Showing posts with label Song Kang-ho. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Song Kang-ho. Show all posts

Sunday, 30 July 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Results

10. Song Kang-ho in Thirst - The film is a bit too scattershot overall for Song to truly make something special out of his priest turned vampire. He's good, but it's a lot less than you'd hope for. 

Best Scene: Ending. 
9. Paul Giamatti in Cold Souls - Paul Giamatti as himself is an idea with potential, but really doesn't add up to too much. He's good as himself but it isn't something special.

Best Scene: Feeling too much. 
8. Hal Holbrook in That Evening Sun - Holbrook is consistently honest, despite working with a very weak script. 

Best Scene: Reconciling with his son.  
7. Ben Whishaw in Bright Star - Whishaw unsurprisingly brings a natural ease and power to a poet, both in words but also hidden longing. 

Best Scene: Last meeting. 
6. Aaron Taylor-Johnson in Nowhere Boy - Taylor-Johnson gives a terrific depiction of John Lennon, by not playing to the icon, but rather finding the young man before it all. 

Best Scene: Reacting to his uncle's death. 
5. Stephen McHattie in Pontypool - McHattie rather wonderfully sells every extreme turn the film sends him in, going through unscathed even when the films gets ridiculous. 

Best Scene: Heroic broadcast. 
4. Ben Foster in The Messenger - Foster gives a striking depiction of self contained PTSD and the potent struggles of the man dealing with home and the memories of war.  

Best Scene: Second report.  
3. Michael Stuhlbarg in A Serious Man - Stuhlbarg gives a hilarious but also very human depiction of a man falling apart. 

Best Scene: Breaking in front of his lawyer. 
2. Tahar Rahim in A Prophet - Rahim gives a brilliant portrait of the slow adaptation of a young man lost, to finding his way to survive in a horrible situation and then mastering it.   

Best Scene: The murder. 
1. Ricardo Darin in The Secret in Their Eyes - Good predictions Luke, Perfectionist (x2),Bryan, Omar, Calvin, Emi Grant (x2) & RatedRStar.  Darin gives an absolutely wonderful performance that makes every disparate tone and story element cohere but also amplifies them into a performance that is so much all in one performance.

Best Scene: The train. 

Next: 2009 Supporting

Friday, 26 May 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2009: Song Kang-ho in Thirst

Song Kang-ho did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Sang-hyun in Thirst.

Thirst tells the story of a priest who gets infected with a deadly virus that he survives through a blood transfusion that turns him into a vampire. 

If just getting to the vampire part seems complicated, it is, and in this instance, I would say overly complicated. The whole first act of Thirst I would say is a rambling narrative as it touches upon several different ideas but in a way that is just a mess of them rather than any cohesive tapestry. We have our priest played by Song of course, who is going about his duties for dying patients. Song portrays the character very much as any priest you might see often in such scenes, having this calm dignity about him, and careful manner as he goes about administrating prayers and last rites. We essentially have the common priest for many an introspective film, as we see him in private quarters pained over potential doubts and that careful manner seems to show a depressed mood after all. Song certainly portrays this effectively and grants you a sense of the specific malaise of the man behind the apparent dignity. We then jump to his potentially suicidal act by asking to be part of an experimental vaccine for a deadly virus that will most likely kill him. And when asking for this Song certainly conveys just a man staring into the void seemingly without purpose in his life. And through the series of odd circumstances leads up to the other side as a cured man but as a vampire. Leading again for his local congregation to see him as a true healer, and I'll bluntly say this whole aspect of the film could've been cut out. It never really goes anywhere, or at least anywhere interesting, and frankly, Sang-hyun seems just slightly baffled by them. I'd extend that to really his occupation as a priest is nearly set dressing because aspects of faith and morality are barely considered and really only leave this one thread, represented by a one-note group of believers, that amount to absolutely nothing. I think again Song is more than fine in presenting sort of the man going through the motions as the healer, even as his belief is clearly failing him. 

The film remains on shaky ground as we explore Sang-hyun as he begins his feelings of bloodlust but also sexual lust that often seems more dominating than his blood lust more often than not. We discover this through his frequent visit to a family of his parishioners which includes Tae-ju (Kim Ok-bin), the young wife fed up with her husband and family. And here where the film really continues to be sloppy as Sang-hyun and Tae-ju begin an affair, and I would say would be his vampire allure I guess. Because in this stage of the relationship, Song and Kim's chemistry is limited at best. There's more than a little missing in the puzzle particularly if you say compare it to the relationship in Decision to Leave, where you instantly felt here, here it honestly just feels forced...at the start. This is both the writing and acting I think, as writing wise there just isn't enough substance to create any meaningful connection or even just lust between them, and performance wise the urge also specifically between them seems somewhat absent. Song isn't bad in these scenes mind you, he's good in presenting the hidden growing lust within his own performance, but the importance given to the relationship makes it seem like there should be more. Outside of those scenes what we get from Song is essentially the portrayal of the vampire as a junkie. And here Song is quite good in just exuding constant desperate need. Where he successfully switches within the moments of being completely enthralled in his desperate lust for blood and creates the vicious sense of that titular thirst. Against moments where he creates internally the pained conflict of the man literally drinking blood and the shame in it. He successfully creates the constant pull of conflict within the character of Sang-hyun and fashions successfully the idea of creating a very real idea within the mythic concept of vampirism. 

Where the film gets interesting, if not entirely non-sloppy still, is when he begins to take Tae-ju as a partner in his crimes, as she asks him to kill her husband for him. This is when they actually do discover some actual chemistry, what was missing in the just initial relationship, is found once they start realizing the "bond" is a wholly toxic one. This is where things get more interesting and Song's performance, while it has been always good, becomes its most dynamic. His performance particularly comes to life in terms of embodying the conflict of Sang-hyun who doesn't want to be a vampire but has to be one. In these moments about going for the murder, we see him go to his lowest, where Song conveys in his eyes the peak of the desperation that he accentuates as a mix between sexual lust, straight up hunger but also this sort of depressive urge to fall into a kind of despair that goes along with him at his lowest morality. Although I'll still say it doesn't quite have *it* in terms of making this a truly captivating depiction just yet. In fact, you have to go through him murdering the husband, then Tae-ju almost dying due to becoming regretful, which really doesn't feel earned, and leading her to almost die causing Sang-hyung to turn her into a vampire. Song portrays this moment well in instantly evoking such a striking sense of loneliness as he spirals into the act and revives her against his best judgment. And here is where we get slightly closer to something truly captivating, though not really writing wise, as Tae-ju becomes entirely vicious as a vampire and proceeds to kill indiscriminately. Song's performance shifts from the completely messed up drug addict to the one trying to temper his psychotic co-dependent. And there is something in his reaction as we see the sense of honest fear of what has he done and the attempts to be any sort of directing figure for her while she goes off on the deep end. Eventually leading to the ending of the film where he decides they need to both die from the sun, and here is where I most liked Song and the film in general. The quiet calm conviction in Song's performance as he shows perhaps the priest of old trying to hold strongly onto what is the right thing to do while also conveying the severity of what this choice means. He is moving in a subtle manner he takes as he quietly embraces Tae-ju, after fighting with her attempts to survive, and accepts their mutual fate. Having said that, my review probably seems all over the place, because for me the film was all over the place. There are moments I really like, maybe even love, in this film, but they are pieces of a puzzle that don't fit together. Even this ending could've been something truly special if we had a stronger connection to the relationship from start to finish. Instead, it is a messy situation that keeps far from one of Park Chan-wook's best films. Song for his efforts is good, consistently good even, but I'll be honest this is not one of his best performances, for me. There are aspects that suggest he could've brought something special, however, the unwieldy nature of the film, also keeps him from being able to craft a completely cohesive portrait of the reluctant vampire. 

