Wednesday 2 March 2016

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1962: Results

5. Robert Duvall in To Kill a Mockingbird - Duvall gives a flawless performance that fully realizes his his pivotal character in a matter of 3 minutes.

Best Scene: His only scene. 
4. Lee Marvin in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance - Marvin gives a memorable villainous turn by being the absolute lout bully that Liberty Valance should be.

Best Scene: The duel. 
3. Tatsuya Nakadai in Sanjuro - Nakadai once again offers a worthy adversary for Toshiro Mifune's nameless samurai, but this time surprisingly strikes up a certain underlying connection between the foes.

Best Scene: The duel. 
2. Robert Ryan in Billy Budd - Ryan gives one of his best performances, giving a chilling portrayal of a sadist, but also manages to find the depth within what compels the man.

Best Scene: Billy tries to comfort Claggart. 
1. Peter Sellers in Lolita - Sellers gives an amazing performance as he's absolutely hilarious, but also manages to be surprisingly unnerving in the role at the same time.

Best Scene: Just a normal guy with a normal face.
7. Arthur Kennedy - Kennedy offers the needed two sides to his character the slightly shallow broadcaster, but as well the sardonic man who is well aware of what he is doing.

Best Scene: "I'll take your bloody picture"
6. Anthony Quayle - Quayle brings surprising depth to his role as he quietly portrays the affecting arc of his character, which is to fully understand who Lawrence really was.

Best Scene: The funeral. 
5. Anthony Quinn - Quinn gives an appropriately larger than life performance capturing the grandeur needed for the role, but importantly finds the right nuance when it is needed.

Best Scene: Tayi and Brighton.
4. Jack Hawkins - Hawkins naturally fulfills the role of the proper British General but goes further in his exploration of his character's relationship with Lawrence.

Best Scene: Allenby convinces Lawrence to take up the fight again.
3. Alec Guinness - As per usual Guinness gives strong work successfully disappearing into his role as well as giving a rather captivating portrait of a quiet yet powerful leader.

Best Scene: Faisal is interviewed.
2. Jose Ferrer - A brilliant one scene wonder as he completely realizes his character's disposition and finds the needed subtext of his scene through his performance.

Best Scene: His scene.
1. Claude Rains - Good predictions mcofra7, and Jackiboyz. Rains gives such an excellent performance as he does not waste a second in creating a fascinating depiction of a smooth political operator.

Best Scene: The ending.
Overall Rank:
  1. Peter Sellers in Lolita
  2. Robert Ryan in Billy Budd
  3. Omar Sharif in Lawrence of Arabia
  4. Claude Rains in Lawrence of Arabia
  5. Tatsuya Nakadai in Sanjuro 
  6. Lee Marvin in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  7. Jose Ferrer in Lawrence of Arabia
  8. Brock Peters in To Kill a Mockingbird
  9. Alec Guinness in Lawrence of Arabia
  10. Robert Duvall in To Kill a Mockingbird
  11. Jack Hawkins in Lawrence of Arabia
  12. Charles Bickford in Days of Wine and Roses 
  13. Burgess Meredith in Advise & Consent
  14. Ed Begley in Sweet Bird of Youth 
  15. James Gregory in The Manchurian Candidate
  16. Anthony Quinn in Lawrence of Arabia
  17. Melvyn Douglas in Billy Budd
  18. Anthony Quayle in Lawrence of Arabia 
  19. Charles Laughton in Advise & Consent
  20. Karl Malden in Birdman of Alcatraz
  21. Lee Montague in Billy Budd
  22. Arthur Kennedy in Lawrence of Arabia
  23. Lew Ayres in Advise & Consent
  24. Frank Overton in To Kill a Mockingbird
  25. Joseph Wiseman in Dr. No 
  26. David McCallum in Freud
  27. Richard Harris in Mutiny on the Bounty  
  28. Woody Strode in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance 
  29. Richard Attenborough in All Night Long 
  30. Henry Fonda in Advise & Consent
  31. John McGiver in The Manchurian Candidate
  32. Jack Klugman in Days of Wine and Roses
  33. Rentaro Mikuni in Harakiri
  34. David McCallum in Billy Budd
  35. Edmond O'Brien in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  36. Michael Redgrave in The Loneliness of the Long Distance Runner
  37. Khigh Dheigh in The Manchurian Candidate
  38. Paul Rogers in Billy Budd
  39. Victor Buono in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? 
  40. Akira Ishihama in Harakiri
  41. Walter Pidgeon in Advise & Consent
  42. Robert Brown in Billy Budd
  43. Gary Cockrell in Lolita
  44. John Carradine in The Man Who Shot Liberty Valance
  45. Yuzo Kayama in Sanjuro
  46. John Neville in Billy Budd
  47. Jack Kruschen in Cape Fear
  48. John Megna in To Kill a Mockingbird 
  49. Buddy Hackett in The Music Man 
  50. Telly Savalas in Cape Fear
  51. Andy Devine in The Man Who Liberty Valance 
  52. Martin Balsam in Cape Fear
  53. Rip Torn in Sweet Bird of Youth 
  54. Takashi Shimura in Sanjuro
  55. Hugh Griffith in Mutiny on the Bounty
  56. James Anderson in To Kill a Mockingbird
  57. Andrew Prine in The Miracle Worker
  58. Paul Fix in To Kill a Mockingbird
  59. Larry Parks in Freud
  60. Wesley Addy in What Ever Happened to Baby Jane? 
  61. Telly Savalas in Birdman of Alcatraz
  62. Don Murray in Advise & Consent
  63. Edmond O'Brien in Birdman of Alcatraz 
  64. Henry Silva in The Manchurian Candidate
  65. Victor Jory in The Miracle Worker
  66. Jack Lord in Dr. No
  67. Ron Howard in The Music Man
  68. Keith Mitchell in All Night Long
Next Year: 1939 Lead

