Saturday, 3 May 2014

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2009

And the Nominees Were Not:

Michael Fassbender in Fish Tank

Michael Fassbender in Inglorious Basterds

August Diehl in Inglorious Basterds

Peter Capaldi in In The Loop

Christian McKay in Me and Orson Welles

Nicholas Tse in Bodyguards and Assassins

Jackie Earle Haley in Watchmen

Jeffrey Dean Morgan in Watchmen

For the Prediction Contest:

Fassbender in Fish Tank

Capaldi

McKay

Tse

Morgan

Friday, 2 May 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Results

5. Nicolas Cage in Bad Lieutenant: Port of Call New Orleans - Nicolas Cage is at his mad best here giving a wildly entertaining depiction of the corrupt and drug addicted bad Lieutenant.

Best Scene: The Lieutenant watches the soul dance.
4. Sam Rockwell in Moon - Rockwell gives two great performances here and creates a genuine moving depiction of two men who have more in common than they would like.

Best Scene: Old Sam tells New Sam to go instead.
3. Tom Hardy in Bronson - Hardy gives an amazing and incredibly magnetic performance that brings to life his very strange and violent character in a compelling fashion.

Best Scene: Bronson's "performance" in regards to the sanitarium.
2. Sharlto Copley in District 9- Sharlto Copley gives one of the greatest feature debut performances of all time in his complex, poignant and surprisingly believable depiction of the transformation from a bureaucrat to a half alien freedom fighter.

Best Scene: Wickus is used as a guinea pig by his own company.
1. Viggo Mortensen in The Road- This was a great year for leading performances and it is real shame that the academy could not be bothered to drift out of traditional baity fair to recognize any of these performances. Although I loved all five of these performances the one that left the most lasting impact on me was Mortensen's performance. He gives his best performance with his heartbreaking and almost painfully realistic portrayal of a single man trying to save his son in the horrible conditions of a post-apocalyptic world.

