Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2018: Results

10. Russell Hornsby in The Hate U Give - Hornsby gives a very strong performance realizing the intense determination of his character based around both his past hardships and his genuine love for his family.

Best Scene: How to behave when pulled over.

9. Peter Bogdonavich in The Other Side of the Wind - Bogdonavich's performance, 40 years in its making, is a surprisingly nuanced portrayal of the vulnerable ego of a man who built his own legacy by imitating his mentor.

Best Scene: Trying to tell Hanneford the truth.

8. Brian Tyree Henry in If Beale Street Could Talk - Henry gives the highlight of his banner year in his moving portrayal of essentially memory both those of a loving friendship and a harrowing traumatic experience.

Best Scene: His scene.

7. Alessandro Nivola in Disobedience - Nivola disappears into his role as one of the pillars of a Jewish community and gives a particularly powerful portrayal of a man coming to terms with his beliefs and how they relate to his friendship and his marriage.

Best Scene: "Choose"

6. Linus Roache in Mandy - Roache gives an amazing turn capturing both the hilarity and the horror of a wannabe prophet with severe delusions and pathetic desperation.

Best Scene:  Presenting himself.

5. Nicholas Hoult in The Favourite - Hoult once again is given a meaty role and once again makes the most of it in his masterful portrayal of a vicious wit and ambition.

Best Scene: Abigail's Offer.

4. Russell Crowe in Boy Erased - Crowe gives one of his best performances in his nuanced portrayal of a father failing then slowly learning to understand his homosexual son.

Best Scene: Ford Dealership.

3. Tom Waits in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs - Waits delivers a wonderful one man show that creates such an empathetic journey in one man's search for gold.

Best Scene: "You Didn't Hit Nothin' Important"

2. Steven Yeun in Burning - Yeun gives a masterful portrayal of an egotistical detachment that creates a most unnerving sort of possible evil.

Best Scene: Burning Greenhouses. 

1. Jeff Bridges in Bad Times At the El Royale - Good prediction Michael McCarthy, and AnonymousBridges takes the top spot overall for me as he delivers one of his best performances. This is giving a thoroughly engaging turn in giving so much life to every facet of his character from the various levels of the facade he puts on, the camaraderie he finds, and most of all his absolutely heartbreaking depiction of a man with dementia.

Best Scene: Describing his memory loss.

Overall Ranking:

1. Jeff Bridges in Bad Times At the El Royale
2. Steven Yeun in Burning
3. Tom Waits in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
4. Richard E. Grant in Can You Ever Forgive Me? 
5. Lewis Pullman in Bad Times At the El Royale
6. Russell Crowe in Boy Erased
7. Tim Blake Nelson in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
8. Nicholas Hoult in The Favourite
9. Linus Roache in Mandy
10. Lily Franky in Shoplifters
11. Bill Heck in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs - 4.5
12. Alessandro Nivola in Disobedience
13. Jonathan Pryce in The Man Who Killed Don Quixote
14. Harry Melling in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 
15. Jonjo O'Neill in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 
16. Grainger Hines in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
17. Brian Tyree Henry in If Beale Street Could Talk
18. Peter Bogdonavich in The Other Side of the Wind
19. Daniel Kaluuya in Widows 
20. Chris Hemsworth in Avengers: Infinity War 
21. Robert Forster in What They Had
22. Anton Yelchin in Thoroughbreds
23. Russell Hornsby in The Hate You Give 
24. Josh Brolin in Avenges: Infinity War
25. Michael B. Jordan in Black Panther
26. Jesse Plemons in Game Night - 4
27. Mark Rylance in Ready Player One
28. Riz Ahmed in The Sisters Brothers 
29. Kairi Jō in Shoplifters
30. Sam Elliott in A Star is Born 
31. Dolph Lundgren in Creed II
32. Florian Munteanu in Creed II
33. Josh Brolin in Deadpool 2
34. Josh Hamilton in Eighth Grade
35. James Smith in The Favourite
36. Brian Tyree Henry in Widows
37. Gabriel Byrne in Hereditary 
38. Liev Schreiber in Isle of Dogs
39. Sylvester Stallone in Creed II 
40. Tom Waits in The Old Man and the Gun
41. Sean Harris in Mission Impossible: Fallout
42. Armie Hammer in Sorry to Bother You 
43. Wyatt Russell in Overlord
44. Cameron Mitchell in The Other Side of the Wind
45. Richard Brake in Mandy 
46. Topher Grace in Blackkklansman 
47. Dave Bautista in Hotel Artemis
48. Ron Livingston in Tully 
49. Ben Whishaw in Mary Poppins Returns
50. Robert Downey Jr. in Avengers: Infinity War
51. Adam Driver in Blackkklansman
52. Jake Johnson in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse
53. Christian Slater in The Wife 
54. Matthew McConaughey in White Boy Rick 
55. Ed Helms in Chappaquiddick
56. Benedict Cumberbatch in Avengers: Infinity War
57. Harry Belafonte in Blackkklansman
58. Paul Bettany in Avengers: Infinity War
59. Joel Edgerton in Boy Erased - 3.5 
60. Sebastian Stan in Destroyer
61. Jake Gyllenhaal in Wild Life
62. Tom Holland in Avengers: Infinity War
63. Kyle Chandler in Game Night
64. Joe Alwyn in The Favourite
65. Sterling K. Brown in Black Panther
66. Mads Mikkelsen in At Eternity's Gate 
67. Bruno Ganz in The House That Jack Built
68. Jon Hamm in Bad Times At the El Royale
69. Steve Buscemi in Nancy 
70. Edoardo Pesce in Dogman
71. Masaharu Fukuyama  in Mirai
72. Michael Shannon in What They Had 
73. Bradley Cooper in Avengers: Infinity War
74. Bruce Dern in Chappaquiddick
75. F. Murray Abraham in Isle of Dogs
76. Lin Manuel Miranda in Mary Poppins Returns 
77. Henry Cavill in Mission Impossible: Fallout
78. Julian Dennison in Deadpool 2
79. Brendan Gleeson in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
80. Norman Foster in The Other Side of the Wind 
81. Edward Norton in Isle of Dogs
82. Jeff Goldblum in Isle of Dogs
83. Bill Murray in Isle of Dogs
84. Bob Balaban in Isle of Dogs
85. Chelcie Ross in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
86. Tom Vaughan-Lawlor in Avengers: Infinity War 
87. Andrew Dice Clay in A Star is Born 
88. Jude Law in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
89. Cedric the Entertainer in First Reformed
90. Anthony Welsh in Journeyman
91. Jason Clarke in First Man 
92. Brian Tyree Henry in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse 
93. Ben Mendelsohn in Ready Player One 
94. Bill Camp in Wild Life
95. Jasper Paakkonen in Blackkklansman
96. Paul Stewart in The Other Side of the Wind
97. Stephen Root in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 
98. Colin Farrell in Widows 
99. Dick Van Dyke in Mary Poppins Returns
100. Corey Hawkins in Blackkklansman
101. Stephen Dillane in The Outlaw King
102. Nicolas Cage in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse
103. James Franco in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 
104. Steven Yeun in Sorry to Bother You 
105. Simon Pegg in Mission Impossible: Fallout
106. Rob Delaney in Deadpool 2
107. Gregory Sierra in The Other Side of the Wind
108. Ned Dennehy in Mandy
109. Saul Rubinek in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
110. Noah Jupe in A Quiet Place
111. Paul Sparks in Thoroughbreds 
112. Joe Alwyn in Boy Erased 
113. Willie Watson in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs 
114. Mark Ruffalo in Avenges: Infinity War
115. Rupert Friend in At Eternity's Gate 
116. T.J. Miller in Deadpool 2 
117. Aaron Taylor-Johnson in Outlaw King
118. Colman Domingo in If Beale Street Could Talk 
119. Flea in Boy Erased 
120. Michael Beach in If Beale Street Could Talk  
121. Trevante Rhodes in Bird Box
122. Michael Douglas in Ant-Man and the Wasp 
123. J.K. Simmons in The Front Runner 
124. Jeff Goldblum in Hotel Artemis
125. Bill Duke in Mandy - 3
126. Rory Cochrane in White Boy Rick
127. Jeffrey Donovan in Sicario: Day of the Soldado
128. Tom Hiddleston in Avengers: Infinity War
129. Ving Rhames in Mission Impossible: Fallout
130. Tamuera Morrison in Aquaman 
131. Blake Jenner in American Animals
132. John Leguizamo in Nancy
133. Chris Evans in Avengers: Infinity War
134. Roland Møller in Papillon
135. Corey Stoll in First Man 
136. Winston Duke in Black Panther
137. Benedict Wong in Avengers: Infinity War
138. Dave Chappelle in A Star is Born 
139. Liev Schreiber in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse 
140. Kevin J. O'Connor in Widows 
141. Tom Hollander in A Private War
142. Dave Bautista in Avengers: Infinity War
