though is when Allenby attempts to get Lawrence back on track in terms of defeating the Turkish empire. These moments could have been easy enough to show Allenby attempting to get Lawrence to tow the line so to speak. I love that Hawkins does not play it that way as he calls upon the certain chemistry he has with O'Toole to make it more than that. Hawkins exudes an underlying respect Allenby has as his glances which suggest that Allenby sees the man he wishes he could be. When Allenby encourages Lawrence to take back the fight once again Hawkins is genuinely inspirational as he brings so much vigor in his eyes and words as he tells Lawrence to go on and fulfill his destiny.

Now a favorite scene of mine for both Hawkins and Guinness is near the end of the film where the two argue over who Lawrence belongs to, and the two are forced to decide that he is equally useless for the both of them since either side can lay claim to his actions. Both Hawkins and Guinness are rather cold in this moment by speaking as men of straight duty trying to simply get their demands across without much care for who it might effect. The two do share an equally memorable moment though just as they agree to basically forget Lawrence and get onto more business. Before that though Hawkins and Guinness each have a silent reaction that is quietly moving as Faisal and Allenby each for the moment suggest what Lawrence really does mean to them, before overcoming their emotional connection and moving on. Both Guinness and Hawkins do very commendable work here since either could have been reduced to caricatures of just an Arab Prince or a British General, and could have been just there to occasionally move the plot along. Neither actor allows this to be the case. They both are able to realize not only what are Allenby's and Faisal's motivations, but also who they are as men as well as what their relationship with Lawrence truly is.
(For Hawkins and Guinness)

Anthony Quinn did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Auda Ibu Tayi in Lawrence of Arabia.

Anthony Quinn plays Auda Ibu Tayi who appears as the leader of a large tribe who Lawrence convinces to join the cause, despite Tayi originally being paid to fight for the Turks. Now this is a role where you get technically what you'd expect, but that's not a problem. This is a very much in Quinn's wheelhouse as a larger than life warrior type which is fitting for a man who will ride into battle because it is "his pleasure" to do so. Quinn brings that boisterous power to his performance, that grand stature of a man who is a true leader of his people, and wholly embraces his life style of war. Quinn's performance excels in just being the spirited aggressive force he should be, as his ability and willingness to ride into war is something that it is obvious he lives for with every breath that he takes. Quinn stands as high as he can in the role as he frankly does not hold back in terms of the exuberance he brings to the part, and nor should he. It fits so well with who Auda Ibu Tayi needs to be for the film, and Quinn stands out by presenting someone in the story who fights exactly for what he says he fights for. He has no hidden motives for his war path.

Quinn is indeed very entertaining in the role as he enlivens the screen with his presence at any given moment he is in. He has some very enjoyable moments as he shows Tayi's personal beliefs that he is very passionate about. He is also effective in showing the certain callousness that comes from such a man, particularly in his brutally straight forward delivery of "It was written then" when he hears that Lawrence had to execute man he previously risked his life to save. Quinn though does well to not make Tayi too simplistic ever. He carefully throughout the film portrays Tayi's growing personal respect for Lawrence. I really like the way he does this still within in his own blunt personal style of course. There's a moment towards the end of the film between Lawrence's right hand man Sherif Ali (Omar Sharif), and Auda Ibu Tayi, where Ali actually threatens Tayi with violence. However it's actually made a rather poignant scene by both actors as they reveal a stronger concern for Lawrence than they are willing to let on. I like how Quinn keeps Tayi rather uncouth as speaks to Ali on the matter, yet he still alludes to Tayi's own honest sympathy for their ally. Quinn's work contributes well to the film offering the right larger than life figure in Tayi, while still finding some depth within him.
Anthony Quayle did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Colonel Brighton in Lawrence of Arabia.