Best Scene: The man says goodbye to the boy.
Overall Rank:
  1. Viggo Mortensen in The Road
  2. Sharlto Copley in District 9
  3. Tom Hardy in Bronson
  4. Ricardo Darin in The Secret in Their Eyes
  5. Tahar Rahim in A Prophet
  6. Sam Rockwell in Moon
  7. Michael Stuhlbarg in A Serious Man
  8. Nicolas Cage in Bad Lieutenant
  9. Ben Foster in The Messenger
  10. Stephen McHattie in Pontypool
  11. Aaron Taylor-Johnson in Nowhere Boy
  12. Michael Sheen in The Damned United 
  13. Philip Seymour Hoffman in Mary and Max
  14. Ben Whishaw in Bright Star
  15. Filippo Timi in Vincere
  16. Jean Dujardin in OSS 117: Lost in Rio
  17. Patton Oswalt in Big Fan
  18. Hal Holbrook in That Evening Sun
  19. Alex Descas in 35 Shots of Rum
  20. Colin Firth in A Single Man
  21. Paul Giamatti in Cold Souls
  22. Mark Ruffalo in The Brothers Bloom
  23. Jeff Bridges in Crazy Heart
  24. Matt Damon in The Informant!
  25. Vincent Gallo in Tetro
  26. Alden Ehrenreich in Tetro
  27. Luis Tosar in Cell 211
  28. Alberto Ammann in Cell 211
  29. Sébastien Huberdeau in Polytechnique
  30. Song Kang-ho in Thirst
  31. Aamir Khan in 3 Idiots
  32. Robin Williams in World's Greatest Dad
  33. Michael Caine in Harry Brown
  34. Maxim Gaudette in Polytechnique
  35. Adrien Brody in The Brothers Bloom
  36. Jake Gyllenhaal in Brothers
  37. Kodi Smit-McPhee in The Road
  38. Ranbir Kapoor in Wake Up Sid
  39. Jared Leto in Mr. Nobody
  40. Vincent Lindon in Mademoiselle Chambon
  41. Willem Dafoe in Antichrist
  42. Benno Fürmann in Jerichow 
  43. Robert Downey Jr. in Sherlock Holmes
  44. Tony Leung Ka-fai in Bodyguards and Assassins
  45. Johnny Depp in Public Enemies 
  46. Joseph Gordon-Levitt in 500 Days of Summer
  47. Tony Leung Chiu-wai in Red Cliff Part 2
  48. Christopher Plummer in The Imaginarium of Doctor Parnassus
  49. Max Records in Where The Wild Things Are
  50. Barry Humphries in Mary and Max
  51. Bruno Campos in The Princess and the Frog
  52. Russell Crowe in State of Play
  53. Ed Asner in UP 
  54. Michael Nyqvist in The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo
  55. Wyatt Cenac in Medicine for Melancholy
  56. R. Madhavan in 3 Idiots
  57. Sharman Joshi in 3 Idiots
  58. Edgar Flores in Sin Nombre
  59. George Clooney in Fantastic Mr. Fox
  60. Zachary Quinto in Star Trek
  61. Evan McGuire in The Secret of Kells
  62. Jesse Eisenberg in Zombieland
  63. Chris Pine in Star Trek
  64. Chiwetel Ejiofor in 2012
  65. Lluís Homar in Broken Embraces
  66. Jason Palmer in Guy and Madeline on a Park Bench
  67. Bill Hader in Cloudy With a Chance of Meatballs
  68. Daniel Day-Lewis in Nine
  69. Adam Sandler in Funny People
  70. Daniel Radcliffe in The Half-Blood Prince
  71. Hugh Jackman in X-Men Origins Wolverine
  72. Morgan Freeman in Invictus
  73. Rupert Friend in The Young Victoria
  74. James McAvoy in The Last Station
  75. Tobey Maguire in Brothers
  76. Colin Hanks in The Great Buck Howard
  77. Bradley Cooper in The Hangover
  78. Nicolas Cage in Knowing
  79. Jim Carrey in A Christmas Carol
  80. Mark Wahlberg in The Lovely Bones
  81. Seth Rogen in Funny People
  82. George Clooney in Up in The Air 
  83. John Cusack in 2012 
  84. Zac Efron in Me and Orson Welles
  85. Tom Sturridge in The Boat That Rocked
  86. Zach Galifianakis in The Hangover
  87. Ed Helms in The Hangover
  88. Sam Worthington in Avatar
  89. John Krasinski in Away We Go
  90. Quinton Aaron in The Blind Side
Next Year: 2009 Supporting

Thursday, 1 May 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Sam Rockwell in Moon

Sam Rockwell did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Sam Bell in Moon.

Moon is an intriguing film about a seemingly lone man who takes care of power station on the moon.

Sam Rockwell is an actor with a style that is all his own and I would say that makes him a rather perfect choice for a one man show. Moon is mostly a one man show, even though there are some other actors who make very brief appearances, but on the station itself it is only Rockwell and an Artificial Intelligence voiced by Kevin Spacey. Rockwell though is an actor easy to watch for the entire duration of the film as you are at least guaranteed a Rockwellian moment or two which tends to be entertaining. Early on though Rockwell seems to be playing a fairly restrained part for him as he just seems to be playing a lonely man who must do a thankless job alone while wishing he was back on earth with his wife and away from the minutiae that is required for the various tasks he needs to do.

Rockwell is very effective in these subdued moments realizing honestly the boredom of the task that Sam has. Although he is doing work on the moon Rockwell shows every task that Sam handles as just a thing he has to do and there is no wonderment to be had despite where he is. Rockwell establishes Sam incredibly well in these early scenes as he presents the somber mood in the man with just the right hint of optimism whenever he thinks about seeing his wife and child again after his contract ends which he believes will be soon. Rockwell also does well to present a certain physical deterioration in his tired and altogether burnt out demeanor. Rockwell handles this particularly well because at first it seem that it probably is just from being on the Moon for too long, but with that he also sets up properly what really is going wrong with Sam which is revealed later.

A twist comes in the form of another Sam who discovers the other Sam who had an accident with one of the Moon Rovers. Neither of the Sam's are hallucinating but rather they find out that they are both clones who are simply being used by the company as disposable workers for the company. This new Sam is quite a bit different from the old Sam and Rockwell does a fantastic job in creating two separation between the two. What Rockwell shows with the new Sam is probably how the old Sam was when he believed that he had just started the job. Rockwell plays this part with a clear stronger enthusiasm through the character as the new Sam technically has just come to life. This Sam obviously is far more ready for the needs of the job than the old job, and we see him as a man prepared to handle his assignment opposed to the old Sam who just wants to retire.