Saturday, 20 May 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2009

And the Nominees Were Not:

Ricardo Darin in Secret in Their Eyes

Ben Whishaw in Bright Star

Michael Stuhlbarg in A Serious Man

Song Kang-ho in Thirst

Stephen McHattie in Pontypool

Predict these five, those five or both:

Tahar Rahim in A Prophet

Aaron Taylor-Johnson in Nowhere Boy

Ben Foster in The Messenger

Hal Holbrook in That Evening Sun

Paul Giamatti in Cold Souls

Saturday, 25 February 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2022: Results

10. Song Kang-ho in Broker - Song brings a  naturalistic and charming chemistry even if the film tasks him to go into some less than natural directions for this character late in the film. 

Best Scene: Seeing his daughter. 
9. Robert Pattinson in The Batman - Pattinson gives a great depiction of Batman that gives a greater insight within the development of the character and the different shades of his identity. 

Best Scene: "Bruce WAAAYNE"
8. Christopher Abbott in On the Count of Three - Abbott gives a captivating depiction of a man on an extreme mental edge that manages to be intense, heartwrenching but also at times rather funny. 

Best Scene: Seeing the high school bully. 
7. Mehdi Bajestani in Holy Spider - Bajestani gives an extremely disturbing portrayal of a man whose depravity goes far beyond just psychopathy. 

Best Scene: "Not Crazy"
6. Mark Rylance in The Outfit - Rylance amplifies his film every step of the way, giving a consistently captivating portrayal of a man who essentially weaponizes modesty. 

Best Scene: "I'm the mole"
5. Alexander SkarsgÃ¥rd in the Northman - SkarsgÃ¥rd delivers a powerful performance that goes beyond just his tremendous physical presence and also gives a potent portrayal of the emotional weight of his journey. 

Best Scene: The Queen's truth. 
4. Felix Kammerer in All Quiet on the Western Front - Kammerer gives a heartbreaking portrayal of the effects of war, both in terms of the bonds between soldiers and of the terrible mental degradation from the losses and horrors suffered throughout his experience. 

Best Scene: In the crater. 
3. Timothée Chalamet in Bones and All - Chalamet delivers for me his best performance, that offers an honest off-beat charisma, a fantastic chemistry with his co-star, and a powerful emotional vulnerability, all in his depiction of a cannibal. 

Best Scene: What really happened with his dad. 
2. Ralph Fiennes in The Menu - Fiennes gives an amazing performance that manages to be extremely intense, but also incredibly hilarious as his hate and regret filled killer chef. 

Best Scene: A cheeseburger. 
1. Park Hae-il in Decision to Leave - Park gives an entirely captivating and absolutely haunting portrayal of obsession. 

Best Scene: The snowy mountain.
Overall:
  1. Colin Farrell in The Banshees of Inisherin
  2. Park Hae-il in Decision to Leave
  3. Bill Nighy in Living
  4. Ralph Fiennes in The Menu
  5. Timothée Chalamet in Bones and All
  6. Felix Kammerer in All Quiet on the Western Front
  7. Paul Mescal in Aftersun
  8. Alexander Skarsgård in the Northman
  9. Mark Rylance in The Outfit
  10. Mehdi Bajestani in Holy Spider - 5
  11. Ram Charan in RRR
  12. N.T. Rama Rao Jr in RRR
  13. Christopher Abbott in On the Count of Three
  14. Robert Pattinson in The Batman
  15. Mark Rylance in The Phantom of the Open
  16. Song Kang-ho in Broker
  17. Adeel Akhtar in Ali & Ava
  18. Jonathan Majors in Devotion
  19. Denis Ménochet in As Bestas
  20. Daniel Giménez Cacho in Bardo
  21. Daryl McCormack in Good Luck To You, Leo Grande
  22. Eden Dambrine in Close
  23. Gang Dong-won in Broker
  24. Jeremy Pope in The Inspection
  25. Daniel Kaluuya in Nope
  26. Austin Butler in Elvis
  27. Gabriel Labelle in The Fabelmans
  28. Ricardo Darin in Argentina, 1985
  29. Brendan Fraser in The Whale
  30. Diego Calva in Babylon 
  31. Ben Foster in The Survivor
  32. John Boyega in Breaking - 4.5
  33. Daniel Craig in The Glass Onion
  34. Michael Ward in Empire of Light
  35. Adam Driver in White Noise
  36. Antonio Banderas in Puss in Boots: The Last Wish
  37. Jack Lowden in Benediction
  38. Jerrod Carmichael in On the Count of Three
  39. Colin Farrell in After Yang 
  40. Brad Pitt in Babylon
  41. Idris Elba in Three Thousand Years of Longing
  42. Nicolas Cage in The Unbearable Weight of Massive Talent
  43. Adam Sandler in Hustle
  44. Harris Dickinson in Triangle of Sadness
  45. Rory Kinnear in Men
  46. Donald Elise Watkins in Emergency
  47. Peter Lanzani in Argentina, 1985
  48. Ali Junejo in Joyland
  49. Tom Cruise in Top Gun: Maverick
  50. Will Smith in Emancipation
  51. Viggo Mortensen in Crimes of the Future
  52. RJ Cyler in Emergency 
  53. Peter Capaldi in Benediction
  54. Sterling K. Brown in Hong For Jesus. Save Your Soul
  55. Kenneth Branagh in Death on the Nile - 4
  56. Colin Farrell in Thirteen Lives
  57. Viggo Mortensen in Thirteen Lives
  58. Jon Hamm in Confess Fletch
  59. Dali Benssalah in Athena
  60. Yahya Abdul-Mateen II in Ambulance
  61. Glen Powell in Devotion
  62. Benedict Cumberbatch in Dr. Strange in the Multiverse of Madness
  63. Christian Bale in The Pale Blue Eye
  64. Gregory Mann in Pinocchio
  65. Jake Gyllenhaal in Ambulance 
  66. Sami Slimane in Athena
  67. Elliott Crosset Hove in Godland
  68. Zach Efron in The Greatest Beer Run Ever
  69. Christoph Waltz in Dead for a Dollar
  70. Ryan Gosling in The Gray Man 
  71. Joe Alwyn in Stars At Noon - 3.5
  72. Daniel Radcliffe in Weird
  73. Chris Hemsworth in Thor: Love and Thunder
  74. Karl Urban in The Sea Beast 
  75. Luke Evans in Scrooge: A Christmas Carol
  76. Chris Evans in Lightyear 
  77. Jake Gyllenhaal in Strange World - 3
  78. Banks Repeta in Armageddon Time
  79. Sam Rockwell in See How They Run
  80. Brad Pitt in Bullet Train 
  81. Hugh Jackman in The Son - 2.5
  82. Eddie Redmayne in Fantastic Beats: The Secrets of Dumbledore 
  83. Sam Worthington in Avatar: The Way of Water
  84. Daniel Zolghadri in Funny Pages
  85. Will Ferrell in Spirited - 2
  86. John David Washington in Amsterdam
  87. Christian Bale in Amsterdam
  88. Ryan Reynolds in Spirited
  89. Chris Pratt in Jurassic World: Dominion
  90. Mason Thames in The Black Phone 
  91. Dwayne Johnson in Black Adam
  92. Peter Billingsley in A Christmas Story Christmas - 1.5
  93. Cooper Raiff in Cha Cha Real Smooth - 1
Next (eventually): 1961 Lead