Quayle's performance here is actually rather interesting one to examine since just with a cursory glance there may not seem to be much to the character, though there actually is as he has perhaps the third most dynamic character arc after Lawrence and Sherif Ali. The earliest point chronologically speaking that we meet Brighton is when Lawrence first appears to Prince Faisal's camp. Brighton in these scenes very much is the proper British officer who just wants Lawrence to keep quiet, and stick to the plans devised by the British high command. Now apparently Quayle and Lean argued over the portrayal of Brighton as a character with Quayle wishing to play him as a fool while Lean wished for him to be shown as an honorable man. The intriguing part of this is that watching the performance you can take either interpretation to what interpretation took precedence. In that it seems Quayle went about playing it that Brighton's foolishness in fact allows him to be honorable. This is shown even when he's the British officer telling Prince Faisal to do things that mainly benefit the British, but Quayle actually does play Brighton as genuinely believing this to be their best course of action.

Now Brighton's arc is not heavily focused upon but based around his view of Lawrence changing throughout the film. Obviously he begins frankly as an obstacle who wishes to keep Lawrence from making any sort of real impact. However Lawrence proves everyone wrong by taking an important city in a way that no one believed could have been done. When Brighton continues to work along with Lawrence as they proceed to attack the Turkish rail lines. Quayle keeps the skepticism with Brighton, though it is not nearly as strong as it was a before. Quayle though is in one very good scene where he questions some of the Arabs' motivation including Auda Ibu Tayi's. Again both interpretations potentially shine through though it is no less effective as Quayle reveals the intense discontent in Brighton against them. Again Quayle manages both because, he may be foolish to hold such a simple view, yet he is honorable as Quayle once again brings only a genuine passion to Brighton as man who believes one should fight for what one believes in. Now the character's transition in regards to Lawrence continues throughout the film, and Quayle gradually reflects in Brighton as a further understanding of the man. That brings it to his most pivotal moments of the film, that are at completely opposite points in the film. That being his first and last scene, his first scene taking place after Lawrence's death, but each show Brighton's final perspective on the man. The first scene Quayle is rather moving in showing Brighton fully accepting the important, and rather great man that Lawrence was at his funeral, as in the end both men fought for what they believed was right. His last scene is equally strong as Quayle presents Brighton as the one man who can appreciate what Lawrence did without exception through his depiction of Brighton's disdain as he sees that everyone else in the end was merely using him for their own ends. This somewhat brief work once again brings so much unexpected depth to the role, and in turn the film, as Quayle makes Brighton anything but a stock side character.
Arthur Kennedy did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Jackson Bentley in Lawrence of Arabia.

Arthur Kennedy plays an American photojournalist based upon the real Lowell Thomas who helped to make Lawrence famous. Kennedy's not an actor who has always been a favorite of mine, though I don't dislike him, but his performance style works quite well for this part. That being Kennedy's usual method of rather accentuated delivery. This feels completely fitting for the role of Bentley as he depicts Bentley very much as a man ready to make a radio broadcast with his words. Kennedy is very good in the scenes where he is in essentially interviewer mode. Kennedy feels like a true broadcaster in these scenes as he kind of has that false refinement of sorts as he speaks so directly, and specifically about topics yet one can't help but feel he's reciting from a script. Kennedy's good in the way he undercuts that when someone basically ask Bentley for a more direct, more honest answer. Such as when Faisal asks really why Bentley's interested in Lawrence after receiving some platitudes previously. Kennedy drops the act for a moment, but importantly does not show Bentley to stumble with this. He still shows him to be an intelligent man, but rather just more naturally responds as he states the exact reason for wishing to cover Lawrence.

Kennedy's good in the scenes where he interacts with Lawrence, and the rest of the party. This is largely because Kennedy embraces the idea that Bentley is able to be the most detached from the situation given that he's really there just to get a good story out of Lawrence. Kennedy reveals the right enthusiasm as he goes about taking Lawrence's picture, and getting the icon he's looking for. Kennedy again brings back the proper broadcaster routine as he interviews Lawrence, as well as Sherif Ali, and he's very effective in the way he drifts from that to a semi-sardonic observer whenever Bentley decides on a bit of an editorial. One of his best moments is in his first scene as he eulogizes Lawrence first in a proper memorial ready for a headline which Kennedy delivers with the utmost passion and respect, then a second later the truth about the man's shortcoming which Kennedy delivers with a definite sarcastic edge. I love that not even the understandably detached Bentley is not only defined by that. Kennedy has a great final scene where he must witness a changed Lawrence as he goes on a massacre of a Turkish brigade. It's a brief moment but rather affecting one as Kennedy bluntly shows that Bentley cannot be detached from what Lawrence has done. Kennedy's excellent in revealing how disturbed Bentley is by what he sees and the outrage as he still must go about his duty to glorify Lawrence. Again this is not a huge role yet Kennedy makes a definite impact with Bentley. He successfully, in just his few scenes, creates a portrait of this journalist as man ready to make stories for more mainstream public consumption yet is well aware of the reality.
Jose Ferrer did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying the Turkish Bey in Lawrence of Arabia.

