Sunday, 21 March 2021

Best Actor 2020: Steven Yeun in Minari

Steven Yeun received his first Oscar nomination for portraying Jacob Yi in Minari. 

Minari is a great film depicting a family of Korean immigrants trying to start a farm in Arkansas during the 1980's. 

Steven Yeun with this Oscar nomination makes academy history by becoming the first Korean and even first East Asian born actor to be nominated in this category. An achievement in itself, however also notable is the nature of this role, which is not the type frequently recognized by the academy, that of the introverted man. I'll admit I have a special appreciation for the successful depiction of introverts, because it is so frequently screwed up to become either just different quirky kind of extrovert or just plainly dull. A great introverted turn needs to to say so much in often so little. Now let's take Steven Yeun's performance here as the patriarch of the family, who we follow just as they've moved to Arkansas. Now from the outset this is just a performance that exudes authenticity as this Korean immigrant father. This as even his American accent that isn't at all like Yeun's actual accent, this as Jacob has a somewhat broken American accent. It is so naturally handled by Yeun in creating a sense of really the amount of time that Jacob has spent in America. This as he has a certain level of comfort in speaking English, yet clearly has only learned over the past few years. This flawless bit of establishing the history of the man though is really only the tip of the ice berg in his realization of this man. 

I think it is worth noting really how far away his presence here is actually from a lot of Yeun's recent work, such as his goofy yet endearing turns in Okja and Sorry To Bother You, or his criminally overlooked turn in Burning as a slick yet ambiguously sinister playboy. You can forget that entirely as Yeun exudes a entirely different presence here. This as there is an innate maturity here of a father just in the way he moves really, and just his manner within his family. Yeun has kind of the right almost wear, for the lack of a better word, in we can see the years of the family on him. This is not in a negative way, rather just that weight of responsibility is within Yeun's work. You never second guess him as the family man, he simply is this father here, and you feel the right connection within the family. I have to say it is here where you get the greatness of Yeun work in creating Jacob as this introvert, as we see him in different situations, rightly Yeun depicts very different sides to the man. I think it is important here that this isn't played by Yeun as different facades or anything like that, rather we see the different qualities the man needs to project depending where he is, or what it is that he has to do. 

Take Yeun's scenes where we see Jacob interacting with the local peoples, rather that is occasionally with slight social interaction or with some business in mind. In the former Yeun projects the man as being very closed off within his space. Yeun though is careful in this as he so naturally shows in this manner who just as a man who prefers to keep to himself and his family. There isn't a hostility within it, rather just almost a kind of solace of being apart, and being where he is most comfortable. When speaking to business arrangements Yeun projects more directly however within this Yeun presents a man very much doing what he has to in order to get what he needs for his farm. Yeun bringing the appropriate courtesy but still very much a distance in keeping it as businesslike as possible within the arrangement. There is a great touch in this with Jacob's interactions with a local man, who ends up working for him, Paul (Will Patton). Early on you have the same kind of passive distance in Yeun's delivery in their initial interaction. Afterwards, while I wouldn't quite say Yeun shows Jacob warming up to him, he brings such a natural slightly more open quality in his reactions. This in showing a bit more direct emotion and casual manner in his speaking towards the man, this opening up, not in the more obvious way, but in a way that is entirely befitting Jacob's more introverted style.  

This all though is in contrast with how Jacob is with his family, and in this we see so much of who the man is by how Yeun approaches these scenes opposed to those outside his homestead. Yeun is fantastic in naturally showing the other side to the man, not a as a different man, but that man being able to be himself. Although here we see how finely tuned Yeun is to this character by the way he differentiates his scenes with each family member, that grants more there than is even written. Take his relationship with his children particularly his son David (Alan Kim). This as Yeun brings so much warmth to the father in the moments of trying to excite the kids within their new surroundings. This is earnest as Yeun shows only a pure sense of the man trying to share his own excitement with them. In this though there is even the right playfulness in their interaction as a truly loving father, and you get a real sense of the family dynamic within this. There is wonderful moment early on with David where the two discover how to find water without hiring a water diviner. This is a pitch perfect scene for Yeun, as he brings a sense of fun in just the way he tries to prod his son to finding the solution. Then there is so much pride and love as his son seems to find the solution. The little asides about Koreans being smart, bring such an endearing quality as he shares his personal pride with his son with such authentic intimacy. It is worth noting though Yeun is just as convincing in disciplining his son. I love how direct and simple Yeun's delivery is in these moments, as a no nonsense, simple request for David "To find a stick". This also is no joke in Yeun's performance, rather he upfront shows Jacob will have no disrespect from his son. 

