Ljubiša Samardžić did not receive an Oscar nomination, despite winning the Volpi Cup, for portraying Mali in The Morning.
The Morning follows the period of time of victory immediately after WWII in Yugoslavia, which results in an odd combination of celebration and killings.
I’ll admit going with a festival winner might not always be a guaranteed choice for analysis as there have been the examples where the winner seemed like the juries pulled a name out of the hat and said “sure” rather than really accrediting a great performance. And I’ll say while Ljubiša Samardžić’s performance isn’t entirely that but I wouldn’t call it a great performance either. His actual appearances in this already fairly short film are limited as it takes a wavering perspective and he only becomes lead by virtue that the film keeps coming back to him as it frequently diverges to other people dealing with their new found “freedom”. We to Samardžić depiction of Mali as a man who basically is killing people still even after the war even having this strange urge to do so, where it appears the people may be guilty in some way, but still the jump cuts we get to depict the executions leaves some questions in mind about that guilt. Samardžić’s performance is interesting in the exuberance he brings to it, that is a kind of madness he creates in the man. He doesn’t play it as fully insane as though he’s a psychopath, despite his killings, but rather someone who has become detached from his existence to have this sort of dreamy enjoyment of the madness. This state of his is captivating when the film chooses to depict him as his physicality even maneuvering around almost like a ghost himself, but the way he seems so carefree about everything. He’s captivating as far as he can go in depicting this, as we see him talk to a few women about either the present or the past, but even that Samardžić depicts with the same sort of casual ease that seems eerily disjointed. It all works in his performance in crafting this very specific state of being that does successfully realize this man is sort of ripped from reality, but still playing with it in his own way. BUT, the film’s choices to constantly divert attention to someone else or to some extreme stylistic swing does limit how much Samardžić actually gets to explore, even as the technical lead of this film. He’s good with what he has but we don’t really get to play with it in more directions. We get a stylized scene of getting into fineries but even that is far more visual than something the performers really get to sink their teeth into. Regardless, Samardžić gives a good performance, but it was one where I felt we got a great starting point that sadly the film didn’t allow him to explore beyond a certain point.
59 comments:
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
5º Ljubiša Samardžić
4º Sergei Bondarchuk
3º Michel Simon
2º Scott Wilson
1º Toshiro Mifune
Did I miss something? Why's everyone suddenly putting Bondarchuk at #4 after putting him at #1 last time?
Harris: I put Bondarchuk at #1 initially due to how emotionally powerful the climax of War & Peace was in the novel and 2016 mini-series but since Calvin watched it a few days ago and put him bottom in his prediction, I had no choice but to lower him.
And I'd much rather put my personal feelings aside to win requests.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Louis: Depending on the strength of their performances, would it be possible to do a write-up on either Newman (Hombre), Heston (Will Penny) or Poitier (To Sir, With Love). Supporting is pretty weak for suggestions apart from Donald Pleasence in Will Penny.
Louis: What are your ratings and thoughts on Stephen Curry in Hounds of Love, Daniel Giménez Cacho in Zama, Timothy Spall, Cillian Murphy and Bruno Ganz in The Party, Lior Ashkenazi and Steve Buscemi in Norman, Joe Cole in Thank You for Your Service, and Martin McCann in Lost in London?
1. Mifune
2. Simon
3. Wilson
4. Bondarchuck
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Luke: Fair enough.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Bondarchuk
4. Simon
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Samardzic
4. Simon
5. Bondarchuk
Louis: If it's ok, I'd like to use one of my requests.
Antonio R. Fraustro in Vámonos Con Pancho Villa (1936) (Lead)
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Louis: Your thoughts on the use of music in Rushmore's ending? https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ELQOnEgzt-I
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Emi Grant: I noticed from your review of A Complete Unknown that you're a fan of Abigail Devoe's, as am I. What are your favourite videos of hers, outside of her Bob Dylan reviews?
Toshiro Mifune really is GOATED, isn't he?? Watched High And Low for the first time recently. What a masterpiece. And how awesome he is in it. The way he shows conflict there. So much passion.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Louis: I don’t have many recommendations at the moment, I need to catch up on a lot, but I suggest you check out some of these movies:
-July Rain (lovely character study)
-The Red and the White
-Titicut Follies (Wiseman’s first long feature)
-A Man Vanishes
-Mist (the title song appeared in Decision to Leave, great performance by Yoon Jeong-hee)
I'm also curious to read what you think about Marketa Lazarová and The Young Girls of Rochefort.
Tony: Hell yeah! Good to know you're a fan too!
Her vids on Bitches Brew, Is This It, Pink Moon, Souvlaki, Wish You Were Here, the second Layla vid, the (unfortunately taken down) What's Going On and Trout Mask Replica are among my favs from her.