Rockwell goes even further with distinguishing though the two than just simply from their differing amount of time in existence. Rockwell also effectively does create two separate feeling personalities in the two well still making the two seem the same man in the core. One of the major factors for this is suggested by Rockwell frankly to their knowledge of being a clone. The new Sam has learned this basically from his creation whereas the Old Sam has had to live for almost three years thinking he was a normal man all along. This leads them onto two different paths as men as well as with dealing their situation. With the old Sam Rockwell presents a more reflective man who must face this revelation for all its pain. Rockwell is very poignant in showing the depression that grows in this Sam who frankly has lived too long thinking he was a man to be told that he wasn't.

The new Sam on the other hand is shown by Rockwell to take a far more aggressive approach in regards to dealing with being a clone. This Sam wants to action quickly and intends to try hard to find out where exactly it is that the new clones are made from. At the same time this Sam is far quicker to anger especially when the old Sam in the way of finding where the secret room may be. Rockwell plays the aggression perfectly as he does not play at if the new Sam is need in some anger management. No instead Rockwell suggests it through the reaction of the cloning problem for the new Sam. The new Sam seems less openly troubled by it, but actually Rockwell alludes to all this anger stemming from his own reaction to the cloning even though unlike the other Sam he is able to take his response and try to pull it into doing something constructive.

One of the best aspects of Rockwell's performance is actually his chemistry with himself and even though there is only one Sam Rockwell it feels like a two man show. The two Sam's are always distinct characters in Rockwell's hands in through doing that he honestly creates an very interesting dynamic between the two. It is particularly complex one as a man technically is interacting with himself and Rockwell does technically have some of the same qualities between the two as he should but where they differ makes their interactions all the more interesting to watch. Rockwell is effortlessly in making it seem like two clones believably dealing with each other in their conflicts which does not play as just Rockwell yelling at himself. It's much more interesting with Rockwell attuning the intensity of each to their different state of minds from their time as clones.

What is amazing is that Rockwell, despite the strangeness of the whole prospect, honestly creates a very natural bond that slowly builds as the two try to find out a way to try and beat the horrible system that they have been placed in my their deceitful company. Rockwell is incredibly moving by realizing the friendship between the two so delicately as the old Sam wastes away, and the new Sam slowly begins to care more and more for his old clone. This whole concept could have just seemed silly or played purely for laughs but that's not the case as Rockwell gives such a surprising about of heart to his performances. Rockwell actually does get some humor out of the concept to be sure, but he does it extremely well by letting it come out in such a genuine way from the reactions the two clones have throughout their time together.

Everything about Moon might not have worked if it was not for the devoted performance by Sam Rockwell who manages to give two great performances in this film as both the Old and the New Sam. Although it can easily be said that it is seems like a pretty flamboyant idea for an actor to play two roles particularly if it is Sam Rockwell in that role and had Rockwell been that way in this film certainly probably would have been entertaining to be sure. Rockwell dials it back here considerably and it pays off in spades giving not one but two poignant portraits of a man who discovers that his whole existence is a lie. I know I've already given four fives so far in my reviews of 2009,  and that's because I loved all of those performances. All I can say is I loved this performance too.

Wednesday, 30 April 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Viggo Mortensen in The Road

Viggo Mortensen did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite getting a few critical mentions, for portraying the man in The Road.

The Road is an effective film about a man and his son trying to survive after the apocalypse.

Viggo Mortensen is no stranger to playing heroic characters but in The Road his character is a far cry from the wandering King Aragorn in The Lord of the Rings. Mortensen here only plays a man known as simply the man as formal names are never given. Mortensen seems like the perfect fit for such moniker considering he has a definite everyman quality to him, and this is further helped by his naturalistic style of acting. This average man though is not in any average situation though as some cataclysmic event occurs suddenly throwing the world into a post-apocalyptic landscape where few people survive, the plant life and most of the animals seem dead, and many of the human who still survive are cannibals who hunt down other survivors and sometimes even use them as if they were cattle.

