Tuesday, 3 January 2012

Best Supporting Actor 1959: Ed Wynn in The Diary of Anne Frank

Ed Wynn received his only Oscar nomination for portraying Albert Dussel in The Diary of Anne Frank.

The Diary of Anne Frank is an ensemble filmed caused by the fact that it is a group of character in their cramped hiding place trying to deal with each other. Only two were nominated from the ensemble though Shelley Winters in her Oscar winning role as Petronella Van Daan, and Ed Wynn as the dentist Albert Dussel who arrives later to join in their hiding place. Wynn's nomination probably was helped by the fact that Joseph Schildkraut, who gives the best performance in the film in my opinion, most likely suffered category confusion, and Wynn was likely helped by the fact that he plays against type.

Ed Wynn was best known for his comedic work, and it is almost rather hard to believe that one would ever expect for Wynn to play anything but comedy. This is because the fact that Wynn not only just naturally looks funny, but his voice has to be one of the funniest natural voices ever heard on film. Wynn though proves himself capable of giving a dramatic performance here, although it should be noted it is a dramatic performance with comedic undertones. Dussel is suppose to be just a normal man, but has just some rather fussy habits that the film attempts to derive humor from.

Ed Wynn actually is effective in his role though, even though it is most certainly limited by the very nature of the ensemble film. A funny thing about this performance actually is that Wynn seemed to have to tone down his voice and his face, since he stays mostly quiet in the film almost to prevent his comically sounding voice from coming out, as well his facial expressions are always withdrawn as well almost again to hide the fact that he just is rather funny looking when wide eyed. This is only really noticeable though if you have seen many of Ed Wynn's other performances, as I have, and Wynn actually does a good job of keeping realism in his performance as Dussel.

Ed Wynn best scenes though are his quietest ones especially his very first scene where he sadly tells of a list of many Jewish people who have been taken away by the Nazis. Wynn performance here is not overly emotional yet rather there is a haunting quality because he only sadly tells of the facts that cannot be ignored. Wynn never is nearly as effective as his initial scene as he becomes more of just part of the ensemble. Yet Wynn does not becomes forgotten in the rest, and still has a certain presence in their scenes even if it is less than say Winters or Schildkraut.

Wynn comes in and out of focus scenes with most small reactions that for the most part are appropriate. Really his less effective moments come in when he freaks out near the end of the film, only really because his voice comes out more, but still Wynn presents Dussel as a man honestly troubled by his terrible situation. Wynn casting though likely did come from the fact there is some humor involved with the part involved in just his fussiness. Wynn is able to add some humor, while still keeping it within the tone of the film. Wynn actually does add a nice presence to the film overall with his humor, and genuine emotions he does bring to the part. It is not the most memorable, or best performance in the film but it is a good one.

9 comments:

RatedRStar said...

I agree with you on Joseph Schildkraut =), not sure about Ed Wynn though I thought he was just ok and a bit overshadowed somewhat xx

dinasztie said...

I don't really remember him. :) But I saw Shelley's Oscar. :D I always say that in connection with this movie. LOL

I agree, though about Shildkraut.

Anonymous said...

Good performance and this is in my opinion the saddest film ever made, I couldn't stop crying at the end, and I've only cried with 6 films in my entire life.

Louis Morgan said...

I must agree it is extremely sad.

Anonymous said...

Hellο there, You hаve done an inсreԁible
job. I'll definitely digg it and personally suggest to my friends. I am confident they will be benefited from this site.

My web page; www.chaserpedia.com
Also see my web site: Read The Full Piece of writing

Anonymous said...

I've been browsing online more than 3 hours today, yet I never found any interesting article like yours. It'ѕ pгettу woгth enough for me.
Perѕonally, if all webmasters anԁ bloggeгѕ made good content as yοu ԁid,
the net will bе much more useful thаn ever befoгe.


Feel free to ѕurf to my wеb page: silkn sensepil

Lukas Miller said...

What did you think of Millie Perkins as Anne?

Louis Morgan said...

She was miscast and I feel she never overcame that. I still think she certainly tried very hard in the role and I do feel some of that does come across in a positive way.

Anonymous said...

When I originally commented I seem to have
clicked on the -Notify me when new comments are added-
checkbox and now whenever a comment is added I receive 4 emails with the same comment.
Perhaps there is a way you can remove me from that service?

Thanks!

Also visit my webpage: brookvale weight loss service