Tony: Oh, and her review of King Crimson's Red too! That's one of her best written reviews as a whole.
Louis: Your thoughts on the editing and screenplay of Breaking the Waves?
Emi: Those are all good choices. I thought her recent videos on Phil Ochs and the Mountain Goats were great too. You watch any other YouTubers, esp. ones who discuss music or film?
Luke: What made you put Simon over Mifune in your last prediction?
Harris: Because I was kinda hoping he'd get his first five on the blog. But again Calvin's prediction changed that.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Louis: I've noticed that Tahmeed and Robert's predictions were put into spam.
Louis: From what I remember, at least 5 or 6 have been removed.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Samardžić
5. Bondarchuk
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Louis, your thoughts and rankings on the Emmy Nominees?
J96: The Daytime nominees were announced. The Primetime nominees which are the most relevant won't be announced until Tuesday.
1. Mifune
2. Wilson
3. Simon
4. Bondarchuk
5. Samardžić
Luke: I've noticed Mifune is already at a 5; is it the first instance of a performance already having that rating but not getting reviewed until later?
Tony: No, James Mason in Odd Man Out, Toshiro Mifune in Stray Dog and Timothy Spall in Secrets & Lies are a few examples.
1) Mifune
2) Wilson
3) Simon
4) Bondarchuk
5) Samardzic
Tony: Jeff Daniels was already Louis's win for 1993 before getting reviewed for Gettysburg as well.
Tony: James Woods in True Believer will probably get the same treatment once 1989 bonus round starts.
Robert Ryan in The Naked Spur and Lily Franky in Shoplifters
Well, that's more than I thought.
Regarding Superman:
Hated a few things, a couple Gunnisms (Jimmy being irresistible to women, using the Kents for laughs) and a fundamental choice around the El’s which I found fundamentally wrong for the character. But beyond that I really enjoyed this including Gunn’s “you know who Superman is” approach to just jumping into a world with Superman and superheroes and running with it. For plenty of entertainment in its high flying spectacle, and most of the humor worked for me despite those aforementioned bits. I’d say emotionally could’ve gone further, and one could nitpick around this quite a lot, however as a good superhero romp, I had a good time.
Corenswet - 3.5
Brosnahan - 3.5
Hoult - 4
Gathegi - 3.5
Fillion - 3
Merced - 2.5
Gisondo - 3.5
Sampaio - 2
Pierce - 2.5
Bennett - 2
Vince - 3.5
Howell - 2
de Faria - 2
Buric - 2
Calvin Law: Could I ask you for slightly more detailed thoughts on Bondarchuk in War and Peace Pt. IV?
Hey guys!
Tell us your ranks of 1967 nominees in each category:
Song
1. "The Bare Necessities" - The Jungle Book
2. "The Look of Love" - Casino Royale
3. "The Eyes of Love" - Banning
4. "Thoroughly Modern Millie" - Thoroughly Modern Millie
5. "Talk to the Animals" - Doctor Dolittle
Score (Adapted | Musical or Comedy)
1. Camelot
2. Valley of the Dolls
3. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
4. Thoroughly Modern Millie
5. Doctor Dolittle
Original Score
1. In Cold Blood
2. Cool Hand Luke
3. Far From the Madding Crowd
4. Thoroughly Modern Millie
5. Doctor Dolittle
Sound Mixing
1. In the Heat of the Night
2. The Dirty Dozen
3. Camelot
4. Thoroughly Modern Millie
5. Doctor Dolittle
Sound Editing
1. The Dirty Dozen
2. In the Heat of the Night
Editing
1. In the Heat of the Night
2. The Dirty Dozen
3. Beach Red
4. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
5. Doctor Dolittle
Visual Effects
1. Tobruk
2. Doctor Dolittle
Costume
1. Camelot
2. The Taming of the Shrew
3. Bonnie and Clyde
4. Thoroughly Modern Millie
5. The Happiest Millionaire
Production Design
1. Camelot
2. The Taming of the Shrew
3. Thoroughly Modern Millie
4. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
5. Doctor Dolittle
Cinematography
1. In Cold Blood
2. Bonnie and Clyde
3. The Graduate
4. Camelot
5. Doctor Dolittle
International Feature Film
1. Closely Watched Trains (Czechoslovakia)
2. Portrait of Chieko (Japan)
3. I Even Met Happy Gypsies (Yugoslavia)
4. Live for Life (France)
5. Bewitched Love (Spain)
Adapted Screenplay
1. The Graduate
2. In Cold Blood
3. In the Heat of the Night
4. Cool Hand Luke
5. Ulysses
Original Screenplay
1. Bonnie and Clyde
2. The War Is Over
3. Two for the Road
4. Divorce American Style
5. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
Supporting Actress
1. Katharine Ross
2. Mildred Natwick
3. Estelle Parsons
4. Carol Channing
5. Beah Richards
Supporting Actor
1. Gene Hackman
2. George Kennedy
3. Michael J. Pollard
4. John Cassavetes
5. Cecil Kellaway
Lead Actress
1. Anne Bancroft
2. Audrey Hepburn
3. Edith Evans
4. Faye Dunaway
5. Katharine Hepburn
Lead Actor
1. Rod Steiger
2. Paul Newman
3. Dustin Hoffman
4. Warren Beatty
5. Spencer Tracy
Director
1. Mike Nichols
2. Richard Brooks
3. Arthur Penn
4. Norman Jewison
5. Stanley Kramer
Picture
1. The Graduate
2. Bonnie and Clyde
3. In the Heat of the Night
4. Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
5. Doctor Dolittle
Harris: it's a good performance, I think he does well to sell the more general reactions to the state of his predicament and like the other films frames himself well within the spectacle, I just never got a super strong emotional response from him which I think the material has potential for (again, compared to say, Dano).
