Alternate Best Actor 2004: Shah Rukh Khan in Swades

Shah Rukh Khan did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Mohan Bhargav in Swades.

Swades follows a NASA scientist who returns to India to see his surrogate mother who raised him after his parents’ deaths. 

My third time reviewing a Khan performance comes in the form of a I’d say more classical kind of setup for a star where you have the return home scenario for a character. Although the nature of the situation is a bit different as often the individual should be maybe more troubled outside of the home, which isn’t the case for Khan’s Mohan Bhargav in this film. Rather we see him as part of NASA and a key part of a specialized team making great advances as a scientist. He’s a successful man and Khan’s portrayal of Mohan emphasizes someone who is more or less fine with the circumstances. Khan rather presents a more subtle state of while not in any way being burdened by his existence in the United States, he is instead just quietly not particularly spirited in his manner or demeanor. It’s all “fine” in Khan’s presentation of his life, no more, no less. So when he decides to visit back home, really with just a mission to do right by his nanny/surrogate mother Kaveri (Kishori Ballal), Khan delivers the lines regarding this as essentially a passive duty. Khan suggests he does care but his emphasis makes it mostly just as a general responsibility of someone who considers himself a good man, but it is not a fundamental desire of someone wishing to reunite with his home and the people there. 

Mohan leaves for India initially searching for Kaveri at a retirement home in Delhi only to find that she left a more rural village. Something that he searches for to continue in his duty and where Khan’s performance emphasizes a more low key distance. Khan doesn’t present himself as above the village rather portrays Mohan as just more fixated on doing what he believes is his simple task to take care of Kaveri by bringing him back with her. There is a nuanced emotion Khan naturally brings to discover Indian again after being away for so many years but there’s a modest quality of someone who really isn’t trying to face them at the moment. Naturally things get more complicated when he learns that it is Kaveri’s mission to find a husband for Mohan’s childhood friend, Gita (Gayatri Joshi), naturally, a beautiful school teacher at this point who has no desire to become a subservient wife and is devoted to the idea of bringing an education to this rural area. Khan’s very good in striking the right kind of chemistry with Joshi, where initially it is the warmth of an old pair of friends, though there is a subtle glint in Khan’s eyes of someone who obviously sees a bit more in her than just a friend in this surprising reunion. Particularly when he hears about potential, not particularly impressive suitors, where Khan brings a natural comedy in his fairly dismissive reactions to the idea of her marrying some forgettable guy. 

In these interactions of course Gita is more than willing to herself denounce anyone who wants to place her in a box and we do get some properly attuned reactions from Khan where you see how impressed he is with her multiple ways. Khan has the right ease of being intrigued in moments, while also comedic asides where he gets a bit of her directness or just takes joy in it when he gives it to others. This however still doesn’t change Mohan’s overall approach as he soon calls NASA which Khan still presents as Mohan fixated on still going back, but just in this instance thinking he’ll be able to go back with her as his wife. Gita though is steadfast in wanting to bring education for all despite some in the village protesting the notions. Mohan doesn’t need to be changed to help rather we see the innate goodness of the man come out. Khan is very good in the way he plays the quiet building supportive passion of the man as he stands firm in his beliefs with Gita and goes about helping her. What he does so well is not present it as any kind of patronizing support to lust after her, rather playing it as a straight honest support. Importantly going further in playing the quiet growing joy in the man sharing his own expertise to help the village. Something that comes out in one of the film’s musical sequences, where Mohan entertains the village after a power loss by showing his knowledge of the sky. A sequence that is of course dubbed, but Khan’s portrayal of the sheer infectious energy as he physically motions every bit of it, completely still comes across throughout the sequence. It is a wonderful bit where you absolutely see the full star charisma of Khan and is a standout moment within the film thanks to every bit of work where you see really the fun of his knowledge as he convincingly pulls everyone into it even beyond the song that goes with it. 

The more dramatic edges of the story come as Khan travels further to collect a debt for Gita where he finds continued hardship due to the lack of fundamental resources. The key to these scenes are Khan’s reactions. He builds on each scene of learning about it with such a palatable sense of empathy towards those he is getting to know and learn about. Each scene Khan shows the growth of the concern from just a general interest to a real devotion. Bringing then a building passion that becomes more expressed in his overall performance as he becomes more than just an observer and begins to make plans to build essentially an hydroelectric dam. Khan’s portrayal of his devotion in this works best as the natural expression of the growing concern and love for the land. It is less of a man completely changing rather than a certain strength and passion of the man revealing itself more openly, even to himself. As something we keep coming back to is his check ins with NASA. At first Khan brings a casual interest to his delay, then we see the split burdens as he speaks trust that he will return but there is the conflict in his eyes, until then it becomes NASA is his burden and the village is truly what he cares about. Khan having the moment of acceptance brings the right exuberance to the man essentially finding his calling by bringing his knowledge home essentially. It is a performance that isn’t about this raw transformation, rather a leading man’s charisma, with just the right Capraish determination, though with maybe a bit less dramatic hardship to overcome. Regardless, I wholly enjoyed Khan’s work here, from his quiet romantic moments, to his more comedic reactions, and his energy within the musical moments.