There are a few scenes set before the man must wander the world with his son, the boy (Kodi Smit-McPhee). These are shown a few times early on in the film as we the Man and his wife, the woman (Charlize Theron), are first dealing with the event while the woman has to give birth to the boy. Mortensen is excellent in these few scenes by showing a different man than we see in the scenes set in the present. Mortensen portrays the Man much gentler and is exceptional in the way he suggests the lack of the current experience in the man. Mortensen properly gives us the man before the end where we see perhaps the man who had been living a good life. The scenes could have easily seemed unnecessary to the film as a whole but Mortensen uses them brilliantly as establishes so well the man who was of the old world and not the horrible one we see him existing in for the majority of the film.

Mortensen also powerfully creates though the beginning of the deterioration through his personal loss in one scene where the woman basically resigns herself from life and decides to leave the man and the boy just to go out into the darkness and just die somewhere. Mortensen is absolutely heartbreaking in the scene as the man tearfully asks her not to go. What makes the most so particularly moving is because Mortensen gives us the futile nature of the man's pleading. Mortensen plays it as the man knowing she is going to leave and that there isn't anything he will be able to do about. In the moment Mortensen makes the loss completely palatable despite the brevity of these scenes. We get very little of the relationship between the woman and the man and the scene comes relatively quickly. Mortensen is able to put forward that love the man shares with the woman and realize the better times while barely seeing making the loss something truly felt.

The rest of the film takes place in the bleak present where the man moves from place to place with his son in attempt to try to find food and some sort of refuge. Mortensen is excellent in these scenes as we see the years in this environment in his face and every physical mannerism of the man. Mortensen's eyes are absolutely haunting in every scene as we basically see what the man has seen within them. There is the history of loss in his expression as we see happiness is something far from what has every been found within his face. The man is slowly dying throughout the film from an unknown lung related ailment that only worsens as the film proceeds. Mortensen's portrayal of this as well as simply the ravages of starvation is harrowing to witness. There never seems to be any acting seen here, Mortensen manages to bring us this man in this situation.

Mortensen very importantly creates a very effective dynamic with Smit-McPhee as the son as he makes the man have a very particular relationship with his son, particular because of the world they must live in. On one hand Mortensen brings the needed warmth in the role and it always makes it obvious that the man loves his son deeply, even though Mortensen does well in often subtly suggesting than always coming out with it in a needlessly overt fashion. The reason that is so important is because the man is suppose to betraying to make it so the son will be ready to face what's left of the world even after the man's death. Mortensen does not make it a distance but rather very honestly portrays the attempts to make the son ready like any good father making his son ready but with far different circumstances. There is no coldness in it, but Mortensen gives the right bluntness in the father's attempts at teaching his son.

Mortensen never wastes a moments in their interactions as he brings such complexity to the relationship. Two of the most heart wrenching scenes are one slightly calmer and one more intense due to the predicament they find themselves in are when the father is trying to show the son how to commit suicide with a gun. The first time Mortensen shows it to be an unfortunate somber remainder to his son, and there is always that extra effort that Mortensen suggests in his performance, which exemplifies that the father does not want to do this, but he simply must. The other is when they believe themselves to be possibly caught by cannibals, and the man for a moments believes he must mercy kill the boy. It is an unforgettable scene because Mortensen makes the horrible nature of the moment only ever ring truthfully as his performance only reflects what any good man would be going through in such a moment.

Mortensen is incredible in realizing a man who tries to hold onto a decency even though it is extremely difficult to do so. Mortensen is fantastic in any moment where the man must set aside his morals for the moment due to the fact he must protect his son. This includes an early encounter with an encounter with an obvious cannibal. Mortensen gives a very moving portrayal by so authentically creating the desperation in the man as he must basically force himself to kill the man as there is no other way. When trying to avoid this Mortensen is so great at showing that the man tries every ounce to handle the man in a peaceful way, and once again shows that extra effort he must put forward to deal with the situation. Mortensen never makes the man an otherworldly hero, but rather very powerfully making him a man who is giving every ounce himself to protect his son and be one of the good guys. 