143. Ted Danson in Hearts Beat Loud 
144. Steve Buscemi in Lean on Pete
145. Alfred Molina in The Front Runner
146. Edmond O'Brien in The Other Side of the Wind 
147. Lamorne Morris in Game Night 
148. Udo Kier in American Animals 
149. John Magaro in Overlord
150. Johnny Depp in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
151. John Mulaney in Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse 
152. Steve Zahn in Lean on Pete
153. Tom Hollander in Bird Box
154. Ryan Eggold in Blackkklansman
155. Pedro Pascal in If Beale Street Could Talk 
156. Mahershala Ali Spider-Man: Into the Spider-verse
157. Allan Corduner in Disobedience
158. Lukas Haas in Widows
159. Danny Glover in Sorry to Bother You
160. Pilou Asbaek in Overlord
161. Brad Bird in Incredibles 2
162. Liam Neeson in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs  
163. Travis Fimmel in Lean on Pete 
164. Sebastian Koch in Never Look Away
165. Chris Hemsworth in Bad Times At the El Royale
166. Tom Hollander in Bohemian Rhapsody
167. Alec Baldwin in Mission Impossible: Fallout
168. Harvey Keitel in Isle of Dogs
169. Paul Walter Hauser in Blackkklansman
170. Liam Neeson in Widows
171. Sebastian Stan in Avengers: Infinity War 
172. Jamie Dornan in A Private War
173. David Krumholtz in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs
174. Mark Gatiss in The Favourite
175. Woody Harrelson in Solo 
176. John Malkovich in Bird Box
177. Wood Harris in Creed II 
178. Yorick van Wageningen in Papillon
179. Clancy Brown in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs   
180. Algee Smith in The Hate U Give 
181. Chadwick Boseman in Avengers: Infinity War
182. Russell Hornsby in Creed II
183. Jon Øigarden in 22 July
184. Bruce Dern in White Boy Rick
185. Xavier Dolan in Boy Erased 
186. Garrett Dillahunt in Widows 
187. Alec Baldwin in Blackkklansman
188. Brian Tyree Henry in White Boy Rick
189. Billy Howle in Outlaw King
190. Joseph Mazzello in Bohemian Rhapsody
191. Stellan Skarsgard in The Man Who Killed Don Quixote
192. Sam Rockwell in Vice
193. David Kross in Sorry to Bother You 
194. Kyle Chandler in First Man
195. James LeGros in Support the Girls 
196. Danny Glover in The Old Man and the Gun
197. Gwilym Lee in Bohemian Rhapsody
198. Terry Crews in Sorry to Bother You
199. Forrest Whittaker in Black Panther
200. Billy Magnussen in Game Night
201. Walton Goggins in Ant-Man and the Wasp
202. Tyler Perry in Vice 
203. Courtney B. Vance in Ben is Back
204. Patton Oswalt in Sorry to Bother You 
205. Wayne Knight in Blindspotting
206. Colin Firth in Mary Poppins Returns
207. Mandy Patinkin in Life Itself 
208. Laurence Fishburne in Ant-Man and the Wasp
209. Jonah Hill in Don't Worry He Won't Get Far On Foot
210. Bob Odenkirk in Incredibles 2 
211. Ben Kingsley in Operation Finale
212. Don Cheadle in Avengers: Infinity War
213. Donald Glover in Solo
214. Clancy Brown in Chappaquiddick 
215. Jack Lowden in Mary Queen of Scots
216. John Cena in Bumblebee
217. Stacy Keach in Gotti
218. Benedict Wong in Annihilation -  2.5
219. Robert Duvall in Widows 
220. Willem Dafoe in Aquaman 
221. Will Patton in Halloween
222. Jude Law in Vox Lux
223. Joe Alwyn in Mary Queen of Scots
224. Nick Kroll in Operation Finale 
225. Timothy Hutton in Beautiful Boy 
226. Gen Hoshino in Mirai
227. Anthony Mackie in Avengers: Infinity War 
228. Jake Gyllenhaal in The Sisters Brothers
229. Henry Golding in A Simple Favor
230. Dan Fogler in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
231. Yahya Abdul-Manteen II in Aquaman 
232. Jim Gaffigan in Chappaquiddick
233. Jack Black in Don't Worry He Won't Get Far On Foot
234. Stanley Tucci in A Private War
235. Xavier Dolan in Bad Times At The El Royale
236. Ben Falcone in Can You Ever Forgive Me?
237. Bob Random in The Other Side of the Wind  
238. Daniel Kaluuya in Black Panther 
239. Ezra Miller in Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald
240. Mark Duplass in Tully
241. Jared Abrahamson in American Animals
242. Common in The Hate U Give
243. John Ortiz in Bumblebee
244. Ben Hardy in Bohemian Rhapsody
245. Paul Bettany in Solo
246. Dimitar Marinov in Green Book 
247. Andy Serkis in Black Panther
248. Chris Pratt in Avengers: Infinity War 
249. Patrick Wilson in Aquaman
250. Oscar Issac in At Eternity's Gate
251. Martin Freeman in Black Panther
252. Rufus Jones in Stan & Ollie
253. Dolph Lundgren in Aquaman
254. Dave Franco in If Beale Street Could Talk
255. Anthony Mackie in The Hate You Give  
256. Manuel Garcia-Rulfo in Sicario: Day of the Soldado 
257. Mamoudou Athie in The Front Runner
258. Aidan Gillen in Bohemian Rhapsody
259. K.J. Apa in The Hate U Give 
260. Antonio Banderas in Life Itself
261. Jorge Lendeborg Jr. in Bumblebee 
262. Danny Huston in Stan & Ollie - 2
263. James Cromwell in Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom 
264. Joe Alwyn in Operation Finale
265. Riz Ahmed in Venom
266. Steve Carell in Vice  
267. Ted Levine in Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
268. Guy Pearce in Mary Queen of Scots
269. Jimmy O. Yang in Crazy Rich Asians
270. David Gyasi in Annihilation
271. Toby Jones in Jurassic World: Fallen Kingdom
272. Michael Pena in Ant-Man and the Wasp
273. Justin Theroux in Mute
274. Ken Jeong in Crazy Rich Asians - 1.5
275. Jefferson Hall in Halloween
276. Alex Monner in Life Itself 
277. Allen Leech in Bohemian Rhapsody 
278. Haluk Bilginer in Halloween 
279. Benedict Hardie in Upgrade
280. Rafi Gavron in A Star is Born 
281. Harrison Gilbertson in Upgrade
282. David Tennant in Mary Queen of Scots
283. Charlie Day in Hotel Artemis
284. Max Irons in The Wife
285. Oscar Isaac in Life Itself
286. Harry Lloyd in The Wife
287. Oscar Isaac in Annihilation
288. Shea Whigham in Vice - 1
289. Spencer LoFranco in Gotti 
290. Jesse Plemons in Vice 
291. Mike Myers in Bohemian Rhapsody 
292. Justice Smith in Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom 
293. Toby Kebbell in Destroyer
294. Rafe Spall in Jurassic World Fallen Kingdom