Sunday, 19 February 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2022: Song Kang-ho in Broker

Song Kang-ho did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite winning CANNES, for portraying Ha Sang-hyeon in Broker. 

Broker is a good film about the "brokers" of an abandoned child, who go with that child's mother to find a buyer while being tracked by police. On re-watch, though I would say it isn't Kore-eda's best, getting bogged down a bit by the amount of plotting he includes particularly a strangely haphazard one involving a gangster wanting the child. 

Having said that there is still plenty to appreciate about this film within Kore-eda's typical appeal about calm observation via slightly atypical circumstances. This time working with a South Korean cast, led by two well-known South Korean vets Bae Doona as the seemingly cold cop tracking the brokers, and Song Kang-ho as the lead broker. The very idea of the brokers at the core of the story seems a particularly corrupt idea, as Song's Ha along with Gang Dong-won's Dong-soo, who is also an orphan himself, collect babies abandoned at a local church and sell them on a black market. You don't instantly reject them, despite their actual job seeming a bit diabolical on the surface because of the performances of both men, though particularly Song who is his typically charming self. Song brings that innately joyful presence of his that does quickly disarm you from being too suspicious of the men, and you instantly suspect that they must have some better motivation despite how potentially horrid their chosen crime may be. Song just exudes a good man so you believe they must have a good reason and in every aspect of his performance in a way he is putting any viewer at ease because in every instance, even when destroying evidence of their crime, Song presents an affable manner seemingly of a man who isn't nefarious despite the nefarious deed he seems to be committing. 

Matters get slightly more complicated quickly when the mother of the child comes back, Moon (Lee Ji-eun), joins the two men in their slightly rough van to try to sell the child. Early on we do get an explanation for this practice where Ha explains that they would rather the child not just be left an orphan and that they do search for a genuinely loving home. Song's performance is essential in this scene because you absolutely need to believe Ha at this moment. And with Song you absolutely do, who just delivers every word with just sincerity and a kind optimism that is emphasized in every word. His expression isn't of a man hiding something more, as strange as the practice is, and as much as they are making money from the practice, Song shows that Ha is performing a real duty to help the child out in his mind. And everything Song does in the performance shows the good nature of the character. His presence might as well be described as sunshine here with the great big smile that is most often adorning his face in every given moment. Song showing consistently a man who just wants to help the situation even while doing it in a way that most would deem questionable and is in fact illegal when it comes to practical description. 

For much of the film, which is most often on this ragtag group, who are eventually joined by another young orphan just to add to this, and where Song is a great deal of just emphasizing the optimistic manner of his character. Song doesn't present him as foolish within this idea either, rather his manner with this is always as someone keenly empathetic towards those around him and keenly aware of the problems they may be facing. That is where Song does excel in creating a sense of true empathy in really the moments quite simply where Ha isn't smiling and in these moments Song does bring a real emotional depth in the sense of the character's willingness to try to understand others. I love particularly his pivotal scene with Moon where they talk about her choice to abandon her child, and while Ha asks the occasional pressing question which Song delivers with the most genuine sense of concern, his eyes at the same time show this respectful restraint within the character. It is wonderful to work in portraying this sense of the man's real honest goodness even within his profession as the reinforcing trait in Song's performance consistently throughout the film is his care and concern for others. It is simply a given and that is what it should be. 

Now Ha, despite ostensibly being one of the leads of the film probably has the least given to him in terms of backstory for the four main leads of the film. The one scene that differs from this is when we see Song visit his own daughter, where he clearly some deadbeat dad to some extent as he is promising money for his estranged wife and trying to connect with his daughter. Although I think the scene itself is implemented a little imperfectly just it feels placed in the narrative in an overly disconnected way,  Song is great in the scene. As this is a scene where Song doesn't show cheerfulness as the basic emotion in the man. Rather he is filled with a certain insecurity and where in every other moment you see his lack of hesitation to emotionally reach out there's a real power to the restraint in the power of his work at the moment by showing Ha nearly lost for words and holding back his emotions. In turn, what Song shows is Ha dealing with his real pain at the moment where in particular when his daughter quotes a dismissive remark about him, Song is heartbreaking at the moment when he thinks that is coming from his own daughter as you see in his subtle reaction just how much pain is in this. 