The film thankfully has a reprieve of sorts where the man and the boy happen upon a survival bunker that is stocked with supplies. The scene allows them to leave their current situation and sort of return what would likely be their normal relationship. Mortensen is terrific in this scene because we briefly see many of the fears and paranoia that had been slowly growing rest. It is a wonderful moment as Mortensen let's even more of the warmth and love the father has to give come out. Mortensen in this scene shows even more that has been lost by showing what has been gained by this comfort. Mortensen again carefully does not overplay the optimism instead beautifully suggesting but never going too far as the man's unfortunate suspicions come to play once again when they hear people who seem to be following them.

This is a complete triumph by Viggo Mortensen as he carries the film upon his shoulders. Although John Hillcoat's direction realizes the apocalypse in all its cryptic detail it is Mortensen that makes the story resonate through his depiction of the man. Even though the story may take place in a fictional time and place this will never be found in Mortensen almost unbearably honest performance. Even though he is only a man and is named so simply as man there is nothing simple about Mortensen's man. He completely realizes every facet of this man's struggle with his son and the final moments of the man's life are devastating to witness because there is not a false breath in Mortensen's work. This is monumental performance by the great Viggo Mortensen and I have no hesitations with calling it his very best performance.   

Saturday, 26 April 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Joseph Gordon-Levitt in 500 Days of Summer

Joseph Gordon-Levitt did not receive Oscar nomination, despite being nominated for a Golden Globe, for portraying Tom Hansen in 500 Days of Summer.

500 Days of Summer is about the highs and lows of a relationship between two young adults. The first time I watched it I thought it was fine enough, on re-watch though it's style wore very thin very quickly for me.

Joseph Gordon-Levitt plays the male lead in Tom Hansen an aspiring architect, obviously, who works at a greeting card company. Tom is technically speaking a hopeless romantic in that he is a fervent believer in true love and intends to find it in his crush who works at the same company Summer (Zooey Deschanel), who shares no such beliefs with Tom and makes that rather clear very early on to him. The film jumps back and forth in the timeline sometimes to the beginning of their relationship which is straight out of a romantic movie with certain flamboyant acts. Many other scenes depict the end of the relationship with Summer simply insisting that they should only be friends with Tom dreading this idea. We then get various quirky stylistic flourishes from the direction which bridge the various scenes together.

Joseph Gordon-Levitt whole performance is one of a particular style as well as often he must fit in these various flourishes of the director Marc Webb which includes even a musical number after Tom has consummated the relationship. There are mostly two halves to the performance particularly early on. On one side there is the Tom pursuing Summer and starting the relationship with her. On this side Gordon-Levitt is fairly charming enough and his enthusiasm in these scenes are endearing enough. Also in these screes are some wacky moments which well they are indeed there with Gordon-Levitt needing to be awkwardly hilarious. I did not find him awkwardly hilarious, but he is more than entirely fine in these scenes as well. On the other side set in the future though Tom is quite the opposite.

In the scenes set later Tom is basically in a set state of depression mixed with a hatred both due to Summer's treatment of him. The film and Gordon-Levitt don't mind really saying that Tom is a bit of a self-absorbed jerk in this regard and this is the way he plays it. I imagine though it is also meant to be fairly comedic in nature as Tom is unable to be reasoned with in his state. Gordon-Levitt certainly gets the points across as he should and the fairly simple way of playing does make sense for the character as Tom is suppose to be so set on his ideas of romance that anything else causes him to basically shut down. Anyway though again I did not find the performance particularly hilarious, and although I think he got the point of Tom across well enough it still did not make his character especially compelling or interesting to watch.

After a certain point the film becomes a bit more regulated as does Gordon-Levitt performance as he basically shows Tom having learned his lesson therefore basically taking things to less of an extreme. In turn he does the same with his performance no longer being so enthusiastic in the happy moments but not nearly as depressed and angry in the bad moments. Tom basically just starts to deal with things like a man who is more assured when it comes to facing things realistically. Gordon-Levitt is once again completely solid in these scenes which are certainly quieter but probably more natural in style. He once again fulfills the need of the character's change in attitude and is believable, even though again he never made to get caught up too much, or frankly even care that much about Tom's problems.