Now his relationship with his wife's mother (Youn Yuh-jung) and his wife Monica (Han Ye-ri), is really the crux to the brilliance of this performance. I love how it isn't said, however just from the performances you can sense that Jacob never entirely came to connect with his mother in law. This as just when Jacob speaks to her, and with her, it is only ever with a respectable distance. In that Yeun evokes no overt connection, but rather just doing what he should do as a proper son in law. Now with his relationship with Monica, I think this is where you know the film was made by an actual Korean, and because there is no outside looking in quality to this, this as they'll have the insight to depict a family, honestly, and well families don't always get along. There is so much here really to every interaction they have in creating their relationship. It really is outstanding work, because there is only really a few lines that speak directly to this, yet this is felt so clearly within their performance. This as we know the tension built from the move the family took away from the city and to this rural area. The opening where they come across the house, their separation is so well realized by both actors as we completely understand where each is coming from in this regard. This as Yeun shows such joy in seeing his new house, where his field will be, meanwhile Han shows the almost disgust at seeing essentially the trailer they will be staying at in the middle of nowhere. The moment even in getting in the house, Yeun shows the enthusiasm as Jacob tries to urge Monica in, while Monica pushes him away when refusing the help, which shows she doesn't really want any help from him at this point. The two's tension is really perfectly realized as you get the coldness presently from Monica to Jacob, however even in that you sense not strangers, but two people who were once so intimate being pulled apart by conflict.

What we get is a fantastic and so powerfully realized sense of their marriage that is on the border of breaking. What is so remarkable about this is as it is directly connected to Jacob's dream. Now to speak on the dream, we must see where Yeun is amazing in expressing such a genuine jubilation at the idea of it. When he speaks to wanting to grow Korean vegetables and sell them, he speaks with a explosive energy. He not only believes it, he wants to sell it to his whole family on the idea. There is such a potent passion within every moment reflecting this. This as he speaks to the need for the farm, Yeun emphasizes always this real personal enthusiasm that is of such a pure place in his heart. When we simply see Jacob plowing his field, the bliss on Yeun's face is amazing, as he expresses a man truly living his dream. What I then love is that we see really a struggle with dreams, which is the possible collateral damage of them. This is in his conflict with his wife, where Yeun presents the man who does put his dream first. This as when the whole family seems potentially in danger in a storm, Yeun still reacts with a pure optimism, which is true to Jacob at this point, while also shows that Jacob isn't being wholly sensitive to those who can't quite see his perspective. This isn't to say there is a simplification of the dream. In fact his connection with his wife is found within it. There is a great little moment early on between David and Jacob, where the former asks what happens to male chicks at a chicken farm after being separated from the females. As Jacob notes they're gotten rid of, he speaks towards the fact they best make themselves useful. Yeun emphasizes a weight into this line, and in that granting the responsibility within his dream to living up to this family. We see then as the farming isn't going perfectly, Yeun expresses powerfully the frustrations that grow. This so effectively in showing such a typically quiet man's frustrations that are so well portrayed by Yeun because he's yelling, you can always see him trying to hold himself back before getting caught up with the emotion again. It is not his nature to do so, but still shows such a man can be overwhelmed. There's an essential moment where after a rough day, Jacob finally speaks to understanding Monica's frustrations and why should could leave. Yeun's expression of this defeat is heartbreaking as there is such an honest desire to provide for his family within this moment of also trying to connect with his wife against as his dream begins to seem further out of reach. We see though in Yeun's work a persistence in himself to stay with his dream no matter what. It becomes a heartbreaking as Yeun expresses the tempered dream, this still a drive, but now with a sadness as though he may never be able to achieve it. The final fight between Jacob and Monica, is incredible acting by both Yeun and Han. They're work isn't about any overt rage, rather we just see so pointedly each person's point of view filtered between their long history. They fight having known each other for so long, having loved each other for so long, but now are at this point. This is a brilliant performance by Steven Yeun, as he always stays true to the quiet nature of his character, yet in that expresses still so much in crafting this powerful and vivid empathetic portrait of a man trying to achieve the American dream.