Speaking of disconnected scenes though, there are none more disconnected than the gangster also seeking the child, which frankly should've just been removed from the film since they feel so rushed. Sadly Song is the one involved in these scenes. This is particularly in the final scenes with the gangster where two extremely rushed and very brief scenes need to show the typically happy-go-lucky man not only not happy but going straight to murdering the gangster. An idea that I think could've worked if it was built in a more substantial way, but the whole process feels rushed and haphazard. Song is good to his credit, though the odds are stacked against him because he legitimately doesn't have enough time to really convey that determination to take such a rash act. It isn't entirely convincing, not due to Song, I think he does what he can but the writing sabotages the attempt. The same is true for his extremely brief final scene, where Song's silent expression does reveal the weight of the crime, but it is so brief, it limits the power of seeing Ha fall to this point. Again Song does what he can but I do think Kore-eda does a disservice to his performance in both scenes. And I hate in part having to leave this review as such because I don't want to be misunderstood this is a wonderful performance still. He's so great in every little naturalistic moment we get with him and the group. I have to say although the limits of the film, keep this from being one of Song's best performances, and in the scheme of the film, I will say the two female leads left the greatest impression, which was true on my initial watch but only became more abundantly clear on re-watch. 

Friday, 10 February 2023

Alternate Best Actor 2022

And the Nominees Were Not:

Felix Kammerer in All Quiet on the Western Front

Ralph Fiennes in The Menu

Park Hae-il in Decision To Leave

Alexander Skarsgård in The Northman

Timothée Chalamet in Bones and All

Predict those five, these five or Both. 

Mehdi Bajestani in Holy Spider

Mark Rylance in The Outfit

Song Kang-ho in Broker

Christopher Abbott in On the Count of Three

Robert Pattinson in The Batman

Tuesday, 9 November 2021

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000: Results

10. Jeremy Irons in Dungeons & Dragons - The best part of his atrocious film, however doesn't achieve the true brilliance of a performance of its ilk.

Best Scene: Blood in the sky.
9. Lucas Black in All The Pretty Horses - Brings a moving authenticity that is bluntly missing from the rest of his film.

Best Scene: Being taken off.
8. Stephen Tobolowsky in Memento - Tobolowsky in his brief screentime finds the humanity in his odd state.

Best Scene: Insulin.
7. Sean Connery in Finding Forrester - Connery one last time brings out his actor in delivering a properly charismatic yet also troubled turn as a recluse.

Best Scene: Explaining why he is recluse.
6. Kyle MacLachlan in Hamlet - MacLaclan gives a powerful portrayal that manages to modernize the role of Claudius while also mine the greatness of the character in his traditional form.

Best Scene: Limo phone call.
5. Song Kang-ho in Joint Security Area - Song gives a brilliant portrayal of man who puts on a facade of the cold soldier, and reveals the empathetic human within.

Best Scene: The Event.
4. Joaquin Phoenix in The Yards - Phoenix proves his measure early on here in his remarkable and intense portrayal of a wannabe gangster coming to terms with himself. 

Best Scene: Final scene.
3.  Emilio Echevarria - Amores Perros - Echevarria gives a terrific portrayal of man struggling with empathy so naturally seguing from a broken animal lover and a callous hitman.

Best Scene: Finding the dogs.
2. Paddy Considine in A Room For Romeo Brass - Considine delivers an absolutely stunning debut turn that manages to be equally every bit of the mess of a man both terrifying yet also heartbreaking.

Best Scene: The threat.
1. Malcolm McDowell in Gangster No.1 - Good predictions Razor, Ytrewq, Shaggy (X2), and Brazinterma. McDowell delivers a proper ferocious portrayal of a vicious gangster, yet is also oddly heartbreaking in his portrayal of a man realizing the meaningless of his life.

Best Scene: "Number one"

Next: 1955 Lead

Wednesday, 13 October 2021

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000: Song Kang-ho in Joint Security Area

Song Kang-ho did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Sgt. Oh Kyung-pil in Joint Security Area. 

2000 seemed just a year where Korean cinema was beginning to reveal so many of its great talents burgeoning with so many of their, now, most essential directors making their start, or continuing their start, and so many of the actors starting to make their name. One such actor was Song Kang-ho who, despite earlier wrongheaded comments on my part, deserves to be mentioned right along with Byung-hun Lee and Choi Min-sik, as the three best Korean actors currently working, and really three of the best working actors of their generation regardless of country. Song in 2000 actually had a particularly great opportunity to explore his range this with his two performances, one in the comedy, with a bit of drama, in Foul King, directed almost paradoxically by Kim Jee-woon, where he got to be a failed banker who becomes a wacky wrestler. The same year though he worked with another of the Korean trio in Park Chan-wook, with the excellent Joint Security Area, about the unlikely friendship between border soldiers from South and North Korea. Where Byung-hun Lee played the senior soldier on the south side, Song plays the senior officer on the North side. And in turn we get a dynamic between the two great actors that helps greatly towards the immense success of this film. 

Now with Song we get a completely different seeming actor from his other work in 2000 frankly as we see his earliest, chronological scene, where we get this calm, frankly powerful, presence of the soldier of a dictatorship. There's just this sort of innate no nonsense strength within Song's work that is remarkable in itself compared to his "silly" work in Foul King, Song here exudes a man who has this innate power of self and is wholly convincing as this career soldier. Although what is fascinating though is in his first chronological scene we get that presence, however we also get a brilliant subversion of it within his performance. This as he stands as the presence of the North at the border, however a visitor losing their hat, the Sergeant hands it back over, and just the slightly facial movement of a near smile suggests powerfully yet so subtly the man within the soldier. This is each of these earliest flashback scenes where Song brings the sort of command of such a soldier, yet what is so essential is the way he does these minor little indications to the real nature of the man. Even a moment of a threat to Sergeant Lee, as they both are at their post, Song delivers the threat with a quietly comical sentiment that makes the threat a true joke, and shows the man enjoying the potential connection with his sworn enemy. 

Song is expectedly wonderful then in crafting the chemistry with Lee, and the two actors with the privates who also join the other two in their border friendship. This as Song just crafts the chemistry with just showing the indication of the nice man beneath it all, openly with these moments of sincere and sweet conversations of the men bonding together. Song is great by playing these scenes really without reservations in terms of the humanity of the character. Even his physical manner delivers this way of the man being embracing and supportive. Song reinforces in every way of his performance just the loving man beneath the soldier ready and willing to get out. The man indicated by the earlier brief moments completely exposed for the joy of life seeking man beneath it all. Song does great work by showing really the confidence within this manner, and showing that as a soldier it isn't even exactly a repression, just a requirement as there is no hesitation in the man when given the chance. One small moment I love is Song playing with this speaking with a sharp determination to speak of his hopes for North Korea to develop proper sweets, though again Song showing really the Sergeant himself actively subverting the expectation of the type of soldier he is. 