This whole performance came off as just fine to me in basically every way in that there were not any scenes where I hated his performance but he failed to ever impress me either. This isn't even a standard romantic lead turn as Tom is suppose to be slightly insufferable and Gordon-Levitt shows that well enough just like how he does pretty much everything well enough. He is charming enough, he has enough energy in the role, he has enough passion when he needs it, and he is always clearly trying more than enough. Enough I suppose means that I would describe this as a good performance, and I'll call it a good performance, but I won't call it a great one or one that made me care any more about the film. Now it is time for me to go batten down the hatches.

Thursday, 24 April 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Tom Hardy in Bronson

Tom Hardy did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Michael Peterson also known as Charles Bronson in Bronson.

Bronson is stylish and effective film about the man dubbed to be Britain's most violent prisoner.

This is my first review of a performance by Tom Hardy who is one of the most interesting younger actors around the reason for this can easily be seen through his performance here. Hardy physically transformed himself in the role, as he again did playing Bane later on, he built himself to be a hulking individual. Hardy's muscle bound physique certainly adds to to the whole film, and without a doubt Hardy makes himself look like the real man while also making it so you never once doubt the criminal nature of his character. Hardy hardly leaves the muscles to do the work though in creating Michael Peterson/Charles Bronson and meeting the challenge found in playing in this film. The man is already rather odd individual to begin with from what he did in reality, but this film is not solely interested in the more literal events of the man's life.

A substantial amount of the film is a performance within the performance by Hardy, and even this is broken into two segments of sorts. One where Bronson appears to be performing in front of an audience some strange reenactment of his life, and another where he is directly we as the audience in a form of narration. In his narration Hardy stares straight at you with a fierce intensity quite fitting the brutal nature of the man. Along with that you get the unwavering accent that Hardy uses in the role. It always comes off as completely naturally which is important and it also amplifies Bronson's nature quite brilliantly. The reenactment is quite different though in that you could kind of say that Hardy is playing another role since not only does Bronson act as though he is someone else but also these scenes are suppose to be a performance.

Hardy is incredibly magnetic in these scenes and it is fascinating just to watch him perform as Bronson performing his various acts. Hardy has the right type of fun in these scenes as brings out the joy of performance to be sure but he rather shrewdly does it through the character of Bronson rather than seeming as though it is coming from Hardy himself. Hardy's method is particularly in that he manages to show such a delight in Bronson in basically every part of his life that he describes no matter what it may entail even if what it entails some rather brutal crimes which are usually some rather brutal beatings for all involved. Hardy very simply is amazing to watch though in every moment he has, and honestly Hardy probably could have made a compelling film if all the film was Bronson's very bizarre stage performance.

The rest of the film we follow Michael Peterson in his A Clockwork Orange type of story as we follow him through his most unusual life of crime. His life of crime is particularly odd because throughout the film he only commits a few crimes outside of prison. The scenes outside of prison are brief but Hardy makes the most of them in the way he plays with Bronson's behavior. Hardy has this element he brings in Bronson as he tries to interact in the outside world where there is a constant awkwardness to him. Hardy always brings this fairly odd intensity in it in that it is not why you might expect. There certainly is the more traditional violent intensity in Hardy's performance but there is more to that than that. The intensity Hardy infuses is that of a man who seems unable to really respond like a normal person in that Hardy shows that Bronson never seems right in any scene where he is on the outside.

Bronson barely spends any time outside though and spends most of the time in prison where he technically does not really fit either since he spends most of his time beating guards as brutally as possible in turn being beaten himself and being thrown into solitary confinement. Bronson is a most unusual man and Hardy in turn gives a most unusual performance yet it always seems genuine in the creation of the man. Bronson is not a character who really has much of an arc in that although he has a pattern he does not really change much as man no matter what might be going on. That does not mean the character or Hardy's performance ever becomes uninteresting or repetitive as Hardy turns Bronson into such peculiar but always compelling character no matter what even when it is always rather doubly reinforced how much of a brute that he might be.