Jose Ferrer has the smallest role out of everyone listed here. He only appears in two scenes, one for only a few seconds. His second scene takes place as Lawrence is caught by a few Turkish soldiers and taken to their superior played by Ferrer. Ferrer apparently believed this to be his greatest performance, and I'm a bit inclined to agree despite its brevity. Ferrer is brilliant as he instantly set up his character in the way he simply looks up from his desk as we see a truly exhausted individual. Physically speaking of course but more so mentally. The way he walks even keeps the proper military step yet so labored it is of a man who just is barely keeping to his step. The man then proceeds to look over the potential suspects and Ferrer again is outstanding in the way he slowly reveals more of this man. At first it seems like he might be looking for someone important as he scans the man. As we see a little longer though Ferrer's expression becomes somewhat more peculiar as he decides on Lawrence to be the man who is kept. At first it seems that Lawrence may be found out, which would mean his death, as the Bey notes his eye color. Ferrer though notes this not as though Bey is making a great discovering as an officer in the Turkish army, but rather has found something he finds rather appealing. When the Bey ponders on the fact that he's the only one who notices interesting faces where he is particularly stationed, Ferrer alludes to a consternation. This consternation is not made by Ferrer as that of a man frustrated by the lack intelligent discussion, but rather that of sexual frustration. Ferrer is terrific as he subtly reveals a bit of ache in the Bey as he examines Lawrence, and that ache he's ready to satisfy as he states to his men to "beat him" with a understated glee. After Lawrence is released he's never quite the same man. We know he was beaten but largely due to Ferrer's work we can assume it did not stop there. Ferrer's performance is outstanding as he effortlessly realizes the subtext of the scene. Ferrer like the rest of the cast, though with even less time, makes Bey more than simply a Turkish officer who detains Lawrence, far far more.
Claude Rains did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Mr. Dryden in Lawrence of Arabia.

Now as for Claude Rains we have one of the greatest actors of all time in one of his final roles. A quick side note I must admit there is something enjoyable to see as he and the man he shares the record for most supporting actor nominations without a win with, Arthur Kennedy, share a direct interaction with one another. Anyway Rains's performance is sort of a hidden treasure in the film. Say on a initial viewing you pay no mind to Dryden, you're missing something rather special hidden right in front of you. Rains plays Dryden the head of the Arab bureau basically the man who deals with the political matters connected with the Arab campaign. Dryden is in a more than a handful of scenes, and though he does not have an excessive amount of lines he has some pivotal ones. The thing is that the lines themselves, though well written, could often be meaningless if it weren't for Rains's delivery of them. Rains conducts himself so well here as he has Mr. Dryden be someone who takes his time in his movement, yet there is never a question that he's a man who knows exactly where he should be. The level of assurance that Rains conveys with such ease makes the strong willed characters seem meek in way, even though Rains keeps Mr. Dryden so carefully unassuming in his personal style.