Despite the camaraderie we follow as their nations' differences enforce themselves upon the group's conversation, and I love the way that in a way Song shows his Sergeant as the wisest of the group, and clearly the man who has seen the most. This as in each of his deliveries there is a blunt sense of experience and understanding the Sergeant. Song showing a man who knows really the truth of the situation at every point. This including the climatic moment, which the film slowly unwraps, where a North Korean soldier, who is not part of the group, comes in leading to a bloodbath. Song is fantastic throughout the scene as again showing the man who is consistently calm within the conflict, but also trying to be persuasive towards the others for calmness. There is such a palatable sense of empathy in every word that Song brings in his words, but also just in his manner throughout. He never loses that sense of decency even as guns are fired, and his expression of shock at the actions of the others are truly powerful in showing the one man whose decency cannot be shook by anything that occurs. This making just his moment of looking at the shooter of the scene with horror, Song is heartbreaking in granting the real sense of loss by showing the man who despite the circumstance never forgets that they are friends. This as even as the Sergeant takes action to help the men, who have killed his comrades and almost him, Song performs every moment with this intensity but also certainty of a man trying desperately to help his friends despite all that has transpired. This nature is even reinforced in the scenes that take place beyond the incident, such as early one where investigators meet him when he is unwilling to cooperate. Song shows the man putting on the tough soldier in displaying his battle scars, and just trying to ignore the situation. When they bring the two sergeants together again, Song is excellent in showing the subtle sense of recognition of the past so subtly, and then properly is all bluster when frankly putting on the facade of the angry North Korean soldier filled with hate. This is in stark contrast to his final major scene, which is a quiet yet powerful moment. This as Song speaks with a sense of regret for what happened, yet it is still filled with this incredible empathy. An empathy that Song wholly earns by always showing throughout that this is but the innate nature of the man. That as imperfect as the situation is, Song shows the good man who was only seeking friendship throughout. Although less overtly as expressive as Lee's powerful work, Song's contribution is essential in showing a man perhaps more equipped for what their unique situation, but only due to the unshakable nature of his humanity.

Thursday, 7 October 2021

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2000

And Nominees Were Not:

Emilio Echevarria in Amores Perros
 
Kyle MacLachlan in Hamlet
 
Malcolm McDowell in Gangster No. 1 (and to continue to contemplate his placement)

Stephen Tobolowsky in Memento

Sean Connery in Finding Forrester

Predict those Five, These Five or Both.
 
Joaquin Phoenix in The Yards

Lucas Black in All The Pretty Horses

Jeremy Irons in Dungeons and Dragon

Paddy Considine in A Room For Romeo Brass

Song Kang-ho in Joint Security Area

Sunday, 26 January 2020

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2019: Results

5. Robert Forster in El Camino - Forster makes the absolute most out of every minute of his screentime to give a very funny, yet also quietly moving portrayal of a most unusual sort of professional.

Best Scene: "We're Open"
4. Robert Downey Jr. in Avengers: Endgame - Downey gives a worthy sendoff to his now most iconic role, offering the same charm, humor and charisma  as Tony Stark that made him a star once again, though also continuing to take his character on an honest emotional journey. 

Best Scene: Meeting Howard.
3. Sterling K. Brown in Waves - Brown gives an effective portrayal of an overbearing father that quietly and powerfully reveals the real vulnerability and love within the man.

Best Scene: Talking about it.
2. Sam Rockwell in Jojo Rabbit - Rockwell gives a hilarious portrayal of an exasperated soldier just running down the minutes of his existence that eventually becomes rather moving as well.

Best Scene: "Rosie was a good person"
1. Song Kang-ho in Parasite - Song gives a brilliant portrait of the slow descent of a man from a strange contentment towards rage and despair.

