Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1939: Results

5. Thomas Mitchell in Gone With The Wind - Mitchell gives a very strong performance by so effectively realizing the wear of loss through his enthusiastic portrayal before the war and his haunting one after it. 

Best Scene: The return to Tara.

4. Lee J. Cobb in Golden Boy - Cobb completely overcomes his potential miscasting by exuding both the age and background of his character so effortlessly through his performance. Cobb goes even past that to give such striking yet almost silent depiction of the moral center of the film.

Best Scene: Mr. Bonaparte before the fight.

3. Ralph Richardson in the Four Feathers - Richardson gives a powerful performance that effectively steals the spotlight of the film through his depiction of the breakdown of a proper soldier.

Best Scene: Durrance realizes who saved him.

2. Bert Lahr in The Wizard of Oz - Lahr is consistently endearing and hilarious in a performance that stands out among a memorable ensemble through his portrayal of a true scaredy cat.

Best Scene: The Lion's introduction.

1. Cedric Hardwicke in The Hunchback of Notre Dame - Good Predictions Luke, and Anonymous. Among a great field Hardwicke stands at the very top for me in his outstanding portrayal of a zealot's struggle to destroy sin which he sees everywhere including in his own desires.

Best Scene: Frollo reveals his feelings for Esmeralda. 

Overall Rank:

1. Cedric Hardwicke in The Hunchback of Notre Dame
2. Thomas Mitchell in Stagecoach
3. Claude Rains in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
4. Bert Lahr in The Wizard of Oz
5. Frank Morgan in The Wizard of Oz 
6. Ralph Richardson in The Four Feathers
7. Lee J. Cobb in Golden Boy
8. Thomas Mitchell in Gone With the Wind
9. Ray Bolger in The Wizard of Oz
10. Thomas Mitchell in Only Angels Have Wings 
11. John Barrymore in Midnight
12. Jack Haley in The Wizard of Oz
13. Humphrey Bogart in The Roaring Twenties
14. Harry Davenport in Gone With the Wind
15. Edward Arnold in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
16. Leslie Howard in Gone With The Wind
17. Thomas Mitchell in Mr. Smith Goes To Wasington
18. George Bancroft in Stagecoach
19. Don Ameche in Midnight
20. John Carradine in Stagecoach
21. Robert Preston in Beau Geste
22. John Carradine in Jesse James
23. Thomas Mitchell in The Hunchback of Notre Dame
24. Sam Jaffe in Gunga Din 
25. Claude Rains in Juarez
26. Harry Davenport in The Hunchback of Notre Dame
27. John Carradine in Drums Along the Mohawk
28. Brian Donlevy in Beau Geste
29. Eduardo Ciannelli in Gunga Din 
30. Ward Bond in Gone With the Wind
31. C. Aubrey Smith in The Four Feathers
32. Otto Kruger in Another Thin Man
33. J. Carrol Naish in Beau Geste
34. Frank McHugh in Another Thin Man
35. Nigel Bruce in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
36. Sheldon Leonard in Another Thin Man
37. Arthur Shields in Drums Along the Mohawk
38. Donald O'Connor in Beau Geste 
39. Shemp Howard in Another Thin Man
40. Sig Rugman in Only Angels Have Wings
41. Henry Fonda in Jesse James
42. Douglas Fairbanks Jr. in Gunga Din 
43. Adolphe Menjou in Golden Boy 
44. Sig Rugman in Ninotchka
45. Felix Bressart in Ninotchka
46. Alexander Granach in Ninotchka
47. Donald Meek in Young Mr. Lincoln
48. George Zucco in The Adventures of Sherlock Holmes
49. Broderick Crawford in Beau Geste
50. Fredrick Culley in The Four Feathers
51. Humphrey Bogart in Dark Victory
52. Harry Carey in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington 
53. Charley Grapewin in The Wizard of Oz
54. Richard Bathelmess in Only Angels Have Wings
55. Donald Meek in Stagecoach
56. Joseph Calleia in Golden Boy
57. Ward Bond in Drums Along the Mohawk 
58. Jack Allen in The Four Feathers
59. Donald Gray in The Four Feathers
60. Lee Bowman in Love Affair
61. Ward Bond in Young Mr. Lincoln 
62. Paul Henreid in Goodbye, Mr. Chips
63. Guy Kibbee in Mr. Smith Goes to Washington
64. David Niven in Wuthering Heights
65. Morton Lowry in The Hound of the Baskervilles
66. Guy Kibbee in Babes in Arms
67. Henry Hull in Jesse James  
68. Sebastian Shaw in Another Thin Man 
69. Terry Kilburn in Goodbye, Mr. Chips
70. Reginald Gardiner in The Flying Deuces
71. Richard Greene in The Hound of the Baskervilles
72. Jeffrey Lynn in The Roaring Twenties
73. Sidney Blackmer in Convict's Code
74. George Reeves in Gone With the Wind
75. Fred Crane in Gone With the Wind
76. John Garfield in Juarez

Next Up:

An announcement first which is to thank everyone who has been following and continues to comment. I really like how civil the discussions over any films or performances are even when we might disagree vehemently over them. Now I must announce a change in pace due to other obligations. For the time being there probably will only be one review a week and sometimes it might be longer. I'll still leave my thoughts on new movies I see, and update film thoughts now and again. Hopefully in the future I will be able to pick up the pace again, but this is how it has to be for the present.

Now to take a break from trying to find the Best OF before the Bonus Rounds start I'd like to go to the opposite end of things with a WISEAU ROUND (as suggested by Robert MacFarlane). Which means give me your best(worst) performances that are of a different breed entirely.