Hardy is very charismatic with Bronson and he carries a unquestionable presence in every scene he is in, and purposefully makes Bronson an entity who insists upon himself. Hardy allows it to be believed that anyone would spend more than a moment with Bronson through the strange charisma he does derive through performance. There is some odd slight refinement that Hardy gives the man that seems completely opposed to the man himself especially in light of his various action throughout the film, but Hardy makes it exactly who Bronson is. The funny thing about it is there is no moment in which Hardy ever really lies about the nature of Bronson either, or tries to show Bronson lying in some way. No instead Hardy makes this alluring qualities to the man something that is part of the madness that lies within him.

Bronson is a brutal man though whose greatest past time is beating others or trying his hardest to get into a situation where he will beat others. Hardy presents Bronson as a man who lives for the fight in terms of both a sadistic glee he gets from his success, but also everything surrounding the build up to the fight. Even in the real experiences Hardy still treats Bronson as giving a performance in the fight scenes, fitting for the movie star name he has adopted, in that Bronson likes the build it up proper. Again it is pure insanity as he threatens extreme violence just to take a violent beating himself, while doing odd things like having a guard oil him up like a wrestler, it is all insanity and Hardy is terrific because all of the insanity seems uniquely part of Bronson. He's crazy to be sure and his actions are absurd, but Hardy only ever presents makes them the strange expressions of Bronson.

One great set of scenes for Hardy involve when Bronson is sent to a mental institution instead of a prison. Hardy uses these scenes well to show a slightly different side of Bronson that also suggests more about Bronson as a whole. In these scenes Hardy shows Bronson honestly most as an actual prisoner more than he is in the actual prisons. In these moments his chances for violence and for the fight are severely limited and Hardy for once tones down his magnetism. In the sterile environment Hardy makes Bronson a man completely lost for once and that what he lives for is the fight, and really without his chances for violence Bronson basically loses his spark in life. Hardy rather interestingly perhaps does indeed make Bronson at his most "sane" technically speaking, and in doing so allows us to see why exactly he behaves the way he does in prison.

This is a fantastic performance by Tom Hardy as he simply realizes Bronson as a person and allows us to observe this strange man for the duration of the film. Bronson could have easily been just a repulsive figure and he technically still is even as Hardy plays him, but Hardy makes him such a watchable repulsive man. Hardy realizes Bronson so perfectly that he does indeed just becomes Charles Bronson which is quite an achievement no only because he realizes the larger than life qualities of the man both literally and metaphorically he also realizes the man as vividly man  and in doing so making sense of a man who's actions so often can seem rather senseless. Bronson could have fallen apart if the lead performance was at all inadequate, but Hardy has a unquestionable grasp on the material and carries the film on his back rather magnificently.

Monday, 14 April 2014

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Sharlto Copley in District 9

Sharlto Copley did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Wickus Van Mere in District 9.

District 9 could be viewed as the good version of Avatar as it actually an interesting and entertaining film about a difficult relationship between humans and an odd group of aliens.

Sharlto Copley before moving into playing a variety of wackos made his acting debut in his friend Neil Blomkamp's own feature film debut which is this film. Here Copley plays a much more down to earth fellow mentally this time around. In the opening of the film he is in fact no more than a bureaucrat ordered to take charge in the eviction of the Aliens from District 9 who are to be sent to another camp named District 10. Wickus spends his early time directly addressing the screen as Wickus is being the sort of star of a documentary video as he goes about his task. Copley is great in introducing us to Wickus as the corporate drone of sorts. The reason being because of just how realistically that he creates Wickus early on despite this being a film about stranded Aliens.

Copley smartly treats the role by playing Wickus simply as man who is being followed in his job as in a real documentary. Although a corporate man Copley still nicely plays Wickus as a man and at the start he is very effective in showing such a genuine excitement in Wickus as he receives his promotion along with his new assignment to remove the Aliens. Copley is particularly likable in the role even in these moments where he could have been unlikable simply because how much life he does bring in the part. Yes he is a bureaucrat to be sure, but Copley very naturally suggests that there is obviously at least a little more to the man than that. Copley makes him a feel like a completely real man even before we see him evict any Aliens, and in dong so he grounds the film incredibly well that could have easily become far too detached otherwise.

