Thursday 18 October 2012

Alternate Best Supporting Actor 1960: Results

5. Gene Kelly in Inherit the Wind- Kelly plays with his type once again playing a loud showman, but this time with a deep rooted cynicism.

Best Scene: E.K. Hornbeck's cynicism is questioned by Drummond. 
4. Charles Laughton in Spartacus- Laughton gives a nice enjoyable performance that creates a believable portrait of a politician who uses quiet methods of persuasion.

Best Scene: Gracchus shares a meal with  Lentulus Batiatus.
3. Fred MacMurray in The Apartment- MacMurray is quite good in role giving a commanding presence that revels to just the right degree in his character immorality.

Best Scene: Sheldrake tries to bribe Baxter one more time. 
2. Laurence Olivier in Spartacus- Olivier as usual gives a great performance here as the main villain of the film. He is effectively a tremendous force of evil, but as well still creates a three dimensional character out of the tyrant that is his character.

Best Scene: Crassus tries to understand Varinia's love for Spartacus.
1. Eli Wallach in The Magnificent Seven- This was a very close one for me, and yes I was ready to give Olivier by lead and supporting for this year. Wallach though is equally excellent in his role in the Magnificent Seven, and manages to do basically anything he possibly could with his role. Even with his role being very limited Wallach never makes it feel that way giving an extremely entertaining as well as being appropriately menacing as well.

Best Scene: Calvera's introduction. 
Overall Rank:
  1. Eli Wallach in The Magnificent Seven
  2. Laurence Olivier in Spartacus
  3. Peter Sellers in Never Let Go
  4. Peter Falk in Murder, Inc.
  5. Peter Ustinov in Spartacus
  6. John Mills in Tunes of Glory
  7. Masayuki Mori in When a Woman Ascends the Stairs
  8. Masayuki Mori in The Bad Sleep Well  
  9. Robert Mitchum in Home From the Hill
  10. Fred MacMurray in The Apartment
  11. Shin Saburi in Late Autumn
  12. Ryuji Kita in Late Autumn
  13. Nabuo Nakamura in Late Autumn
  14. Steve McQueen in The Magnificent Seven
  15. James Coburn in The Magnificent Seven
  16. Peter Ustinov in The Sundowners
  17. Roger Livesey in The Entertainer
  18. Takeshi Kato in The Bad Sleep Well
  19. Charles Laughton in Spartacus
  20. Sal Mineo in Exodus
  21. Tatsuya Nakadai in When a Woman Ascends the Stairs
  22. Martin Stephens in The Village of the Damned
  23. James Mason in The Trials of Oscar Wilde
  24. Ralph Richardson in Oscar Wilde
  25. Woody Strode in Spartacus 
  26. Michael Craig in The Angry Silence 
  27. Richard Attenborough in The League of Gentlemen 
  28. Max Cartier in Rocco and His Brothers
  29. Spiros Focas in Rocco and Brothers
  30. Tatsuya Mihashi in The Bad Sleep Well 
  31. Alan Bates in The Entertainer 
  32. Bryan Forbes in The League of Gentlemen
  33. Geoffrey Keen in The Angry Silence 
  34. Roger Livesey in The League of Gentlemen 
  35. Jack Nicholson in The Little Shop of Horrors
  36. Gene Kelly in Inherit the Wind
  37. Arthur Kennedy in Elmer Gantry 
  38. Nigel Patrick in The League of Gentlemen
  39. Martin Balsam in Psycho 
  40. Bernard Lee in The Angry Silence 
  41. Daisuke Kato in When a Woman Ascends the Stairs
  42. Takashi Shimura in The Bad Sleep Well
  43. Trevor Howard in Sons and Lovers
  44. Paolo Stoppa in Rocco and his Brothers
  45. Robert Coote in The League of Gentlemen
  46. Hume Cronyn in Sunrise at Campobello
  47. Herbert Lom in Spartacus
  48. Jack Kruschen in The Apartment 
  49. Norman Bird in The League of Gentlemen
  50. Maurice Ronet in Purple Noon
  51. Ray Walston in The Apartment 
  52. John Mills in Swiss Family Robinson 
  53. Ed Wynn in Cinderfella
  54. Dennis Price in Tunes of Glory 
  55. Michael Gwynn in Village of the Damned
  56. Harry Morgan in Inherit the Wind 
  57. Brad Dexter in The Magnificent Seven
  58. David Lewis in The Apartment
  59. Albert Finney in The Entertainer
  60. Richard Conte in Ocean's Eleven
  61. Adam Faith in Never Let Go
  62. Andre Checchi in Black Sunday 
  63. Laurence Harvey in The Alamo
  64. Charles Bronson in The Magnificent Seven 
  65. John Neville in Oscar Wilde
  66. Laurence Naismith in Village of the Damned
  67. Tony Curtis in Spartacus
  68. Richard Widmark in The Alamo 
  69. Robert Vaughn in The Magnificent Seven 
  70. Dick York in Inherit the Wind
  71. John Wayne in The Alamo
  72. Alan Young in The Time Machine 
  73. Alexandre Rignault in Eyes Without a Face 
  74. Billie Kearns in Purple Noon
  75. Dennis Weaver in The Gallant Hours
  76. Miles Malleson in Peeping Tom
  77. Katamari Fujimara in The Bad Sleep Well 
  78. Ivo Garrani in Black Sunday 
  79. Joseph Wiseman in The Unforgiven 
  80. Cesar Romero in Ocean's Eleven  
  81. Cecil Parker in Swiss family Robinson
  82. John Fraser in The Trials of Oscar Wilde
  83. Francois Guerin in Eyes Without A Face 
  84. Nigel Davenport in Peeping Tom 
  85. George Peppard in Home from the Hill
  86. Albert Salmi in The Unforgiven
  87. Horst Buchholz in The Magnificent Seven
  88. Ko Nishimura in The Bad Sleep Well 
  89. Everett Sloane in Home from the Hill
  90. Charles Bickford in The Unforgiven
  91. John Dall in Spartacus
  92. Dean Jagger in Elmer Gantry
  93. Sammy Davis Jr. in Ocean's Eleven
  94. Dean Martin in Ocean's Eleven 
  95. Edward Chapman in Oscar Wilde
  96. Michael Anderson in The Sundowners
  97. Akim Tamrioff in Ocean's Eleven 
  98. Sessue Hayakawa in Swiss Family Robinson
  99. Chill Wills in The Alamo
  100. John Ireland in Spartacus
  101. John Gavin in Psycho
  102. John Gavin in Spartacus
  103. Kevin Corcoran in Swiss Family Robinson 
  104. Paul Lukather in Dinosaurus!
  105. Claude Akins in Inherit the Wind
  106. Vladimir Sokoloff in The Magnificent Seven
  107. Alan Roberts in Dinosaurus!
  108. The Rest of the Villagers in The Magnificent Seven
Next Year: 1999 Supporting 