28 comments:

Luke Higham said...

Louis: Rating & Thoughts on Charles Bickford in Days Of Wine And Roses.

Luke Higham said...

Laughton - The Hunchback Of Notre Dame
Fonda - Young Mr. Lincoln
Cagney - The Roaring Twenties
Wayne - Stagecoach
Karloff - Son Of Frankenstein Or Rathbone - The Hound Of The Baskervilles

GM said...

Charles Laughton - The Hunchback Of Notre Dame
Conrad Veidt - The Spy In Black
Edward G. Robinson - Confessions of a Nazi Spy
James Cagney - The Roaring Twenties
Jean Gabin - Le jour se lève
John Wayne - Stagecoach
Michel Simon - The End of the Day
Basil Rathbone - The Hound of the Baskervilles
Cary Grant - Only Angels Have Wings
Henry Fonda - Young Mr. Lincoln

Anonymous said...

Charles Laughton in The Hunchback Of Notre Dame
Henry Fonda in Young Mr. Lincoln
James Cagney in The Roaring Twenties
John Wayne in Stagecoach
Cary Grant in Only Angels Have Wings or Boris Karloff in Son of Frankenstein

Calvin Law said...

Laughton
Cagney
Rathbone
Fonda
Veidt

Louis: with regards to The Crying Game, have your thoughts on Stephen Rea's lead performance changed? On re-watch I love the film more and and more and also his performance, I would recommend giving it another go and just examining the subtle little things he does with his portrayal of a good man discovering in himself that goodness.

Calvin Law said...

I do think that Jaye Davidson is a bit overpraised, although I like his performance well enough, and that Miranda Richardson is underpraised.

RatedRStar said...

Charles Laughton - The Hunchback Of Notre Dame
John Wayne - Stagecoach
Henry Fonda - Young Mr Lincoln
Basil Rathbone - Hound Of The Baskervilles
James Cagney - The Roaring Twenties
Jean Gabin - Daybreak
Cary Grant - Only Angels Have Wings
Conrad Veidt - The Spy In Black
James Stewart - Destry Rides Again
William Powell - Another Thin Man

Alex Marqués said...

Glad to see Sellers winning

mcofra7 said...

Yeah, that was unexpected but a nice surprise. It's funny that I guessed correctly as I've never actually seen Lawrence of Arabia.

Anonymous said...

Louis: What is your rating and thoughts on Edward Arnold in Mr. Smith Goes To Washington?

Michael McCarthy said...

I'd vote for Gabin, Laughton, and Robinson. Idk who else.

JackiBoyz said...

My winning request is a very disturbing performance in a gruesome film, Anthony Wong in The Untold Story.

Michael Patison said...

