Thursday, 8 November 2012

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1954

And the Nominees Were Not:

Peter Lorre in 20,000 Leagues Under the Sea

Raymond Burr in Rear Window

Clifton Webb in Three Coins in The Fountain

Van Johnson in The Caine Mutiny

Fred MacMurray in The Caine Mutiny


Michael Patison said...

Interesting field here. I'll take a stab:
1. Peter Lorre
2. Van Johnson
3. Fred MacMurray
4. Raymond Burr
5. Clifton Webb

Mark said...

1. Burr
2. Johnson
3. Webb
4. MacMurray
5. Lorre

Maciej said...


Lezlie said...

1. Van Johnson
2. Raymond Burr
3. Peter Lorre
4. Fred MacMurray
5. Clifton Webb

Fritz said...

I've only seen Burr who was effective but hardly Oscar-worthy...

RatedRStar said...

Ive seen all 5 ( of course as I requested all 5 of these =D) =D, Burr was good but as Fritz said, he wasnt a 5 star performance in my opinion, Johnson was great, Murray was fine but not as good, Webb was his usual which in my opinion is good, he comes close to being co lead, Lorre is just adorable =D

1.Van Johnson
2.Peter Lorre
3.Raymond Burr
4.Fred MacMurray
5.Clifton Webb

RatedRStar said...

yay Peter Lorre has finally recieved an Oscar Nomination =D =D

koook160 (Robert MacFarlane) said...

My guess:

1. Webb
2. Burr
3. Johnson
4. Lorre
5. MacMurray

moviefilm said...

1) Raymond Burr
2) Peter Lorre
3) Fred MacMurray
4) Van Johnson
5) Clifton Webb

RatedRStar said...

this is a very interesting line up lol, there doesnt seem to be a clear favorite compared to most of the other years.

I think the performance that is the key is whether ull like Webb in Three Coins In The Fountain, as the other 4 im sure ull like.