Rains is terribly clever here as he makes a man so terribly clever in such a tricky way. When he sends Lawrence on his original mission it seems simple enough, yet the potential involved from the mission seems in Rains's expression the whole time. Rains makes Dryden actually the most powerful man in the film, even though he never states his power in least. In fact he acts as though he's just a modest official who has no great ambitions. There's one magnificent scene where he, Brighton, and Allenby discuss the ability to give the Arabs artillery. It is Dryden who makes decision, even though he specifically states it's Allenby's decision, yet the way Rains conveys the message within a question seems so incisive, more than if even directly told Allenby what to do. There's another great moment when Allenby inquires to Dryden if Britain has any plans for Arabia. Dryden states only that "it's a difficult question" but Rains is so perfect in making it a casual deflection yet in his expression there is no question on the matter in Dryden's mind. Rains is amazing in the way he makes it that Dryden really is always in charge even though he never in fact gives away his position. Rains could not be smoother in how eloquent he is in the depiction of a truly seasoned political operator. Rains is even fantastic when he's not do anything. Even in scenes where he is silent every glance is worth something due to Rains. He suggests Dryden analyzing and dissecting everything he sees. It is fascinating to just watch Rains in any given scene as there's not a wasted second in the entirety of his performance. One favorite moment of mine is when Dryden notices cuts have reopened on Lawrence's back, and Dryden for brief instance tries to inform Lawrence of this. Rains's reaction is so good, even humorous in a way, as he shows as Dryden quickly evaluates the situation and decides it's best not get involved with this issue. Another magnificent moment for Rains is at the end of the film is when he finally responds to Allenby claiming not to be a politician. Rains is hilarious, but also oh so shrewd as Dryden subtly scoffs at hearing the rather false claim once again. I love everything about this performance as Rains adds so much to film with a part that with the wrong actor have easily almost just been part of the background. It's such an astute piece of work by Rains as he does so much with so little.

Tuesday, 23 February 2016

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1962

And the Nominees Were Not:

Robert Ryan in Billy Budd

Peter Sellers in Lolita

Lee Marvin in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance

Tatsuya Nakadai in Sanjuro

Robert Duvall in To Kill a Mockingbird

Brock Peters in To Kill a Mockingbird

For prediction purposes: Duvall from the mockingbird men.

And for a single review spectacular:
The supporting cast of Lawrence of Arabia:

Arthur Kennedy in Lawrence of Arabia

Claude Rains in Lawrence of Arabia

Jose Ferrer in Lawrence of Arabia

Alec Guinness in Lawrence of Arabia

Anthony Quinn in Lawrence of Arabia

Jack Hawkins in Lawrence of Arabia

Anthony Quayle in Lawrence of Arabia

For prediction purposes, eh rank em all if you wish.

Monday, 12 January 2015

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1957: Results

5. Bengt Ekerot in The Seventh Seal - Although nicely boosted by the film's direction Ekerot does not lose the mystery and intrigue of the character when he speaks.

Best Scene: The end of the game.
4. Jack Hawkins in The Bridge on the River Kwai - Hawkins effectively creates yet another intriguing portrait of a most peculiar sort of madness. 

Best Scene: Warden is injured.
3. Lee J. Cobb in 12 Angry Men - Cobb gives a strong performance by fulfilling his duties as the passionate "villain", but always showing the humanity that propels him.

Best Scene: 3's final breakdown.
2. Gunnar Björnstrand in The Seventh Seal - Björnstrand gives a great depiction of a man confidant of his own world forced to face whatever the next may or may not be.

Best Scene: The squire faces death.
1. Burt Lancaster in Sweet Smell of Success - Good prediction Jackiboyz. Lancaster gives a brilliantly and coldly brutal portrayal of a man whose words are his most dangerous weapon.