56 comments:

Tim said...

I just love the sight of that last sentence with Daniel Plainview underneath

Mitchell Murray said...

Yet another performance/film I'll be sure to check out. This is chalking up to be quite the field even with Oldman (who's still quite good).

Also, in reference to mine and Matt's comments about "Bon Cop, Bad Cop": Regardless of the quality of it's film, I would never request a performance I felt would be <3.5 (Huard's a 4 for me).

Calvin Law said...

I’m so glad you loved this performance as much as I did, and so correct that this is the type of performance they usually skip over (i.e. Gosling in First Man). This really is a transformative performance, and love your detail on that scene with David talking about the chicks, his lack of interactions with Soon-ja, and every scene with Han in itself is marvellous. I don’t think there’s a performance this year I’ve connected with as strongly as his.

Louis: your thoughts on the scene of Jacob crouching in the fields? That’s my favourite scene of the film, and I think the perfect combination of Yeun’s performance, Chung’s direction and Mosseri’s score.

Anonymous said...

And to think I was once in doubt that he would even be nominated.

Calvin Law said...

Anonymous: I remember the clamour initially about putting him in Lead, and to be fair history was against him. I applaud him and A24 for sticking with it though, it was a such a risky move (especially for a performance of this nature) and it paid off entirely.

Anonymous said...

Calvin: I meant that I remember when people were taking him off their predictions and replacing him with ahmed. Remember this was back when we thought Lindo was getting nominated.

Calvin Law said...

Anonymous: Oh yeah, I was still predicting him then, even after having seen the understated nature of the performance, assuming (against better judgement) an Oldman thinking two Asian actors being nominated was a distant dream. In an ideal world Oldman and Lindo would’ve switched places.

Anonymous said...

Yeah I really liked Oldman's performance but I would not have been upset about him not getting nominated. It is a really good performance but I could understand not nominating it.

Calvin Law said...

He’s good in it no doubt and it’s hard to hate on Oldman, especially with how long he went unrecognised by any major awards bodies, and just his general likability. And he’ll always have Tinker Tailor Soldier Spy as an inspired nod.

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Phenomenal performance by one of the best working today. It speaks to the strength of this lineup that he's "only" 4th for me, although a rewatch could definitely prop him up.

Calvin Law said...

I don’t think I’m alone in saying that this is an INCREDIBLY difficult year to rank this category and lineup. Not so much in terms of who one’s personal win is, but rather everyone who comes after.

Mitchell Murray said...

Calvin: I'll admit, I also find Oldman's nod for "Mank" interesting since it's almost a more straightforward leading turn compared to his other nominated work. Yes he's doing an accent, but you still recognize him as Oldman throughout unlike many of his films. This as both "TTSS" and "Darkest Hour" have very transformative work on his part - the former being a specifically taciturn portrayal of a literary figure, the other a more colourful depiction of a historical one.

Matt Mustin said...

Mitchell: I actually thought he disappeared much more in Mank than in Darkest Hour.

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Louis: Your thoughts on the scene where Monica washes Jacob's hair? I really loved that scene, as it was just such a moving display of their history together, alongside showing the fact that the tenderness hasn't entirely dissipated from their marriage.

Calvin Law said...

Mitchell: Agreed. It’s a traditional leading turn. In terms of transformative, Ahmed and Yeun fall into that category far more (the drumming, the physical transformation, the ASL and of course American accent for the former, the latter the accent, trying to nail the native Korean intonations and the whole physical aspect of the Korean appa).

Calvin Law said...

Tahmeed: The lighting in that scene is particularly beautiful too. Also love the choice to keep them at a certain distance before closing up on Han and Yeun’s faces.

Sorry for dominating so much conversation about this film, I just love it that much.

Luke Higham said...

Between 2nd and 4th, might come down to their best scenes.

And another amazing piece of work from Yeun.

Anonymous said...