Pretty much echo Louis' Superman thoughts except I actually loved the El family choice, BUT I also completely understand hating it. Would go higher for Corenswet, and probably lower for Sampaio (who falters particularly if one compares to Valerie Perrine).
Ah no my mistake, I see she's a 2, that seems about right.
Louis: Thoughts on Howell?
Tony: some 2014 performances too. I believe Isaac, Oyelowo and Hardy(The Drop) were also 5s, in the 2014 comments section, but didn't get their review until 6 years later, I believe.
Perfectionist: Isaac and Tatum were the ones who were 5's and didn't get reviews at the time. Oyelowo was reviewed, and Hardy was a 4.5 for The Drop.
Robert: My bad, man.
Shaggy: I'm not the most well-watched with this year, so i'll leave some out
Sound Editing:
2) In the Heat of the Night
1) The Dirty Dozen
Sound Mixing:
3) Doctor Dolittle
2) In The Heat of the Night
1) The Dirty Dozen
Song:
2) Talk to the Animals
1) Bare Necessities
Original Score:
3) Doctor Dolittle
2) Cool Hand Luke
1) In Cold Blood
Editing:
4) Doctor Dolittle
3) Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
2) The Dirty Dozen
1) In the Heat of the Night
(this lineup is worth talking about more for what was not nominated)
Cinematography:
4) Doctor Dolittle
3) Bonnie and Clyde
2) The Graduate
1) In Cold Blood
Adapted Screenplay:
4) Cool Hand Luke
3) In the Heat of the Night
2) In Cold Blood
1) The Graduate
Original Screenplay:
2) Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
1) Bonnie and Clyde
Supporting Actress:
3) Beah Richards
2) Katherine Ross
1) Estelle Parsons
Supporting Actor:
5) Cecil Kellaway
4) John Cassavetes
3) Michael Pollard
2) George Kennedy
1) Gene Hackman
Lead Actress:
4) Katherine Hepburn
3) Audrey Hepburn
2) Faye Dunaway
1) Anne Bancroft
Lead Actor:
5) Spencer Tracy
4) Warren Beatty
3) Paul Newman
2) Dustin Hoffman
1) Rod Steiger
Director:
5) Stanley Kramer
4) Arthur Penn
3) Norman Jewison
2) Richard Brooks
1) Mike Nichols
(though 3 and 4 are kind of interchangeable)
Picture:
5) Doctor Dolittle
4) Guess Who's Coming to Dinner
3) In the Heat of the Night
2) Bonnie and Clyde
1) The Graduate
Calvin: Do you still stand by your previous prediction, at least for now?
Louis: To avoid spoilers, should we wait until later to ask for your thoughts on the Superman cast?
Superman is a lot of fun. Honestly I didn't even mind Gunn's bits or even the El family storyline, since I understand Gunn wanting to experiment and add an unusual element to characters whose purpose basically just boils down to bidding the titular character adieu.
Corenswet - 4
Borsnahan - 3.5
Hoult - 4
Gathegi - 3
Fillion - 3.5
Merced - 2.5
Gisondo - 2.5/3
Sampaio - 3.5
Pierce - 2.5
Bennett - 2
Vince - 3
Howell - 2.5
Faria - 3
Burić - 3 (ok look, as someone from a country that borders 2 irl equivalents of Boravia, I can easily understand his ferocious, yet moronic approach to this character)
Ah yes, I'd also throw in a 3 for Anthony Carrigan.
could any of the three men in Giant go up? I like Rock Hudson's turn more and more with every viewing
Post a Comment