Best Scene: Sidney goes to see Hunsecker.
Overall Rank:
  1. Sessue Hayakawa in The Bridge on the River Kwai
  2. Burt Lancaster in Sweet Smell of Success
  3. Gunnar Björnstrand in The Seventh Seal
  4. Lee J. Cobb in 12 Angry Men
  5. Jack Hawkins in The Bridge on the River Kwai
  6. Toshiro Mifune in The Lower Depths
  7. Jack Warden in 12 Angry Men
  8. Ralph Meeker in Paths of Glory
  9. Walter Matthau in A Face in the Crowd 
  10. Jack Klugman in 12 Angry Men 
  11. James Donald in The Bridge on the River Kwai 
  12. Karl Malden in Fears Strikes Out
  13. Bengt Ekerot in The Seventh Seal 
  14. Ed Begley in 12 Angry Men
  15. Red Buttons in Sayonara 
  16. Tyrone Power in Witness for the Prosecution
  17. George Macready in Paths of Glory 
  18. Chishū Ryū in Tokyo Twilight
  19. Martin Balsam in 12 Angry Men 
  20. Timothy Carey in Paths of Glory
  21. Lee Marvin in Raintree County 
  22. John McIntire in The Tin Star
  23. Lee J. Cobb in The Three Faces of Eve
  24. Minoru Chiaki in The Lower Depths
  25. Andre Morell in The Bridge on the River Kwai
  26. E.G. Marshall in 12 Angry Men  
  27. Jack Warden in The Bachelor Party
  28. Robert F. Simon in Edge of the City
  29. Larry Blyden in The Bachelor Party
  30. Minoru Chiaki in Throne of Blood
  31. Edward Binns in 12 Angry Men 
  32. E.G. Marshall in The Bachelor Party
  33. Kamatari Fujiwara in The Lower Depths
  34. Maurice Chevalier in Love in the Afternoon 
  35. Wayne Morris in Paths of Glory 
  36. Amedeo Nazzari in Night of Cabiria
  37. Adolphe Menjou in Paths of Glory
  38. Niall MacGinnis in Night of the Demon
  39. Dennis Hopper in Gunfight at the O.K. Corral
  40. Philip Abbott in The Bachelor Party
  41. Jack Warden in Edge of the City
  42. Vasili Merkuryev in The Cranes Are Flying
  43. Bill Nagy in Across the Bridge
  44. Richard Jaeckel in 3:10 to Yuma
  45. Nils Poppe in The Seventh Seal  
  46. Aldo Silvani in Nights in Cabiria
  47. Gunnar Björnstrand in Wild Strawberries
  48. Vittorio De Sica in A Farewell to Arms
  49. Paul Newman in Until They Sail 
  50. Nigel Patrick in Raintree County
  51. Ganjiro Nakamura in The Lower Depths
  52. John Williams in Witness for the Prosecution  
  53. Aleksey Batalov in The Cranes Are Flying
  54. Mickey Shaughnessy in Designing Woman
  55. George Voskovec in 12 Angry Men 
  56. Leo McKern in Time Without Pity
  57. Jim Backus in Man of a Thousand Faces
  58. Ake Fridell in The Seventh Seal
  59. Emile Meyer in Sweet Smell of Success
  60. Sebastain Cabot in Johnny Tremaine
  61. Alberto Sordi in A Farewell to Arms 
  62. Theodore Bikel in The Enemy Below
  63. Robert Webber in 12 Angry Men 
  64. Sunil Dutt in Mother India
  65. Richard Wattis in The Prince and the Showgirl
  66. Takashi Shimura in Throne of Blood
  67. John Fiedler in 12 Angry Men 
  68. Martin Balsam in Time Limit 
  69. Lee Van Cleef in The Tin Star
  70. Geoffrey Horne in The Bridge on the River Kwai 
  71. Jean Marais in White Nights
  72. Joseph Sweeney in 12 Angry Men 
  73. Howard Smith in A Face in the Crowd 
  74. Neville Brand in The Tin Star
  75. Richard Basehart in Time Limit
  76. Bernard Lee in Across the Bridge
  77. Raaj Kumar in Mother India 
  78. Pat Hingle in The Strange One
  79. Rajendra Kumar in Mother India 
  80. Michel Auclair in Funny Face
  81. François Périer in Nights of Cabiria
  82. James Garner in Sayonara  
  83. Arthur Kennedy in Peyton Place
  84. David Wayne in The Three Faces of Eve 
  85. Sam Levene in Designing Woman
  86. Martin Milner in Sweet Smell of Success 
  87. Walter Sande in Johnny Tremaine
  88. Robert Emhardt in 3:10 to Yuma
  89. Oskar Homolka in A Farewell to Arms 
  90. Ricardo Montalban in Sayonara
  91. Joseph Calleia in Wild is the Wind
  92. Jeremy Spencer in The Prince and the Showgirl
  93. Lloyd Nolan in A Hatful of Rain 
  94. John Ireland in Gunfight at the O.K. Corral
  95. George Peppard in The Strange One
  96. Russ Tamblyn in Peyton Place
  97. John McGiver in Love in the Afternoon
  98. Lloyd Nolan in Peyton Place
  99. Arthur Storch in The Strange One
  100. Richard Beymer in Johnny Tremaine 
  101. Leon Ames in Peyton Place 
  102. Rip Torn in Time Limit 
  103. Paul Langton in The Incredible Shrinking Man
  104. David Nelson in Peyton Place
  105. Lou Merrill in The Giant Claw
  106. Anthony Franciosa in A Face in the Crowd
  107. Anthony Franciosa in Wild is the Wind
Next Year: 1937 Supporting if there's time. 