Here is the annual business insider list of nominees that did not deserve it but this one is just ridiculous:https://www.insider.com/oscar-nominations-movies-celebrities-directors-dont-deserve-2021-3

Luke Higham said...

I guess they didn't watch The Father.

Anonymous said...

Louis: your top 10 yeun acting moments

Luke Higham said...

Your top 10 Ahmed moments

Anonymous said...

Whoever wrote that article obviously didn't see The Father. Also, it's not like Hopkins is nominated every year, he literally had a 23 year gap between last year and the nomination before that. I also guess they didn't see that he became the oldest Best Actor nominee, which is also a huge achievement for older actors.

Mitchell Murray said...

So this is quite random, but I watched Volume 1 of "RWBY" just now and...it was fine; Not really my thing, per say, but I do like some of the art style and music, and I can see why it's developed the fanbase it has.

Mitchell Murray said...

Also, in regards to that article, the only example I would vehemently agree with is Close; Cohen gave a good performance just like a lot of his co-stars, so I imagine people would have similar responses if anyone of them got nominated. And the argument against Hopkins might be convincing if Stanfield/Kaluuya we're totally ignored (Instead of just category frauded), or if his film/performance hadn't been received as fondly.

Thomas said...

Louis: Your rating and thoughts on Michael Sheen in The Damned United.

Luke Higham said...

Louis: I've noticed that he's a 4.5 now since he's above Hoffman, which I'm delighted with.

Louis Morgan said...

Calvin:

Don't apologize, love the enthusiasm.

That is great simple scene where we just see kind of the dejection in his face as he sees his dream slipping, beautifully shot at night with the score haunting as ever.

Tahmeed:

A fundamental scene, because it is indeed the only one where we see the true tenderness, even if still distant. Beautifully shot, but also just so quietly realized as this intimate moment between the two connecting to some degree. On that note, also love the moment of grandma commenting on their old love song which she speaks of fondly, while both of them are almost surprised to think of when they were still freshly in love.

Thomas:

I'm pretty sure I covered that before.

Anonymous & Luke:

I think I'll hold on a bit longer, for the sake of suspense.

Calvin Law said...

PYW for Original Screenplay!

Calvin Law said...

(at WGA)

And Borat for Adapted! Good choices for both.

Louis Morgan said...

Calvin:

Oscar next hopefully.

Calvin Law said...

Louis: Agreed. These were great winners, it helps give PYW momentum for that Screenplay Oscar and I’d dare say it also helps to solidify Nomadland as the frontrunner (PYW might just be our #2 now).

Louis Morgan said...

Calvin:

More than anything that hurts One Night in Miami's chances. Might be between Nomadland and The Father (which we need to remember way over-performed in nominations) at the Oscars.

Calvin Law said...

Louis: Agreed, The Father has a strong chance. I meant Nomadland as frontrunner for BP since it’s hard to imagine a universe where Chicago 7 wins Picture without Screenplay.

Psifonian said...

Louis is right. "One Night in Miami" is all but dead now in writing. Adapted will either go to "Nomadland" as the presumptive Best Picture, but there is a very strong chance "The Father" could spoil. It is the unknown quantity, and it could take BAFTA by storm. Plus it is a more traditional writing winner than "Nomadland," which I still think is the frontrunner here.

Sorkin's done. All Fennell really needs to worry about is a "Minari" peak.

Mitchell Murray said...

Random question for everyone here: What's a series or franchise that, in retrospect, you wish you got into earlier?

For me, "Airbender" is an easy answer since I watched it for the first time last September, but it would've loved it just as much when I was younger.

Aidan Pittman said...

Happy for PYW's WGA win, and I definitely agree with Louis that Adapted Screenplay is firmly between The Father and Nomadland at this point. Also think Borat's win is very good for Bakalova's chances in Supporting Actress, as she's already made it this far and the film has the necessary support. Unless she loses SAG I think she'll easily win.

Oh, and I also finally got around to Judas and the Black Messiah today, and my thoughts aren't that different from everyone else on here. A very good film but not quite the great one it could've been. I agree with Robert in that it could've been a great mini series, but as it is it is still good.

Stanfield - 5
Kaluuya - 5
Fishback - 4
Plemons - 3

Luke Higham said...