8 comments:

Robert MacFarlane said...

Please, please, PLEASE review Phillip Baker Hall in Magnolia for 1999. He was my favorite performance in that film, which is saying something considering the across the board acting.

RatedRStar said...

Philip Seymour Hoffman - Magnolia
Philip Baker Hall - Magnolia
Alan Rickman - Galaxy Quest
Philip Seymour Hoffman - The Talented Mr Ripley
Laurence Fishbourne - The Matrix
Hugo Weaving - The Matrix


I thought Christopher Plummer was overated ( and an overated actor in general).

Robert MacFarlane said...

Well, if you wanted to go with the ones generally considered the "snubs" that year, these seemed to be the most highly regarded:

Peter Sarsgaard in Boys Don't Cry
Philip Baker Hall in Magnolia
Christopher Plummer in The Insider
John Malkovich in Being John Malkovich
Pretty Much every other guy in Magnolia

Also, for all that is holy, don't put Pitt in Fight Club as supporting. Tyler Durden has too much screen time and essentially is the only thing that keeps the plot moving by the end.

RatedRStar said...

Actually Sarsgaard would be a great choice since he plays a truly detestable character =D

Maciej said...

Philip Baker Hall - Magnolia
Christopher Plummer - The Insider
Chris Cooper - American Beauty
Rhys Ifans - Notting Hill
John Malkovich - Being John Malkovich

Paoloduncan said...

Hugo Weaving - The Matrix
Christopher Plummer - The Insider
Laurence Fishbourne - The Matrix
Chris Cooper - American Beauty
Philip Baker Hall - Magnolia
Heath Ledger - 10 Things I Hate About You

Anonymous said...

Suggestions:
Chris Cooper in American Beauty
Philip Seymour Hoffman in Magnolia
Christopher Plummer in The Insider
William H. Macy in Magnolia
Alan Rickman in Galaxy Quest

Michael Patison said...

So excited to see Eli Wallach as your top choice.

As for 1999, I'll recommend, in addition to Fishburne in The Matrix:
Chris Cooper in American Beauty
Philip Baker Hall in Magnolia
Philip Seymour Hoffman in Magnolia
Christopher Plummer in The Insider
Alan Rickman in Galaxy Quest
Timothy Spall in Topsy-Turvy