Thursday, 8 January 2015

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1957: Jack Hawkins in The Bridge on the River Kwai

Jack Hawkins did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Major Warden in The Bridge on the River Kwai.

Jack Hawkins was the mainstay of just about every English language epic around the late fifties and early sixties. It may have been even a requirement to have him in your film in fact which would explain why he was the Swedish missionary in Zulu (although I happen to still like him a lot in that role despite the miscasting). This may be one of his most substantial roles in one of these films although he does not appear until the second act after "commander" Shears (William Holden) has escaped the Japanese POW camp and successfully made it to hospital. There he is eventually greeted by Major Warden who runs an elite commando unit. There are three main characters in the Bridge on the River Kwai who are mad, yet not in the usual way. There is Alec Guinness's Colonel Nicholson, Sessue Hayakawa's Colonel Saito, and Hawkins's Major Warden is the third of these insane men. Although the reason they are most unusual is that they all three happen to be proper soldiers at the same time.

Hawkins differs his performance nicely from Guinness's and Hayakawa's work by playing Major Warden as perhaps just a little bit more self aware than the other two. Hawkins brings a bit more of a purposeful humor to his performance, although Guinness does that to although he shows it as an accidental element of just how proper Nicholson does. Warden instead brings just a bit of playfulness almost in how he handles the stiff upper lipped manner of Warden, as though Warden is certainly in on his personal style to a certain degree. He's particularly good at this in the scene where he asks Holden character's about going on a mission to destroy the titular bridge. Hawkins plays the scene as though Warden is playing with Shears the whole time as he portrays the refined concern as Shears reveals he lied about his rank, but then this works perfectly as Hawkins suggests a purposeful joke, for Warden's own amusement only, as he keeps the same reserve as he reveals that Warden has been aware of this the whole time intending to use it basically even as blackmail to ensure Shears's participation in the job.

The madness still is quite evident in Warden though as Hawkins brings such a callousness in the way Warden seems to treat all things. Even though Hawkins makes more amiable than Saito and Nicholson, the way he play with lives is still there. Hawkins actually makes the humor of Warden rather dark in nature, because he keeps his humorous British reserve no matter what he is talking about early on. Whether he is talking about plastic explosives, knifing a man, or potentially getting killed in a parachute run Hawkins is effective by showing the madness in the way Warden treats all of his in such a lighthearted way. Now Hawkins is good in again he differs somewhat from the other mad men, but somewhat suggesting that maybe Warden isn't quite as fervent as others in his views. Hawkins mostly alludes this subtly through his reactions suggesting the awareness in Warden, and this slight fault in the armor is important once Warden goes on with the mission and leads them to destroy the titular bridge.  

Once on the mission Hawkins drops all the humor suggesting that Warden does take the mission very seriously. Hawkins does not drop the sense that Warden does still have that madness as he even views the death of one of the men simply a set back in his game. This cracks suddenly though when Warden is injured and this may not have worked but Hawkins's reaction is perfection. His reaction is both a shattering of his facade of his ease, but also almost a moment clarity as he seems to understand where he has gone wrong. For the rest of the film Hawkins plays the injured Warden as an understandably far more sorrowful yet more empathetic man. It's technically a sudden change of heart but one that Warden succeeds by suggesting some doubt in the man before as well as delivering in the pivotal moment. Just like almost everyone else in the film Hawkins is great in the final scene with every powerful reaction as he shows Warden finally feeling the weight of his "game" full force without his sort of madness to blind him. I won't say Warden reaches the great heights of Hayakawa and Guinness, he still succeeds in giving a rather fascinating portrait of a well refined mad man.

Wednesday, 7 January 2015

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1957

And the Nominees Were Not:

Lee J. Cobb in 12 Angry Men

Jack Hawkins in The Bridge on the River Kwai

Burt Lancaster in Sweet Smell of Success

Bengt Ekerot in The Seventh Seal 

Gunnar Björnstrand in The Seventh Seal