Although the film does not mind showing Wickus to be a more than a little out of his element as he tries to perform the evictions, and Copley does not mind showing this really either, he very importantly does indeed act as an excellent guide through District 9. Copley holds these scenes together incredibly well through the naturalism that he brings to the part. The reason for this is how well he plays the fact that Wickus is making a documentary at this point. In that point Copley properly brings a constant energy in the scenes that only reflect a particular passion that Wickus has to make a good impression in the documentary, but also just the baser sense that he is happy to be the star so to speak. Along with that though Copley brings the right pride in just the way Wickus walks as well as espouses his information of the land as if he were the expert he needs to be for this job.

Copley carefully shifts though depending on the situation as he should in a proper fashion that shows Wickus shifting gears when needed. Whenever Wickus is actually going through the process of evicting Copley effectively brings out the bureaucrat all the more as he attempts to portray Wickus as all business. Copley brings the right weakness in Wickus's manner in these scenes as it is easy to see the cracks in him as he tries to act tough in front of the Aliens. Again though I like that Copley does not overplay that though as he never makes Wickus defined by it by any means. Copley is good in bringing the strong bluster in Wickus trying to be in charge, but Copley shows that he just really does not have it in him. Copley very realistically brings the attitude of a man who really just is not that good at his job, but really is trying very hard to be.

Copley is also terrific when things begin to go wrong during his attempted evictions such as when the Aliens commit violent acts or perhaps even he makes eye contact with a local human crime lord. Copley shifts perfectly in these scenes always to reflect the intensity of them. He even twists quite cleverly yet still realistically though by showing Wickus's strong attempt to try and seem like he still knows what he is doing despite it seeming obvious that he is in over his head. Copley is great by showing how every encounter shakes up Wickus a little more and he makes Wickus filled with far less confidence and a far more nervous fellow then he was at the beginning. This only becomes much worse for poor Wickus though when Wickus accidentally sprays a strange liquid upon himself that came from a hidden canister from one of the Aliens's shacks. 

That liquid causes Wickus to suffer severely and Copley once again delivers brilliantly with this aspect of his performance. Wickus start out becoming ill and Copley does not just leave it to spewing black liquid from his orifices. Copley brings the illness alive through his portrayal and his depiction of Wickus's physical degradation is made odd believable because of him. After he is done for the day Wickus collapses at home finding himself in the hospital, but much worse than that he finds that his hand has become the same hand that belongs to the Aliens. Copley's reaction is outstanding because he merely conveys what most men's reaction would be to discovery this. The horror in his eyes and panic is painfully raw. Copley is very powerful in that scene as well as the proceedings scenes where his company uses him as a guinea pig, but being just so honest in his performance.

 The film technically takes a rather drastic turn as he goes on the run seeking refuge in District 9 while gradually transforms more into the Alien. Copley capitalizes on the fact at the beginning of the film he always manged humanize Wickus even though he was a bit of dope. This is especially important when the film expects us to become completely invested in him as he must try to cure himself and avoid being dissected by his company. Copley allowed the right sympathy by never turning Wickus into a caricature earlier therefore when Wickus's life is threatened it becomes very easy to feel for his plight. The film does not spend too much time on Wickus's regrets as he ends up with teaming up with one of the Aliens, it pretty much leaves it to Copley's portrayal of Wickus's reactions to the Alien. That is all that is needed as Copley's naturalism shines through as we see the shame and regret in him, but Copley keeps it subtle fitting to a man who's problems are quite pressing.

The last act of the film is very action oriented as Wickus has to fight off by the armed company men and plenty of criminals who want him for their use. All of the action could have easily overwhelmed Copley's performance and he could have easily just been kind of there. Copley never let's that happen though making the most of all of his reactions. Yes Wickus kind of does become an action hero through his use of the alien armaments, but Copley does not play it that way. Copley brings the right awe in Wickus's astonishment at most of what he does, as well still bringing the appropriate fear and desperation as he is forced into this situation he never wanted to be a part of. Copley that carries this film so flawlessly. He does this because in every step, even though it is science fiction, even though he plays a guy who is turning into alien, who always makes Wickus feel like a real person through his portrayal of every emotion he goes through. He gives a great performance that is probably one of the best feature film debuts I've seen.