Alternate Best Actor 1949: Results

5. Trevor Howard in The Passionate Friends- Howard has a limited role, and is overshadowed by a co-star, but he does handle his own role well through his charming performance.

Best Scene: Steven tries to defend his affair.

4. Takashi Shimura in Stray Dog- Shimura creates an effective portrait of a veteran detective effortlessly portraying his character's substantial wisdom, and ability.

Best Scene: Detective Sato manages a baseball game. 

3. Dennis Price in Kind Hearts and Coronets- Price meets the difficult challenge of finding the right tone for his film through his dry and thoroughly witty performance.

Best Scene: Louis defends himself in court. 

2. James Cagney in White Heat- Cagney plays his most evil role with a great deal of energy and he especially stands out when his character goes over the edge.

Best Scene: Cody finds out that his mother is dead.

1. Toshiro Mifune in The Quiet Duel- Good Prediction Mark. Toshiro Mifune gives an excellent performance as man who sacrifices his happiness to do the right thing. It is a powerful poignant performance that shows Mifune's ability to excel in both quiet and flamboyant roles.

Best Scene: The doctor finally breaks down. 

Overall Rank:

1. Toshiro Mifune in Stray Dog
2. Toshiro Mifune in The Quiet Duel
3. David Farrar in The Small Back Room 
4. Chishū Ryū in Late Spring
5. James Cagney in White Heat
6. Kirk Douglas in Champion
7. Ray Milland in Alias Nick Beal 
8. Dennis Price in Kind Hearts and Coronets
9. Takashi Shimura in Stray Dog
10. Van Heflin in Act of Violence
11. Joseph Cotton in The Third Man 
12. John Wayne in She Wore a Yellow Ribbon
13. Robert Ryan in The Set-up 
14. Burt Lancaster in Criss Cross
15. Montgomery Clift in The Heiress 
16. James Mason in Caught 
17. Jean Gabin in The Walls of Malapaga
18. Spencer Tracy in Adam's Rib
19. Howard Vernon in Le Silence de la Mer
20. Anton Walbrook in The Queen of Hearts 
21. Cary Grant in I Was A Male War Bride 
22. James Stewart in The Stratton Story
23. Wendell Corey in Holiday Affair
    
24. Robert Ryan in Caught
25. Edward G. Robinson in House of Strangers
26. Robert Mitchum in The Big Steal
27. Trevor Howard in The Passionate Friends
28. Van Johnson in Battleground
29. Broderick Crawford in All The King's Men
30. Robert Mitchum in Holiday Affair
    
31. Thomas Mitchell in Alias Nick Beal
    
32. Dana Andrews in My Foolish Heart
33. Basil Radford in Whiskey Galore! 
    
34. Richard Conte in House of Strangers
35. Ronald Reagan in The Hasty Heart
36. John Wayne in Sands of Iwo Jima
37. Gregory Peck in Twelve O'Clock High
38. Joseph Cotten in Under Capricorn
39. Richard Todd in The Hasty Heart
40. Gene Kelly in On the Town
41. Frank Sinatra in On the Town
42. Claude Jarman Jr. in Intruder in the Dust
43. John Ireland in All the King's Men
44. Michael Wilding in Under Capricorn
45. Budd Abbott in Africa Screams
46. Lou Costello in Africa Screams
47. Victor Mature in Samson and Delilah
48. David Brian in Intruder in the Dust

Next Year: 1949 Supporting

Alternate Best Actor 1949: Dennis Price in Kind Hearts and Coronets

Dennis Price did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Louis Mazzini in Kind Hearts and Coronets.

Kind Hearts and Coronets is an excellent dark comedy about the son of a disowned daughter of a Dukedom who plans to murder all the heirs in front of him in the D'Ascoyne family (all played by Alec Guinness).

Playing the lead of this film certainly is a challenge as Price must be the one really to create and maintain the tone goes by through his portrayal of the serial killer. Of course Louis Mazzini is not the standard psychopathic serial killer instead he kills as a process to meet his goal of becoming the Duke in spite of the D'Ascoyne's disowning his mother. Price finds the right tone here in a similar manner to the way Charlie Chaplin did for Monsieur Verdoux, although Price probably goes even more head first into the approach than Chaplin did. This approach being that of being incredibly dry in their portrayal.

Dennis Price is all about being dry here which works for Louis perfectly. To have Louis really sadistically enjoy the murders, or to even greatly be troubled by them would not work at all for the tone the film is looking for. Price doesn't either portray his as an every man hero for us to follow either, which also would not have worked for the tone either. Instead he takes the dry approach portraying Louis as a particularly cunning, and astute killer. He makes it so the murders are perhaps personal in a certain way, but for the most part they come off as a bit of a sport that any jolly old man from Britain might find quite agreeable to them.

Price hits just the right note with his portrayal of Louis which is really quite a cold portrayal in a certain way in terms of how he goes about the murders, and even how he goes about his romantic relations with a married childhood friend and the widow of one of the men he has murdered. He is cold which works for the black comedy that is present, but importantly he has just the right degree of wit in his portrayal. This never an obviously humorous portrayal of Louis, except his brief scenes at the beginning when he portrays Louis's Italian father, but a far more subtle ones found in his deadpan within character deliveries of his lines.

Price gives a fairly consistent performance here that is fitting of Louis who is steadfast in his desire to become Duke, and basically starts acting like the would be Duke even before he is one. There are variations to this such as when he is trying to get into the graces of one of his eventual victims or the women in his life. Price does not change all that much in demeanor just changes into slightly more welcoming in his behavior although his eyes always suggest that his mission is always on his mind even when he exchanges pleasantries with the people he intends to kill. This again works in favor of the film's very specific tone.

This is a strong performance by Dennis Price that stays constant in tone and style throughout the film. He keeps it dry, intelligent, and wit filled as the murderous Louis Mazzini. This absolutely works to the benefit of the film that has such a particular and difficult fashion of comedy found in the film. Price makes it all work through his effective and efficient performance that moves through the plot in a fantastic fashion. Honestly this was a performance that if it had been off at all, which would have been very easy to say the least, the whole film could have faltered. Price though succeeds entirely with the role, and in turn allows the film to succeed as well.

Alternate Best Actor 1949

And The Nominees Were Not:

Takashi Shimura in Stray Dog

Toshiro Mifune in The Quiet Duel

James Cagney in White Heat

Dennis Price in Kind Hearts and Coronets

Trevor Howard in The Passionate Friends