Best Scene: Birthday gone wrong.
Overall Rank:
  1. Joe Pesci in The Irishman
  2. Al Pacino in The Irishman
  3. Song Kang-ho in Parasite 
  4. Choi Woo-Shik in Parasite
  5. Tom Hanks in A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood - 5
  6. Sam Rockwell in Jojo Rabbit - 4.5
  7. Lee Sun-kyun in Parasite
  8. Baykali Ganambarr in The Nightingale
  9. Sterling K. Brown in Waves
  10. Timothee Chalamet in Little Women
  11. Udo Kier in Bacurau
  12. Robert Downey Jr. in Avengers: Endgame
  13. Robert Forster in El Camino
  14. Bill Hader in It: Chapter 2
  15. John Lithgow in Bombshell
  16. Eric Bogosian in Uncut Gems- 4
  17. Chris Cooper in Little Women  
  18. Stephen Graham in The Irishman
  19. Keith Williams Richards in Uncut Gems
  20. Jesse Plemons in El Camino 
  21. Alan Alda in Marriage Story
  22. Liu Kuan-ting in A Sun
  23. Park Myung-hoon in Parasite
  24. Jeremy Renner in Avengers: Endgame
  25. Chris Evans in Knives Out
  26. Mike Moh in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  27. Chris Hemsworth in Avengers: Endgame 
  28. Don Johnson in Knives Out
  29. Taika Waititi in Jojo Rabbit 
  30. Chris Evans in Avengers: Endgame 
  31. Willem Dafoe in Motherless Brooklyn
  32. James Ransome in It: Chapter 2 
  33. Wesley Snipes in Dolemite is My Name
  34. Ben Mendolsohn in Captain Marvel
  35. Alessandro Nivola in The Art of Self-Defense
  36. Paul Rudd in Avengers: Endgame
  37. Stephen Merchant in Jojo Rabbit 
  38. Winston Duke in Us
  39. Nicholas Hammond in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  40. Christopher Plummer in Knives Out
  41. Richard Madden in 1917 - 3.5
  42. Andrew Scott in 1917
  43. Benedict Cumberbatch in 1917
  44. Mark Strong in 1917
  45. Tzi Ma in The Farewell 
  46. Robert Pattinson in The King
  47. Archie Yates in Jojo Rabbit
  48. Robert De Niro in Joker
  49. Charles Baker in El Camino
  50. Vince Vaughn in Fighting With My Family
  51. Bradley Cooper in Avengers: Endgame
  52. Ben Mendelsohn in The King
  53. Keanu Reeves in Always Be My Maybe
  54. Ray Liotta in Marriage Story
  55. Zahn McClarnon in Doctor Sleep
  56. Lucas Hedges in Honey Boy
  57. Asier Etxeandia in Pain and Glory
  58. Sean Harris in The King
  59. Thomas Haden Church in The Peanut Butter Falcon
  60. Greg Hsu in A Sun 
  61. Roberto Benigni in Pinocchio
  62. Jeff Goldblum in The Mountain
  63. Joel Edgerton in The King
  64. Nick Frost in Fighting With My Family
  65. Jack Dylan Grazer in Shazam 
  66. Michael Shannon in Knives Out
  67. Samuel L. Jackson in Captain Marvel
  68. Lucas Hedges in Waves
  69. Jiang Yongbo in The Farewell
  70. Bokeem Woodbine in Queen & Slim
  71. Al Pacino in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  72. Leonardo Sbaraglia in Pain and Glory
  73. Eric Stoltz in Her Smell
  74. Jay Ryan in It: Chapter 2
  75. Evan Alex in Us
  76. Vince Vaughn in Dragged Across Concrete
  77. Vilhelm Blomgren in Midsommar
  78. James McAvoy in It: Chapter 2
  79. Josh Brolin in Avengers: Endgame 
  80. Kevin Garnett in Uncut Gems
  81. Jamie Bell in Rocketman
  82. Bruce Dern in The Mustang
  83. Tracy Letts in Ford V. Ferrari
  84. Rob Morgan in Just Mercy
  85. George MacKay in Ophelia
  86. Lakeith Stanfield in Uncut Gems 
  87. Tom Waits in The Dead Don't Die 
  88. Dan Stevens in Her Smell
  89. O'Shea Jackson Jr. in Long Shot
  90. Ralph Fiennes in Official Secrets
  91. Jacob Tremblay in Doctor Sleep - 3
  92. Judd Hirsch in Uncut Gems
  93. Keith Stanfield in Knives Out
  94. Alfie Allen in Jojo Rabbit 
  95. John Slattery in Avengers: Endgame
  96. Harvey Keitel in The Irishman
  97. Jake Gyllenhaal in Spider-man: Far From Home 
  98. Lance Reddick in John Wick 3
  99. Don Cheadle in Avengers: Endgame 
  100. Kristian Bruun in Ready Or Not
  101. Bruce Dern in Once Upon A Time in Hollywood
  102. Bryan Cranston in El Camino 
  103. Brian Tyree Henry in Joker
  104. Ian McShane in John Wick 3
  105. Colin Firth in 1917
  106. Adam Brody in Ready or Not
  107. Tom Bower in Light of My Life
  108. Tim Blake Nelson in The Report
  109. Ben Whishaw in Little Joe
  110. Mark Ruffalo in Avengers: Endgame
  111. John Malkovich in Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile
  112. Jason Mitchell in The Mustang
  113. Bruce Dern in The Peanut Butter Falcon
  114. Caleb Landry Jones in The Dead Don't Die
  115. Danny Glover in The Dead Don't Die
  116. Bobby Cannavale in The Irishman 
  117. Sebastian Stan in Avengers: Endgame
  118. Keegan-Michael Key in Dolemite is My Name
  119. Richard Madden in Rocketman
  120. Moisés Arias in Monos
  121. Kurt Russell in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  122. Ray McKinnon in Ford V. Ferrari
  123. Henry Czerny in Ready or Not
  124. Jon Favreau in Spider-man: Far From Home
  125. Jonathan Banks in El Camino
  126. Will Smith in Aladdin
  127. Tom Holland in Avengers: Endgame
  128. Chen Han in The Farewell
  129. Rob Delaney in Bombshell 
  130. Keanu Reeves in Toy Story 4
  131. Timothy Olyphant in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  132. Kodi Smit-McPhee in Dolemite is My Name 
  133. Craig Robinson in Dolemite is My Name
  134. Mike Epps in Dolemite is My Name
  135. Mark O'Brien in Ready or Not
  136. Jeremy Strong in Serenity
  137. Adam Driver in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  138. Clifton Collins Jr. in Waves
  139. Anthony Mackie in Avengers: Endgame
  140. Scott MacArthur in El Camino
  141. Corey Stoll in The Report
  142. Tommy Lee Jones in Ad Astra
  143. Damian Lewis in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  144. Teach Grant in It: Chapter 2
  145. Dwayne Johnson in Fighting With My Family
  146. Chiwetel Ejiofor in The Lion King
  147. Danny Glover in The Last Black Man in San Francisco
  148. Donald Sutherland in Ad Astra
  149. Tracy Letts in Little Women 
  150. Stephen Merchant in Fighting With My Family
  151. Tom Courtenay in The Aeronauts
  152. Jake Gyllenhaal in Velvet Buzzsaw
  153. Luke Perry in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  154. Ted Levine in The Report
  155. Anthony Daniels in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  156. Isiah Mustafa in It: Chapter 2
  157. Scott Shepherd in El Camino 
  158. Frank Oz in Knives Out
  159. Richard E. Grant in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  160. John Hawkes in The Peanut Butter Falcon
  161. Cliff Curtis in Doctor Sleep
  162. Idris Elba in Hobbs and Shaw
  163. Andy Bean in It: Chapter 2
  164. Larry Hankin in El Camino
  165. Bill Duke in High Flying Bird
  166. Pedro Pascal in Triple Frontier
  167. Tim Allen in Toy Story 4
  168. Omar Dorsey in Harriet
  169. Martin Starr in Spider-man: Far From Home
  170. Jon Bernthal in Ford V. Ferrari
  171. Billy Magnussen in Velvet Buzzsaw
  172. Ian McDiarmid in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  173. John Lithgow in Late Night
  174. Tom Roth in Luce
  175. Thomas Kretschmann in Dragged Across Concrete
  176. William Jackson Harper in Midsommar
  177. Steve Buscemi in The Dead Don't Die
  178. Henry Hunter Hall in Harriet
  179. Bruno Ganz in A Hidden Life
  180. Josh Lucas in Ford V. Ferrari
  181. Austin Butler in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  182. Matt Jones in El Camino
  183. Denis Lavant in The Mountain
  184. Keegan-Michael Key in Toy Story 4
  185. Jordan Peele in Toy Story 4
  186. Mathias Schoenaerts in A Hidden Life
  187. Stephen Graham in Rocketman
  188. Jamie Foxx in Just Mercy
  189. Tim Robbins in Dark Waters
  190. Clarke Peters in Harriet
  191. Michael Jai White in Dragged Across the Concrete
  192. Bill Nighy in Detective Pikachu
  193. Ibrahima Traore in Atlantics
  194. Emile Hirsch in Once Upon a Time in Hollywood
  195. Babou Ceesay in The Best of Enemies
  196. Chris Cooper in A Beautiful Day in the Neighborhood 
  197. Carlo Cecchi in Martin Eden
  198. Leslie Odom Jr. in Harriet
  199. Mark Strong in Shazam
  200. Charlie Hunnam in Triple Frontier
  201. Jonny Mars in Bacurau
  202. David Zelner in The Art of Self-Defense
  203. Bruce Willis in Motherless Brooklyn
  204. Haley Joel Osment in Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile
  205. Jason Suedeikis in Booksmart
  206. Matt Smith in Official Secrets
  207. Kyle MacLachlan in High Flying Bird
  208. Jon Hamm in Lucy in the Sky 
  209. Gary Oldman in The Laundromat
  210. Antonio Banderas in The Laundromat
  211. Patrick Stewart in The Kid Who Would Be King
  212. Andy Serkis in Long Shot
  213. Bob Odenkirk in Little Women - 2.5
  214. Bill Skarsgard in It: Chapter 2 
  215. Ólafur Darri Ólafsson in The Vanishing
  216. Clive Owen in Ophelia
  217. Jim Parsons in Extremely Wicked, Shockingly Evil and Vile
  218. Charles Dance in Godzilla: King of the Monsters
  219. Daveed Diggs in Velvet Buzzsaw
  220. Hamish Patel in The Aeronauts
  221. Julio Diaz in La Llorona
  222. Jaeden Martell in Knives Out
  223. Bobby Cannavale in Motherless Brooklyn
  224. Rufus Sewell in Judy
  225. Jonathan Groff in Frozen II
  226. F. Murray Abraham in How to Train Your Dragon 3
  227. Billy Dee Williams in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  228. John Boyega in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  229. Jude Law in Captain Marvel
  230. Oscar Isaac in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  231. Samuel L. Jackson in Spider-man: Far From Home
  232. Billy Eichner in The Lion King
  233. Seth Rogen in The Lion King
  234. Rhys Stone in Sorry We Missed You
  235. Bruce McGill in The Best of Enemies
  236. Ken Watanabe in Detective Pikachu
  237. Bob Odenkirk in Long Shot
  238. Laurie Davidson in Cats
  239. Navid Negahban in Aladdin 
  240. Jason Clarke in Serenity
  241. James Earl Jones in The Lion King
  242. Keegan-Michael Key in The Lion King
  243. Tony Hale in Toy Story 4
  244. Hugh Dancy in Late Night
  245. Ross Brewster in Sorry We Missed You
  246. Finn Wittrock in Judy
  247. Jon Hamm in Richard Jewell 
  248. Sterling K. Brown in Frozen II
  249. Steven MacKintosh in Rocketman
  250. Henry Thomas in Doctor Sleep
  251. Garrett Hedlund in Triple Frontier
  252. Idris Elba in Cats
  253. Bradley Whitford in Godzilla: King of the Monsters
  254. Josh Gad in Frozen II
  255. Alec Baldwin in Motherless Brooklyn - 2
  256. Billy Magnussen in Aladdin 
  257. Noah Segan in Knives Out
  258. Jacob Batalon in Spider-man: Far From Home
  259. John Oliver in The Lion King
  260. Tony Revolori in Spider-man: Far From Home
  261. Thomas Middleditch in Godzilla: King of the Monsters
  262. Jason Derulo in Cats
  263. Joe Alwyn in Harriet
  264. Domhnall Gleeson in Star Wars: The Rise of Skywalker
  265. Ike Barinholtz in Late Night
  266. Will Poulter in Midsommar
  267. Robbie Fairchild in Cats
  268. Ryan Reynolds in Hobbs and Shaw
  269. Mark Dacascos in John Wick 3
  270. Dan Stevens in Lucy in the Sky  
  271. Rhys Ifans in Official Secrets
  272. Skyler Gisondo in Booksmart
  273. Noah Galvin in Booksmart
  274. Marwen Kenzari in Aladdin - 1.5
  275. Ian McKellen in Cats
  276. Bill Camp in Dark Waters
  277. Chris Geere in Detective Pikachu
  278. Jack Reynor in Midsommar
  279. Rafe Spall in Just Mercy
  280. James Corden in Cats - 1
Next Year: 2019 Lead