Next: 2018 Lead

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2018: Peter Bogdanovich in The Other Side of the Wind

Peter Bogdanovich did not receive an Oscar nomination for portraying Brooks Otterlake in The Other Side of the Wind.

The Other Side of the Wind is the final, initially unfinished film, by brilliant egomaniac Orson Welles about a brilliant egomaniac, Jake Hanneford (John Huston), failing to finish his final film.

Keeping in mind that this synopsis that leads to a meta exploration of the nature of filmmakers,  their acolytes and film analysis, we have Peter Bogdanovich in the role of Brooks Otterlake, Brooks a former film critic/historian, protege of Hanneford turned commercially successful director, meanwhile Bogdanovich was a critic/historian, protege of Welles, turned commercially successful director. Bogdanovich obviously is not known as an actor, typically only featured in cameo roles, sometimes to his own detriment in the case of his work in his own film Targets. Bogdanovich in turn was not the original choice for this role, replacing impersonator Rich Little who originally played the role, for reasons that differ depending on the source, though if you've seen Little's impersonathan take on the Christmas Carol you'd probably say it is for the best. Bogdanovich was moved out of his original bit part as one of the interested cinefanatics, and instead was cast as a version himself, to the point Welles told him to evoke their relationship with his performance. This perhaps helped then in Bogdanovich gives a strangely far more committed work here than his nearly abysmal work in his own earlier film, of course the old hand wave of playing himself can be wrongly lobbed as always,  especially since what Bogdanovich gets at here is far more than a surface examination.