For 1939 Lead (alphabetically):
James Cagney in The Roaring Twenties
Henry Fonda in Young Mr. Lincoln
John Garfield in They Made Me a Criminal
Cary Grant in Only Angels Have Wings
William Holden in Golden Boy
Leslie Howard in Intermezzo
Charles Laughton in The Hunchback of Notre Dame
Basil Rathbone in The Hound of the Baskervilles
Ralph Richardson in The Four Feathers
Edward G. Robinson in Confessions of a Nazi Spy
James Stewart in Destry Rides Again
Conrad Veidt in The Spy in Black
John Wayne in Stagecoach

Anonymous said...

I think Richardson is supporting.

Alex Marqués said...

What's everyone's list of 90's lead winners?

Luke Higham said...

Alex:
1990: Rooker
1991: Turturro
1992: Keitel
1993: Douglas
1994: Robbins
1995: McKellen
1996: Branagh
1997: Winstone
1998: Gleeson
1999: Farnsworth

Michael Patison said...

Alex:
1990: Gabriel Byrne
1991: John Turturro
1992: Clint Eastwood
1993: Liam Neeson
1994: Tim Robbins
1995: Morgan Freeman
1996: William H. Macy
1997: Guy Pearce
1998: Edward Norton
1999: Richard Farnsworth

Michael Patison said...

In case anybody is curious, way back when the alternate years started however many years ago, I documented all of the top 10s and then awarded actors points based on their ranking in each top 10, from 10 for 1st down to 1 for 10th. Again, if you're interested, the top 10 in points going into the final year (which has the potential, but is not guaranteed, to change this ranking) are:
1. Toshiro Mifune (no surprises there) with 153 points from 23 nominations
2. James Mason with 112 points from 18 nominations
3. James Stewart with 103 points from 19 nominations
4. Claude Rains with 98 points from 18 nominations
5. Gene Hackman with 97 points from 14 nominations
6. Laurence Olivier with 95 points from 14 nominations
7. Alec Guinness with 88 points from 15 nominations
8. Jack Nicholson with 76 points from 10 nominations
9. Richard Attenborough with 72 points from 11 nominations
10. Tatsuya Nakadai with 69 points from 10 nominations

If there's any random statistic you want to know, like maybe who has the most 10th place finishes or how many different actors have been in a top 10 (it's Burt Lancaster and 717), just ask. I may very well have it.

Robert MacFarlane said...

Alex:

1990: James Caan
1991: Anthony Hopkins
1992: Jack Lemmon
1993: Daniel Day-Lewis
1994: Samuel L. Jackson
1995: Morgan Freeman
1996: William H. Macy
1997: Al Pacino
1998: Edward Norton
1999: Russell Crowe

Anonymous said...

Alex´
1990: Ray Liotta
1991: John Turturro
1992: Harvey Keitel
1993: Michael Douglas
1994: Gary Oldman
1995: Morgan Freeman
1996: William H. Macy
1997: Guy Pearce and Russell Crowe (TIE)
1998: Edward Norton
1999: Richard Farnsworth

mcofra7 said...

Request: Robert Downey Jr in Less Than Zero

Robert MacFarlane said...

That's not a bad request. Even if Louis doesn't think he's great in it, it's certainly an interesting performance to review since that was where the Downey screen persona truly started.

mcofra7 said...

Unfortunately, it's not a good movie. I enjoyed both Downey and Spader, though.

Robert MacFarlane said...

Oh yes, it's a lame after school special, though I get some schadenfreude out of seeing any book by that hack Bret Easton Ellis turned into one. Seriously, fuck that guy.

Calvin Law said...

1990: Depp
1991: Hopkins
1992: Rea
1993: Daniels
1994: Robbins
1995: McKellen
1996: Branagh
1997: Holm
1998: Norton
1999: Crowe

Calvin Law said...

Actually, no, Hopkins for 1993 too (no, really)

mcofra7 said...

From what I've seen:
1990: Liotta
1991: Hopkins
1992: Eastwood
1993: Murray
1994: Robbins
1995: Freeman
1996: Macy
1997: Hall
1998: Bridges
1999: Norton

Louis Morgan said...

Luke:

Bickford - 4(Again he works best with actually more emotional roles. He's really good here as that colder side of Bickford is evident here in the general demeanor of the character, yet the way he quietly reveals the vulnerabilities of his character and how much he cares for his daughter are all the more moving to reveal it within his harden hide)

Calvin:

Probably, should give it another go.

Anonymous:

Hold that thought for the moment.