Saturday, 25 January 2020

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2019: Song Kang-ho & Choi Woo-shik in Parasite

Song Kang-ho and Choi Woo-shik did not receive Oscar nominations for portraying Kim Ki-taek and Kim Ki-woo respectively in Parasite.

Parasite is the perfect cinematic sendoff for the decade by director Bong Joon-ho, a film that I loved upon first viewing and has only grown in my estimation on each subsequent viewing, following a poor family who attempts to infiltrate a rich family by taking all their service jobs. This is a film, where if you have not seen it, I would just say read no further, and just see it already. Though as much as I've loved it every time I've watched, one should never forgo the great experience of discovering this film for the first time.

Regardless of what aspect of the film one examines, Parasite is great, a trademark of a masterpiece I'd say, one of the aspects that carries this greatness is the cast. Everyone fills their parts out so well, making it perhaps the most deserving SAG ensemble winner, ever. Two of the essential performances come in the men I've chosen to focus on here, though as Song Kang-ho plays the father and Choi-Woo-shik plays the son of the poor family. The poor family we first meet as they seem like they can only go up, living in the basement of a building where they struggle to find wi-fi support, and are "treated" to bug spray and a serial unrinator as regular sights. The family, which also includes the mother Chung-sook (Chang Hyae-jin) and the daughter Kim Ki-jeong (Park So-dam), eking out a more than meager living as pizza box makers. So in this sense we get the family in sort of their purest form, which is essential in creating really the state of each character established so well in the performances. With Choi Woo-shik, similar to his not particularly loyal corporate truck driver in Bong's previous film Okja, brings a sort of foolish energy of sorts. This in there is an inherent haplessness in his manner. Choi portraying a lack of certainty with really every interaction in the basement, suggesting the young man unable to build up even the slightest hint of success in his life, having failed university exams multiple times. Bong's frequent collaborator Song Kang-ho, of course is right at home in the director's style, but also makes this important portrayal of the dad's state in the home. This as he brings a sort of goofy enthusiasm of just a typical dad, who actually may be a little too content in his surrounding scenery, this as even though we don't know how the family got here, Song gives a good idea how. This as when the basement is sprayed for bugs, while the other shudder, Song takes in almost a cleansing embrace of what his life is.