Although the film is ostensibly about Huston's Jake Hanneford you perhaps are granted a far more intimate insight into Brooks. This in part is helped from Bogdanovich giving the only bit of acting that is from beyond the original bursts of filming in the original production, this is through the opening introduction where Brooks offers the  introduction to the "documentary" to the viewer. Bogdanovich, though servicing a need to the film's introduction, doesn't cut short the character finding his delivery these years of exasperated pain in trying to uncover the exact truth of his old mentor though with a resignation in regards to letting his and Hanneford's legacy be as it may. In the actual film though we open up to a very different Brooks seemingly in his hay day having fun along with the large entourage of Hanneford. Bogdanovich carries himself magnificently as we see him in the initial press light portraying Brooks seemingly in his element of discussing Hanneford. Bogdanovich successfully delivers a unique charisma and confidence of these moments, with this just the right touch of smug assurance, as though he is the alpha dog, though of the hangerons. This though with the bright badge of honor of his success, which Bogdanovich carries with this casual calm, that he illustrates sometimes in an old Hollywood impersonation. Evidently this was Little's main approach in the part, playing each scene with a different accent which seems a touch broad, however Bogdanovich uses these rather brilliantly as these naturalistic little asides that suggest Brooks as he is so well into his element, but also an allusion to his state as essentially a living impersonation.

At the arrival to Jake's party, and where there will also be a rough cut showing of the film, we are given a series of circumstances that reveals every toxic interaction and relationship created by Hanneford over the years. This puts upon pressure on all specifically Brooks who is pushed by all including other filmmakers. Although we initially are granted Bogdanovich still carrying that certainty, with his delicious delivery of "Jake's surrounded by disciples, I'm the apostle" as this creed that grants a superiority well also is clever admission of the truth of the man. Bogdanovich is quite effective as he wears away, and he manages to convey this certain ease up of the excessive confidence. It rather becomes nearly this defense mechanism as he hears criticisms of himself as essentially a copy of Hanneford, and nothing but an imitator in the end. Bogdanovich is especially effective of this wearing away of the overly clever facade. This even in his brief, public, back and forth with Hanneford who makes many passive aggressive remarks to which Bogdanovich usually plays against an eye roll, though an eye roll that hides more than he initially lets on towards the nature of Brooks. One particularly remarkable moment in this is where he recommends, jokingly, to have a fight with one of his "critics". Bogdanovich delivers the recommendations of fisticuffs with a jovial spin, however now in his eyes bringing this greater desperation in the moment of actually having to defend his relationship with Jake beyond a certain point. Bogdanovich has a surprising depth in his work as he slowly dissolves the nature of Brooks in the progression of the night to essentially reveal a failure of Brooks. Bogdanovich is excellent in the way of playing around with the confidence, depending on the audience, showing the man trying to keep his pride, by making the act all the more pathetic as it goes on. This is until finally he essentially reveals himself fully in a private moment with Jake. All that bravado is gone as Bogdanovich plays the moment as essentially this quiet, even shy, little fanboy who is hesitant knowing his disappointment in the eyes of the mentor, as despite his success can't help him fund his film. Bogdanovich, despite being the last addition to the film, provides the most human element, even within his deeply flawed character. That is obviously not going to come from the delusional Hanneford, instead Bogdanovich surprises with his rich textured work of a man living his own delusion while still within the shadow of another. Bogdanovich, in his efforts to release Welles's final work director, actually helped to uncover an artifact of a greater ability as a performer, though perhaps that was because he uncovered a real pain within himself through this self-portrait of sorts.

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 2018

And the Nominees Were Not:

Tom Waits in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

Tim Blake Nelson in The Ballad of Buster Scruggs

Alessandro Nivola in Disobedience

Russell Hornsby in The Hate U Give

Nicholas Hoult in The Favourite

Peter Bogdanovich in The Other Side of the Wind

Predict those five or these five:

Jeff Bridges in Bad Times At the El Royale

Lewis Pullman in Bad Times At the El Royale

Linus Roache in Mandy

Steven Yeun in Burning

Brian Tyree Henry in If Beale Street Could Talk

Russell Crowe in Boy Erased 

Or Both, and for Prediction purposes:

Waits from Scruggs

Bridges from Bad Times