Saturday, 13 December 2025

Alternate Best Actor 2004: Results

 9. Gael García Bernal in The Motorcycle Diaries - Creates a striking portrait of a man finding his path, convincing as a man but also granting the traits that would create the myth essentially. 

Best Scene: "Political Speech"
8. Irrfan Khan in Maqbool - Gives a captivating take on the oft played character even if the adaptation makes it all in a bit of a rush. 

Best Scene: Making his final decision. 
7. Christian Bale in The Machinist - Bale gives a compelling depiction of the character's mental anguish within his often noted physical transformation. 

Best Scene: Paranoid outburst
6. Shah Rukh Khan in Swades - Khan gives a properly charismatic and moving portrayal of a man finding his path in life. 

Best Scene: Entertaining during a power outage. 
5. Mads Mikkelsen in Pusher II - Mikkelsen gives a moving portrayal of man going from a thug looking for acceptance towards attempting to find a better life through self-improvement. 

Best Scene: Learning about his son.
4. Yuya Yagira in Nobody Knows - Yagira gives a wholly honest portrayal of both the enforced responsibility of an adult and the frustrated boy within. 

Best Scene: Confronting his mom
3. Bill Murray in The Life Aquatic With Steve Zissou - Murray on the surface gives a very funny Bill Murray deadpan performance, but at the same time a powerful portrayal of a man coming to terms with his mortality. 

Best Scene: "I wonder if he remembers me".
2. Tony Leung in 2046 - Leung delivers a great follow-up performance because he successfully expands the role but also powerfully never loses the strength of his original work, by presenting a man still ever haunted however has to continue to live on.

Best Scene: Rejecting Bai Ling.
1. Paddy Considine in Dead Man's Shoes - Good predictions Luke, Jonathan, Tony, Perfectionist, Lucas, A, Harris, Brazinterma, Omar, Tahmeed & RatedRStar. Despite being the theoretical "hero" Considine delivers an absolutely terrifying but also deeply emotional portrayal of a man with a single unrelenting focus. 

Best Scene: His "Party".

Next: Backlog

31 comments:

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Backlog Recommendations:
1. Devi (1960)
2. A River Called Titas (1973)

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Louis: Your favorite films set in the East Coast, specifically NY and MA? The Holdovers being filmed close to my grad school is just one of the many reasons I love it so much.

BRAZINTERMA said...

Chhabi Biswas - Devi
Tatsuya Nakadai - Kill!
John Heard - Chilly Scenes of Winter
Treat Williams - Prince of the City
Matthew MacFadyen - Pride and Prejudice

Harris Marlowe said...

I recommend The Pitt season 1, and if you have enough time for it later on, a rewatch of Starman.

Ytrewq Wertyq said...

I recommend The Pirates! In an Adventure with Scientists! from 2012. I remember having a lot of fun when watching it.

Robert MacFarlane said...

Movie rec: Housekeeping (1987)

TV rec: The Pitt

As for the backlog, BRAZINTERMA’s choices sound good

Luke Higham said...

Treasure Planet (2002)

Harris Marlowe said...

Louis: Thoughts on the screenplay for Sideways?

Jonathan Williams said...

A re-watch of Sleepy Hollow (1999).

Tony Kim said...

Main rec: Community season 1
Secondary rec: The Crown season 1

If you don't think you'll have enough time to get to Community before the nominations are announced, could you give me a heads-up in advance?

Luke Higham said...

Louis: Ratings and thoughts on the rest of the leading performances.

Your Female Top 20s with ratings and other 4+ honourable mentions.

Matthew Brown said...

I'll recommend Arthur Christmas (2011).

Tony Kim said...

Might be a good time to cover John Heard in CSoW, given how evangelical Robert is about that performance. Maybe Selton Mello too.

Glenn said...

My recommendation is The Illusionist (2010).

Anonymous said...

Path To War (2002) with Gambon and Sutherland.

Luke Higham said...

Completely delighted with Considine getting the win.

Luke Higham said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
BRAZINTERMA said...

Taking advantage of the hype surrounding "The Secret Agent," I recommend some films directed by Kleber Mendonça Filho and starring Wagner Moura:
Critic (2008) documentary
Neighboring Sounds (2012)
Pictures of Ghosts (2023) documentary
Lower City (2005)
Futuro Beach (2014)

Stephen Patterson said...

My recommendation is Samson and Delilah (1949)

David Jones said...

The Family Way (1966). John Mills and Marjorie Rhodes are great.

Thomas said...

I'll recommend The Last Valley (1971) with Michael Caine and Omar Sharif.

Anonymous said...

Last Orders (2001)

Luke Higham said...

My request is Vincent Price in The Abominable Dr. Phibes (1971).

Michael McCarthy said...

My recommendation for is The Seagull (1968) if you want to see James Mason, David Warner and Simone Signoret play three of the greatest characters in 20th century theatre. Mason and Signoret in particular have a spellbinding scene together that’s worth a watch on its own.

Tybalt said...

My recommendation is the great Japanese film Audition, from 1999.

Jonathan Williams said...

Louis: My request is Oliver Reed in The Four Musketeers (1974) I'll recommend its predecessor as soon as you review him.

Luke Higham said...

Tybalt: I've been waiting a long time for someone to recommend Audition.

Louis: Audition is 2000 by your rules.

Shaggy Rogers said...

My recommendations:
Went the Day Well? (1942)
Love Is My Profession (1958)
All the Marbles (1981)
The Story of Qiu Ju (1992)

Shaggy Rogers said...

I agree with Tony about having Selton Mello's review.

Tybalt said...

Louis: I'm curious, how much do you know about the plot and structure of Audition? It's better if you know as little as possible going in.

Luke Higham said...

Louis: Ratings and thoughts on the casts of Shrek 2 and Howl's Moving Castle.