Mitchell: Line Of Duty which I first started watching in 2019. For franchises, none that I could think of because anything that was popular enough I would've seen within a year.

Luke Higham said...

Oh and I think Matt's answer to that question will be Lord Of The Rings.

Mitchell Murray said...

Luke: "Line Of Duty" most certainly looks good just from a cursory glance of it's cast.

I suppose many of the series I've been watching lately could also qualify IE "My Hero Academia" and "Yu Yu Hakusho", both of which I'm no doubt going to continue past their first seasons.

Louis Morgan said...

Calvin:

Agreed 100% on that point, picture is Nomadland's to lose at this point.

Tim said...

Mitchell: not a franchise, but a medium. Comic Books. I've only ever read some Batman Graphic Novels, starting last year and i am kind of hooked now. Informed myself about some other comics i might find interesting, and now i plan to go deeper into that rabbit hole. As a kid i was always scared and turned off by the sheer number of comic books existing and just not knowing about a place to start. So one could name non-movie Batman as such a franchise.

As for other franchises, i have never gotten around to watching Breaking Bad even though i always wanted too and intend to do that soon as it seems like i actually SHOULD like it for what i've heard

Mitchell Murray said...

On an additional note regarding "Airbender", has anyone here seen the follow up series "Legend of Korra"? And if so, is it worth watching by itself? I've heard and read reactions all across the spectrum, so I'm guessing it's at least different from ATLA in some metric.

Matt Mustin said...

Mitchell: Luke is right, LOTR for me for sure. I'm embarrassed at myself that I took so long.

Mitchell Murray said...

Tim: There are certainly some comic book stories I wouldn't mind checking out myself, such as "The Dark Knight Returns" or the "Immortal Hulk" series.

Mitchell Murray said...

Matt: Better late than never, right?

Tim said...

I have watched several episodes of the first season of Korra. From what i've gathered, the worldbuilding gets some intriguing new aspects, Korra herself as a character is fine, her two sidekicks can kiss my ass GOD WERE THOSE TWO DUDES ANNOYING!

Robert MacFarlane said...

Haven’t watched Korra, but a bit of trivia: When it aired, it had two Oscar nominees in the voice cast (Eva Marie Saint and Bruce Davidson). Since it aired, it’s had three more (J.K. Simmons, Rami Malek, Steven Yeun).

Michael Patison said...

Mitchell: Korra is great and I recommend it, but it is quite different from ATLA. Do not go into it expecting Last Airbender. As a counter to Tim, I'd argue that the 2 initial sidekicks are not annoying, especially not later on. Bolin, probably the more annoying of the 2, is no more annoying than Sokka was at the beginning of Avatar.

The steampunk aesthetic is a particular high point for me, but I also think the show's commentary on leading during crisis and handling a position of power in a world too often governed by fear are immensely powerful and prescient.

Mitchell Murray said...

Robert: I read that Davidson specifically voices and older Zuko which...is an interesting choice at least.

Michael: I've heard enough about it to know not to expect that. I will also say, that I'm very curious about Korra's setting: ATLA was unique in that it drew from very classic, pre-colonial Eastern imagery and teachings, as well as industrial machinery akin to the World Wars (Ex. The Fire Nation's airships). Given that Korra is set 70 years later, there are a number of possible sources and references they could incorporate further.

Emi Grant said...

Honestly, I have no clue of how Louis' ranking of the nominees will pan out now outside from Oldman being last, and to think we've still got Boseman and Hopkins' reviews to come.

Also, that article had me low-key fuming at the disrespect for The Father.

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Louis: Your thoughts on Minari's editing?

Tahmeed Chowdhury said...

Louis: What would you make of a South Korean remake of The Nice Guys with Yeun and Choi in Gosling and Crowe's roles?

Calvin Law said...

Add in Lee Byung-hun as John Boy and that is perfection. Directed by Kim Jee-woon, ideally.

Anonymous said...

If there was any remaining doubt about Carey mulligan winning actress and fennell winning screenplay they are likely gone now.

Anonymous said...

Louis: Your top ten favourite depictions of married couples in film, in terms of realism and quality of the performances.

Louis Morgan said...

Tahmeed:

Perfect casting.

Let me get to the rest of those thoughts on the next post.