Their chance in a turn around comes as the son is offered a chance at a tutoring gig with a wealthy family by his friend, largely because his friend thinks he'll be less romantic competition for the daughter in the rich family. Choi's great in this scene of hearing of the prospects by in a way being everything his friend is not, portraying a certain fear almost at the prospect, and this consistent physical approach that accentuates the son's apparent lack of potential on the surface. He finds himself invited though into the home of the rich family and the particularly gullible rich mother (Cho Yeo-jeong). Choi's performance creates the sort of operation that defines the first act of the film. This as he sees just how quickly she accepts his ideas, we see an immediate change in his manner, and Choi loses his more unassuming demeanor to create a more striking manner, closer to his visiting friend who recommended him for the job. It isn't though as the man is showing a great confidence as himself, but rather it is essential in the way Choi portrays this as a placed in facade over the apparent sort of fearful young man otherwise. This is most evident within his first tutoring session, where Choi portrays this sort of breakout that is as a performance as some great thinker, where he is just really putting on an act. This act that gets his sister a job as an art tutor for the rich family's son, and eventually his father to replace the rich father's driver. Song is terrific as he continues showing the way the poor father is by far the most at home in the basement, with his proud goofy demeanor. This as we see him take on the job for the father, he is by far the "worst" actor of the bunch. Song's brilliant though in his comic way of bringing to life Song's methods as a proper seasoned driver, who really isn't that great. This with an over eagerness he brings to every word, and a far too casual ease with the rich father, that frequently pushes boundaries. We see more of this as the three attempt to get their mother a job replacing the rich family's housekeeper. Song's terrific in the scenes of preparing for the "performance" in his over the top delivery as he practices it, showing very much the effort the poor father must put into every ounce of the scheme, compared to his children who are a little more prepared. I do though also love the brief moments of pride that Song expresses with such an affectionate grin as he speaks of his children's success with the scheme as though they had all gotten successful jobs without subterfuge, and grants the sense of it being almost a dream beyond any expectation.

The family pushes their success though by using the family's home when they're out for a trip. This is an essential scene though for both Choi and Song. Choi in reverting to more meekness though with this quiet hope as he speaks of his belief that he'll be able to marry the daughter and get the riches for himself. Choi speaking with this earnest delivery, and this way of looking towards some future in the moment, that is an essential seed. Speaking of essential seeds though, when the poor mother, speaks of the father's likely cowardice in the face of the rich family potentially discovering them, he lashes out. Song portraying the moment with a real intensity of a deeper anger, though that he quickly laughs off as though it was all a joke. This release though being an important seed as Song uses that moment to suggest a bit more within the father's certain state of being poor. What happens next though is a sequence of insanity as the family discovers the first housekeeper was storing her deeply in-debt husband into a dark basement, just before the rich family unexpectedly returns home from a flood, which gives the rich house a rather serene appearance. The ensuing chaos is really tour de force for every actor within the cast in terms of portraying the different moments of the scene, and adding so much to the craziness and comedy of each moment. They highlight each instance brilliantly and makes the whole sequence all the more compelling. I have particular affection though for Song's reaction as he witnesses his wife purposefully push the old housekeeper, though accidentally cause great injury, as it instantly evokes the terror of the change in severity of the situation. Eventually the situation leads much of the poor family to hide for some time under the rich's family's table, whilethe rich couple watch their son camp out in the rain. This as the rich father (Lee Sun-kyun) comments on the poor father's smell. Song's silent reaction to just taking this in, and just a moment of quiet sadness and anger, is fantastic bit of acting essential to the story, as we'll see.

The family escapes though only to find that their basement home is flooded, leaving them to take refuge. Although Choi is very good in his reactions to these scenes, Song's work is remarkable in showing the loss of that sort of contentment and pride of the father. There taking hold more of an exasperation within him that in Song's expression creates the sense of a penetrating loss. This creates a terrific contrast though between Song and Choi, this as Choi speaks still with some optimism of a plan to handle all their problems with this youthful wish again, against Song who speaks each word so bluntly that plans are basically without purpose, as they always go wrong. All of this comes to a head as the poor family is called in by the rich family for their son's birthday party, oblivious to their lost home from the flooding. Choi has a marvelous bit of physical comedy actually as we see him exploring the hidden basement in some foolish attempt to resolve the situation with a rock of his, and his fumbling around expertly realizes his plan going the opposite of fruition. This is against Song who is first needed to slowly prepare the party by driving around the wife, before being made by the rich father to pretend to be a bad native for a birthday celebration. Song's face says it all as just this simmering silent bitterness and hate. This not a man wounded so by his experience, and his reactions that show a very real pain that seems as defined by the lack of empathy from those he is looking at as it is his own suffering. All of course does not go to plan in the party as the husband from the basement goes on the attack first, delivering a near fatal blow to the poor son's head, via his own rock, before stabbing the poor daughter. Everything Song does in this scene is downright amazing, but also realizing quite the challenge in what he needs to do. It's effortless though and powerful. This in his portrayal first of sheer horror at seeing his daughter stabbed, and disbelief at the violent chaos. This though as the rich father stepping once too far himself, by not only showing no concern whatsoever over the bleeding Ki-jeong, but also his revulsion at the basement dwelling husband's smell as he picks up the car keys tossed by the poor father. There's a break in Song's eyes as he moves almost in this detached state as he outright murders the rich father. This is such a brilliant moment as we see the spark of anger and intensity, seeded before, but portrayed as this almost instinctual release of pent up rage by Song in the killing. This that he makes as this temporary insanity as his stare the moment afterwards is this incredible realization of what he has done, one of both fear of the consequences but a despair of that he went through with such an act.

The film's epilogue is one of the greatest endings of a film that I've seen in sometime, and two of the reasons for this are the performances of Choi and Song. We see Choi as he recovers from his brain injuries, though with initially a broken laugh, that is so well realized in Choi's nearly vacant expression of a man whose mind just isn't quite fully together yet. This as he finds he and his mother just barely avoiding jail time and falling right back into their basement home once again. This compared to against where we see the father who managed to avoid arrest by retreating into the hidden basement. Song is outstanding once again as we see the immediate desperation after the act, and the moment of realization expanded to a true shame for the act. This now portraying that man without any contentment just now living within a fear of a life lower than the one he had seemingly come to accept in the opening of the story. The son learns of this through Morse code from a light operated by the father, leaving the son to plan an escape for his father. The escape scene that we first see depicted as the son appears rich, and now earnestly confident as himself. This with one particularly brilliant glimpse from Choi as he's just about to enter the house, of a quiet eagerness and almost disbelief at the prospect. Then we witness the father apparently come from his layer, with his son and wife ready to greet him, where Song wears such a haunting expression of years of a form of captivity as he moves to embrace his loved ones once again. This before we cut back to still just the son stuck in his basement thinking of that plan, with Choi's expression being this so poignant combination of that optimistic wistfulness but also an underlining hopelessness as well. Both actors great such emotional detail, largely in silence, and help to create the unforgettable ending it is as this cruel dream that is likely to never exist. Both actors deliver great performances in Choi's portrait of a youth attempting to find the plan that will save his family, and Song's tragic realization of a poor man somehow slowly descending down a path he cannot return from.